Activity coefficients for sodium chloride at 0.1 M ionic strength

4 replies · 2K views · last reply
Yokoko
Messages
15
Reaction score
1
Homework Statement
I've had a go at these but am unsure about the result. I thought the values would have to be closer to each other.
Relevant Equations
See picture
Typed worked solution calculating the activity coefficient for CaSO4 solubility: experimental gamma = sqrt(3.74 x 10^-5)/0.0154 = 0.40, and theoretical log gamma from the Debye-Huckel limiting law with ionic strength 0.0308 M giving 0.61.
 
You have not calculated I correctly. I (not √I) = 1/2∑cz2 for ALL ions present.
Then you haven't used your calculated value for I in the equation for logγ. You used c. Why?
(Do it correctly, and it does come out close to the experimental value.)
 
Handwritten worked calculation on a screen: Ks = s^2 gamma^2 for the experimental activity coefficient of 0.40, theoretical ionic strength I = 0.07 for KNO3 and I = 0.25 for CaSO4, combined I = 0.32, and log gamma = 0.24 from the Debye-Huckel expression.

Thanks for your answer. Again, I'm not sure if I understood this correctly.

I used c as I thought s = c for simple ions. I now took the root of √I to get I.

I assumed the C for KNO3 = 0.0050 and C for CaSO4 = s = 0.0154

This might be where I am wrong?
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten worked calculation of activity coefficient for CaSO4 and KNO3 solutions, showing K_s = s^2 gamma^2, gamma = sqrt(K_s)/s = 0.40, and ionic strength values I = 0.07 for KNO3 and I = 0.25 for CaSO4.
    IMG_20201026_110647.jpg
    66.4 KB · Views: 239
No! 1/2Σcz2 is I, not √I, as I said before. (What are the units?) I = 0.0666M.
 
Oops thanks, I misread your earlier message.
With I = 0.0666 I get an overall value of 0.41 which fits.

Thanks again!