Alonso & Finn Physics Books: Where to find?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the availability and necessity of the Alonso & Finn physics books, which are noted for their educational value but are also described as old and potentially out-of-print. Participants explore various avenues for obtaining these books, including online bookstores and alternative resources, while also expressing concerns about their use in current academic curricula.

Discussion Character

  • Debate/contested
  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Homework-related

Main Points Raised

  • One participant mentions difficulty finding the Alonso & Finn books online, particularly in Europe, and questions whether there are more than three volumes.
  • Several participants confirm that Amazon lists the books but note their high prices, with one suggesting that prices exceed $250 per book.
  • Alternative suggestions include using Bookfinder.com, which some participants claim can locate cheaper copies ranging from $30 to $70 per volume.
  • Concerns are raised about the appropriateness of requiring old, potentially out-of-print books for current courses, with some participants questioning the professor's rationale.
  • One participant shares their experience of struggling to find the books and expresses frustration with the curriculum's reliance on outdated materials.
  • Another participant describes the unique qualities of the Alonso & Finn books, highlighting their mathematical clarity and pedagogical approach compared to other introductory texts.
  • There are discussions about the potential for substituting other texts or resources, given the similarities among introductory physics books.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a mix of agreement and disagreement regarding the necessity and availability of the Alonso & Finn books. While some suggest alternatives and express skepticism about the curriculum, others defend the books' educational merits and share personal experiences related to their acquisition.

Contextual Notes

Participants note the challenges of sourcing older textbooks, the implications of curriculum requirements, and the potential for copyright issues related to using outdated materials. There is also mention of the limited availability of resources in certain regions.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be of interest to students seeking specific physics textbooks, educators considering curriculum materials, and individuals exploring alternative resources for physics education.

Const@ntine
Messages
285
Reaction score
18
Good evening (or, technically, morning, depending on where you are and all that jazz)! Recently a professor of ours told us to look into those books; they're three volumes as far as I'm aware. Thing is, as you probably all know (I mean, they're pretty famous, certainly no indie darlings), they're rather old. I searched around a bit, and got a taste of the prices and whatnot, but apart from Amazon, I cannot find any online bookstore that carries them. "Well blimey, just buy them from there" you might say, but Amazon doesn't always ship worldwide, and residing in Europe I'm in a bit of a... predicament.

So, my question would be; do you have any links to any bookstores that carry these? Are there only three volumes, or more? What about that "Physics" book; is that required reading too? I'm in my second year of Physics, but I've kinda, sorta, lost my track a bit (you get sick for a month, you lose a semester and bam! you're pinned to the ground...), and I figured these would help me get back on the saddle, so to speak.

Thank you for your time.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Check amazon, I’ve seen them listed there but their kind of pricey at over $250 per book.
 
  • Wow
Likes   Reactions: pinball1970
jedishrfu said:
Check amazon, I’ve seen them listed there but their kind of pricey at over $250 per book.
You call that pricey? And yes, comma means decimal point and point means thousand separator.

upload_2018-4-27_1-5-52.png


However, there are cheaper ones, depending on what the OP is looking for. Difficult to say without precise title, language etc.
 

Attachments

  • upload_2018-4-27_1-5-52.png
    upload_2018-4-27_1-5-52.png
    48.2 KB · Views: 1,910
Yikes! Time to get a free openstax courseware book instead.
 
jedishrfu said:
Check amazon, I’ve seen them listed there but their kind of pricey at over $250 per book.
I checked Amazon, but I didn't come across any shipping here. Guess I'll give it another go.

fresh_42 said:
You call that pricey? And yes, comma means decimal point and point means thousand separator.

View attachment 224736

However, there are cheaper ones, depending on what the OP is looking for. Difficult to say without precise title, language etc.
Language, English, I suppose. I doubt there are any translated editions.

jedishrfu said:
Yikes! Time to get a free openstax courseware book instead.
Is that like Chegg but for books instead of solution manuals?
-
I'm asking because for some reason, that's our curriculum for the Physics Labs. I mean, old, 300$ books that you cannot find anywhere, surely make the best source to base your exercises on...
 
Try Bookfinder.com i just searched on the title.

Note this post has been edited.
 
Techno_Knight said:
I'm asking because for some reason, that's our curriculum for the Physics Labs. I mean, old, 300$ books
That is strange. I can't imagine requiring long out-of-print books like this for a course. Have you asked the professor about this? Even though some people have strong opinions about specific first-year introductory physics textbooks, in the end they're really rather similar to each other. You should be able to substitute something else, unless of course he's actually assigning exercises out of his copy of a 20-year (or however) old book.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: PhDeezNutz
jtbell said:
That is strange. I can't imagine requiring long out-of-print books like this for a course. Have you asked the professor about this?
Perhaps the professor (it's the Greece!) thinks that violation of copyright laws is OK? :wink:
 
jtbell said:
That is strange. I can't imagine requiring long out-of-print books like this for a course. Have you asked the professor about this? Even though some people have strong opinions about specific first-year introductory physics textbooks, in the end they're really rather similar to each other. You should be able to substitute something else, unless of course he's actually assigning exercises out of his copy of a 20-year (or however) old book.
Every Semester we get some free books; one for each subject/class. Thing is, they're hardly enough to struggle through the class, so you need more. The bibliography has a list, and we're encouraged to buy everything, and cross reference. It's full of older books, sometimes certain Greek books from the 80s. And those Lab Exercises are straight from there. But anyway, we're encouraged to buy more than one book, which is good in theory, but hard in practise, considering "the List", and the amount. Especially since Semesters are like 2.5 months here, and nobody does their job, really (the stories I know of A = BJ...). To give you an example, that Professor's (and everyone else's, really) philosophy, is that we shouldn't be taught how to do the Lab Exercises; rather, we should already know how to them and, I quote, "he [and the rest of the teaching stuff] should be in the next room drinking". How I'm supposed to know to operate all the 1950s machinery without seeing it somewhere, beats me, but...

