Apparent power, true power, reactive power and power factor

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the concepts of apparent power, true power, reactive power, and power factor in electrical systems. Participants explore calculations related to these concepts, the implications of sign conventions, and the context of power flow in loads versus sources.

Discussion Character

  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Mathematical reasoning

Main Points Raised

  • One participant calculated apparent power (S), true power (P), reactive power (Q), and power factor, noting discrepancies with provided marking instructions regarding the sign of P and the power factor.
  • Another participant questioned the reference angle of 135 degrees, suggesting that the direction of current (+I) affects the sign of power (P).
  • It was proposed that the sign of power could be either positive or negative depending on the context, such as whether the power is supplied or consumed.
  • Concerns were raised about the angle of 135 degrees being incorrect if it represents the phase difference between voltage and current, as it should not exceed 90 degrees in certain contexts.
  • Participants discussed different types of loads (pure resistive, inductive, capacitive) and their corresponding phase angles, indicating that the angle could vary in mixed loads.
  • One participant emphasized that for a load, active power should always be positive, while reactive power could be negative.
  • Another participant clarified that the reference direction chosen for current affects the sign of active power, especially in the context of power sources versus loads.
  • A later reply noted that in the case of a generator, the sign of active power could be negative if it supplies power, but could be positive if it operates as a motor under fault conditions.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the sign conventions for power calculations, the validity of the 135-degree angle, and the interpretation of power in the context of loads versus sources. No consensus is reached on these issues.

Contextual Notes

Participants highlight the importance of context in determining the sign of power and the implications of phase angles, indicating that assumptions about reference directions and load types significantly influence the discussion.

nothing909
Messages
168
Reaction score
4
I calculated the apparent power, true power, reactive power and power factor by using:

S=VI
S=17684.5 at an angle of 135

In rectangular, that's = -1261.83+j1261.83This is probably a stupid question, but I have

S= 17684.5
P= - 1261.83
Q=1261.83

power factor = -0.707

In the marking instructions, it has the real power (P) as 1261.83 instead of what I've got - NEGATIVE 1261.83

Also, the power factor in the marking instructions is 0.707, not negative 0.707. When I calculate the power factor by simply doing cos(135, I get a negative.

Do I just not include the negatives or what, I don't understand.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
nothing909 said:
S=17684.5 at an angle of 135

135 relative to what?

You get to choose the direction of +I which determines the direction of +P. If you don't like the sign, choose the other direction.
 
anorlunda said:
135 relative to what?

You get to choose the direction of +I which determines the direction of +P. If you don't like the sign, choose the other direction.
So my answers are correct, it can be - or +?
 
nothing909 said:
So my answers are correct, it can be - or +?
it also depends on whether you are talking about power supplied or power used.

If you are referring to a load, saying it has -700W used is wrong (in most cases). Make sure it is correct in the context of the question asked.
 
In my opinion if 135 degrees is the angle between V and I then it is wrong because maximum possible it is only

90 degrees-positive or negative. Conventionally, if the current lags the voltage -inductive load-then the angle

positive and if it is capacitive it is negative. In any case cosines is positive but sinus could be positive or negative

So P has to be positive always. Q may be negative.

It seems to me it is not the right voltage [it is not the same phase as the current].
 
The load could be:

pure resistive cosfi=1 sinfi=0 fi=0 degrees

pure inductive: cosfi=0 sinfi=1 fi=+90 degrees

pure capacitive cosfi=0 sinfi=-1 fi=-90 degrees

If it would be mixed load then the angle could be more than -90 and less than +90
 
It depends on the reference direction you chose.If you considered a load,and the reference direction of current is entering towards positive reference terminal of load voltage you will not get an angle more than 90 degree, and the active power(absorbed) is always positive.However for a power source,angle more than 90 is possible and you will get negative active power in that case.This means source is supplying power.

So if your example refers to a load, you chose the current reference direction away from positive reference direction of load voltage and hence negative active power.Because in this case VICos(phi) referes to active power supplied, which is negative for a load.
If your example is of a power source, it possible for the source to absorb or provide active power.In that case it depends on how you chose current direction.If you chose current direction away from positive terminal and still you got negative active power, it means source is absorbing power.
I
 
If it is about a generator and V it is the output voltage, I agree with it. According to the sign convention the active power P is negative-if the generator supply the power, as usual. Of course, in a fault case, the generator turns into a motor and the power-maintaining the same sign rule-could be positive.
However, in my opinion, the angle between I and V cannot be more than 90 degrees-or less than -90.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • · Replies 16 ·
Replies
16
Views
3K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
8
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
3K