Assumptions made when doing calorimetry / errors that occur

In summary, the specific heat capacity of water (as the surrounding) does not change significantly during the reaction, and there are several other assumptions and errors that can contribute to inaccuracies in the results.
  • #1
chemadvisor
11
1
Homework Statement
What are the assumptions that we make when doing a calorimetry experiment? (when the calorimeter is a foam cup)?

What are the sources of error when doing a calorimetry experiment? (when the calorimeter is a foam cup)?
Relevant Equations
this question does not really need any equations to be answered, but Q=mc(delta T)
I just know that one assumption is that the specific heat capacity of water (as the surrounding) stays the same (or the change in its heat capacity is negligible). Please Help me with the rest.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • Like
Likes berkeman
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
chemadvisor said:
I just know that one assumption is that the specific heat capacity of water (as the surrounding) stays the same
That's a bit off. We often do assume that's the case, but nothing stops you from using exact specific heat of the solution if you know it.

Which brings us to another problem with your statement: you say "water as surroundings". That's not entirely correct either. It is not water that is heat up/cooled down by the reaction heat, it is whole solution - water plus whatever the reaction mixture contained and whatever its total mass is.

Does the temperature of the calorimeter itself change?

Is the reaction mixture perfectly isolated?
 
  • #3
Borek said:
That's a bit off. We often do assume that's the case, but nothing stops you from using exact specific heat of the solution if you know it.

Which brings us to another problem with your statement: you say "water as surroundings". That's not entirely correct either. It is not water that is heat up/cooled down by the reaction heat, it is whole solution - water plus whatever the reaction mixture contained and whatever its total mass is.

Does the temperature of the calorimeter itself change?

Is the reaction mixture perfectly isolated?
This is part of a lab procedure question.
We are told that the specific heat capacity of the water remain roughly the same because the solution is dilute.
Reaction 1- solid NaOH + water (aq) temperature change= 5.8
Reaction 2- Solid NaOH + HCl (aq) temperature change =12.6
Reaction 3- NaOH (aq) + HCl (aq) temperature change =6.7

Yes the temperature changes.
It is not isolated perfectly; A foam up is used as the calorimeter and it has no led on it.
Sorry I didn't clarify it at first. Can you help me with it now?
 
  • #4
chemadvisor said:
We are told that the specific heat capacity of the water remain roughly the same because the solution is dilute.

And that's an assumption you are making: that the specific heat capacity doesn't change by much.

It is not isolated perfectly; A foam up is used as the calorimeter and it has no led on it.

Think what it does mean for the heat balance - is all heat used for heating the solution?

Basically questions I asked where not for you to give simple answers, but to make you understand what is going on in the experiment and realize what the assumptions are. That's the way we help here.
 
  • #5
Borek said:
And that's an assumption you are making: that the specific heat capacity doesn't change by much.
Think what it does mean for the heat balance - is all heat used for heating the solution?
So I know one assumption could be that calorimetry and the outside environment do not exchange energy. And one source of error could be the fact that foam cup is not isolated. but the thing is the assumption I made and the error kind of contradict each other, that's why I need help
 
  • #6
chemadvisor said:
the thing is the assumption I made and the error kind of contradict each other

Not sure what you mean by that, please elaborate.

There are still more assumptions and more error sources.
 
  • #7
Borek said:
Not sure what you mean by that, please elaborate.

There are still more assumptions and more error sources.
I mean when I say one assumption is that no heat is transferred between outside environment and the calorimetry then I can't say one error that can occur is that heat can be transferred between outside environment and calorimetry.
I am really struggling with this can you tell me what are other assumptions ad errors?
 
  • #8
chemadvisor said:
I mean when I say one assumption is that no heat is transferred between outside environment and the calorimetry then I can't say one error that can occur is that heat can be transferred between outside environment and calorimetry.

Sure you can say that. These assumptions are reasonably correct, but not perfect - that makes it possible to do the calculations at all. But it also means that - as the assumptions are only approximate - they can be the source of error.

We don't have better way to do calculations, so we have to assume some factors can be neglected. It doesn't mean they don't exist at all, it only means the error they result in is reasonably small.

Try to look at every question I asked you from this point of view.
 

1. What are the common assumptions made when conducting calorimetry?

Some common assumptions made when conducting calorimetry include:

  • The system is isolated and does not exchange energy with the surroundings.
  • The heat capacity of the calorimeter is known and remains constant throughout the experiment.
  • The reaction is carried out at constant pressure and the enthalpy change is equal to the heat absorbed or released.
  • No heat is lost to the surroundings during the experiment.

2. How do errors occur in calorimetry experiments?

Errors in calorimetry experiments can occur due to a variety of factors, including:

  • Inaccurate measurements of mass or temperature.
  • Heat loss to the surroundings, which can be caused by imperfect insulation or incomplete mixing of reactants.
  • Assumptions made about the system that are not entirely accurate.
  • Chemical reactions that are not completely exothermic or endothermic.

3. What is the effect of using an incorrect heat capacity in calorimetry?

Using an incorrect heat capacity in calorimetry can lead to significant errors in the calculated enthalpy change. This is because the heat capacity is used to convert the temperature change into heat energy, and an incorrect value will result in an incorrect calculation of the heat energy absorbed or released by the reaction.

4. How can we minimize errors in calorimetry experiments?

To minimize errors in calorimetry experiments, it is important to:

  • Ensure accurate and precise measurements of mass and temperature.
  • Use a well-insulated calorimeter to minimize heat loss to the surroundings.
  • Conduct multiple trials and take the average to reduce random errors.
  • Choose a reaction that is as close to ideal as possible.

5. Can assumptions be eliminated completely in calorimetry?

While it is not possible to eliminate all assumptions in calorimetry, we can minimize their impact by carefully designing and conducting experiments. It is important to consider potential sources of error and take steps to reduce their effects. Additionally, using more advanced techniques such as bomb calorimetry can help eliminate some of the assumptions made in traditional calorimetry experiments.

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
527
  • Chemistry
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Biology and Chemistry Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • Biology and Chemistry Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
4K
  • Biology and Chemistry Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Engineering and Comp Sci Homework Help
Replies
22
Views
1K
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
619
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
17
Views
2K
  • Biology and Chemistry Homework Help
Replies
8
Views
2K
Back
Top