Anyway, he told us that we need to hunt them down to go forward. He mentioned Feynman, but he said that he doesn't put much stock in him. I don't have a problem hunting down books; I actually enjoy the whole "collection" aspect of it (it kinda makes me feel like a real scientist, despite being awful at it), but I can't find these anywhere. His suggestion was to "look around in antique bookstores", which I did for the one I know, but I'm kind of backed into a corner here.
Demystifier said:
Perhaps the professor (it's the Greece!) thinks that violation of copyright laws is OK? :wink:
Well, considering the only way to progress through the Labs is to pirate Origin and Spice (programs for Graphs and whatnot; they can be bought, but only for institutions and not in all countries), you're not too far off the mark here...
 
  • #10
As I mentioned above, bookfinder.com can find new and second hand copies for $30-70 per volume. There are other book search engines but I think bookfinder searches some of these as well. I've used them to find old aeroplane books. Have several that the Wright Brothers used (not their copies!).
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Const@ntine
  • #11
CWatters said:
As I mentioned above, bookfinder.com can find new and second hand copies for $30-70 per volume. There are other book search engines but I think bookfinder searches some of these as well. I've used them to find old aeroplane books. Have several that the Wright Brothers used (not their copies!).
I just checked that site and yup, it does have lots of options. I reckon it'll prove extremely useful in the days to come!
uzw7SPb.png
 

Attachments

  • uzw7SPb.png
    uzw7SPb.png
    81.9 KB · Views: 1,197
  • #12
I've got all three copies :cool: But it was hellish to get them :confused: bookfinder has been known to me for quite some time, but I did not find it so useful.
 
  • #13
jtbell said:
That is strange. I can't imagine requiring long out-of-print books like this for a course. Have you asked the professor about this? Even though some people have strong opinions about specific first-year introductory physics textbooks, in the end they're really rather similar to each other. You should be able to substitute something else, unless of course he's actually assigning exercises out of his copy of a 20-year (or however) old book.
I think this is true, but Alonso is a bit more mathematical, and is more concise while being clear, then the standard US based books.

Ie., it has a nice geometrical derivation involving a bit of calculus of the components of acceleration for the kinematic equations. Something you would see in a vector analysis book, but it is shown very clearly to first year physics students. It does the same for general curvilinear motion. Something that most books just tack onto a starred section with minimal explanation. Oh, and the Lorentz Transformation , is discussed proper, and given a derivation that is easy to follow. Moreover, it starts with explaining momentum first, which leads to the concept of force. These are just a few goodies which separates it from the common intro books.
It is also fun to read, and not cluttered by seizure inducing diagrams on every page. I can go on and on, but I think you get where I am going.

The true gems of this title, comes in the second and third volume. It is a book between general intro physics books and KK, while being readable for the layman.

Sad that the book is out of print, and the single volume version of this book, is really a shell, removing a lot of the things that made the 3 volume set special,and trimming down the contents of the 3rd volume.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: vanhees71
  • #14
The only issue I see with using these books, is if the student does not have a conceptual understanding of calculus, and their idea of knowing calculus is to just remember algorithms.
 
  • #15
MidgetDwarf said:
The only issue I see with using these books, is if the student does not have a conceptual understanding of calculus, and their idea of knowing calculus is to just remember algorithms.
I couldn't agree with you more !
 
  • #16
Agreed that being vigilant for used copies works. Over the course of 2021 I was able to get a copy of all three volumes in great condition for 30-40 dollars each on eBay and Abebooks.

These books deserve a reprint. As far as I know there were never even revisions of the first printing in the U.S., but I've heard rumors that it received updates in some European countries.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: vanhees71
  • #17
MidgetDwarf said:
I think this is true, but Alonso is a bit more mathematical, and is more concise while being clear, then the standard US based books.

Ie., it has a nice geometrical derivation involving a bit of calculus of the components of acceleration for the kinematic equations. Something you would see in a vector analysis book, but it is shown very clearly to first year physics students. It does the same for general curvilinear motion. Something that most books just tack onto a starred section with minimal explanation. Oh, and the Lorentz Transformation , is discussed proper, and given a derivation that is easy to follow. Moreover, it starts with explaining momentum first, which leads to the concept of force. These are just a few goodies which separates it from the common intro books.
It is also fun to read, and not cluttered by seizure inducing diagrams on every page. I can go on and on, but I think you get where I am going.

The true gems of this title, comes in the second and third volume. It is a book between general intro physics books and KK, while being readable for the layman.

Sad that the book is out of print, and the single volume version of this book, is really a shell, removing a lot of the things that made the 3 volume set special,and trimming down the contents of the 3rd volume.
Yes, I remember, I've used Alonso and Finn a lot in the library when learning for the introductory experimental physics course. Maybe I liked them, because they were a bit more inclined to the theoretical side though ;-). It's really a shame that they are out of print :-(.
 
  • Sad
Likes   Reactions: malawi_glenn

Similar threads

  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
4K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
4K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
12K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
6K
  • · Replies 16 ·
Replies
16
Views
16K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
6K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K