Astronomy master's degree with a bachelor's degree in law?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the feasibility of pursuing a master's degree in astrophysics and astronomy with a bachelor's degree in law. Participants explore the necessary academic background, including foundational physics and mathematics courses, and the implications of transitioning from a law degree to a physics-related field.

Discussion Character

  • Debate/contested
  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Homework-related

Main Points Raised

  • One participant expresses a desire to transition to a master's program in astrophysics despite having a law degree, citing a strong background in high school physics and mathematics.
  • Several participants argue that a bachelor's degree in law does not provide the necessary qualifications for advanced physics coursework, emphasizing the cumulative nature of physics education.
  • Some participants suggest that the first two years of a physics degree may include general education courses that could allow for a shorter completion time, depending on prior credits.
  • There is a discussion about the possibility of taking physics courses intensively or online, with skepticism expressed regarding the credibility of online offerings for core physics subjects.
  • Concerns are raised about the necessity of completing all foundational physics courses, such as quantum mechanics and electromagnetism, to be eligible for graduate programs in astrophysics.
  • Questions are posed about the adequacy of self-studying for the GRE physics test as a means to gain admission to a graduate program.
  • Participants discuss the challenges of completing an undergraduate physics degree in a shorter timeframe and the potential for pre-master's courses, with some expressing doubts about the feasibility of such options.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally disagree on the feasibility of entering a master's program in astrophysics without a comprehensive physics background. While some suggest alternative pathways, there is no consensus on a clear solution or agreement on the necessary qualifications.

Contextual Notes

Limitations include the lack of consensus on the adequacy of alternative educational pathways and the specific requirements of different graduate programs, which may vary by institution and country.

Menna2296
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
Hello everybody,
according to your experience please give me an advice,
Can i go to an astrophysics& astronomy master's degree with a bachelor's degree in law ? I've studied Physics and Math 2 ( calculus, mechanices,algebra) in high school. i was getting high marks at them and I am so comfortable with numbers and i like to use my brain in maths' problems. besides I like the whole idea of laws and its applying that's why i entered a law school . but now i know i should go back to see the numbers instead of so much talk. NOW , I am 20 years old in my senior year. Please, do not say go to a physics bachelor's degree . I have no power to start my master's degree with 24 years old.
Thanks in advance
 
Physics news on Phys.org
The answer is going to be to do a physics bachelor's degree, I'm afraid. A bachelor's degree in law simply won't qualify you for advanced coursework in physics. Physics is cumulative and the instructors of graduate level courses will assume that you're already familiar with everything up to the beginning of the course. So even if you were able to get in, in all likelihood you'd have a hard time keeping up. Remember, everyone else in those classes will have spent their last four years building a solid foundation in physics - studying nearly every day, wrestling with problems, working through labs, etc. And they're going to tend to be the sharper half of the group that did that too.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: CalcNerd and Student100
To add to Choppy, and (somewhat) alleviate your concern about how old you'll be when you finish, the first two years of a Physics degree is also intermixed with general education courses, which you should be able to claim prior credit for. That could turn a four year degree into two or three, depending on what you get credit for and how you load up courses.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: CalcNerd
Choppy said:
The answer is going to be to do a physics bachelor's degree, I'm afraid. A bachelor's degree in law simply won't qualify you for advanced coursework in physics. Physics is cumulative and the instructors of graduate level courses will assume that you're already familiar with everything up to the beginning of the course. So even if you were able to get in, in all likelihood you'd have a hard time keeping up. Remember, everyone else in those classes will have spent their last four years building a solid foundation in physics - studying nearly every day, wrestling with problems, working through labs, etc. And they're going to tend to be the sharper half of the group that did that too.
I've already found some program offering master's degree in physics for those with unrelated degree in chicago uni. I've not applied because of its cost. however, can i study for GRE physics test by my own and the go for master's degree ?
 
Student100 said:
To add to Choppy, and (somewhat) alleviate your concern about how old you'll be when you finish, the first two years of a Physics degree is also intermixed with general education courses, which you should be able to claim prior credit for. That could turn a four year degree into two or three, depending on what you get credit for and how you load up courses.
2 years is still so much, Can i take those courses intensively by 6 months for instence ?
 
Menna2296 said:
2 years is still so much, Can i take those courses intensively by 6 months for instence ?

Are you 8 times smarter than a UChicago undergrad?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: CalcNerd
Vanadium 50 said:
Are you 8 times smarter than a UChicago undergrad?
Come on, I've said (for instence). I do not need all physics taken in an undergraduate degree. I need the physics' courses qulaifying me to resume in astrophysics degree.
 
Menna2296 said:
Come on, I've said (for instence). I do not need all physics taken in an undergraduate degree. I need the physics' courses qulaifying me to resume in astrophysics degree.

You do, actually. The core classes are quantum mechanics, E&M, and classical mechanics. If you're going to be doing astrophysics, you'll need all of them. And even if you didn't, you will not get admitted into a graduate program without showing proficiency in all of them.
 
You asked a question, you got an answer. You don't like the answer you got? Whatever.
 
  • #10
Menna2296 said:
Come on, I've said (for instence). I do not need all physics taken in an undergraduate degree. I need the physics' courses qulaifying me to resume in astrophysics degree.

You need all the sophomore, junior, and senior level physics and math courses. That's likely 2-3 years worth of work.

6 months is an unrealistic fantasy.

Your propensity for ignoring good advice is not a good sign.
 
  • #11
Dishsoap said:
You do, actually. The core classes are quantum mechanics, E&M, and classical mechanics. If you're going to be doing astrophysics, you'll need all of them. And even if you didn't, you will not get admitted into a graduate program without showing proficiency in all of them.
Do you advise me with taking those courses online ? or study by myself and take the GRE physics test ? is GRE physucs is enough for a graduate astrophysics school ? or take a pre_master courses with the university i'll be admitted to ?
 
  • #12
Menna2296 said:
Do you advise me with taking those courses online ? or study by myself and take the GRE physics test ? is GRE physucs is enough for a graduate astrophysics school ? or take a pre_master courses with the university i'll be admitted to ?

There are no accredited online offerings of quantum mechanics, E&M, classical mechanics, or thermodynamics (stat mech) that I can recommend with any enthusiasm or that I think the admissions folks for any reputable graduate program in astrophysics will not scoff at.

Most admissions folks for reputable graduate programs will likely want to see the full slate of undergrad physics courses (and a lot of math) on the transcript of an accredited institution in addition to a good PGRE score to be convinced an applicant has a good chance to succeed in their program. They want a documented track record of learning. The PGRE is a single data point, but an important one. It is necessary but not sufficient.
 
  • #13
Vanadium 50 said:
You asked a question, you got an answer. You don't like the answer you got? Whatever.
No you've misunderstood me. Thanks for trying to help me. but i am trying to give a precise image of my problem of being late.
 
  • #14
Dr. Courtney said:
You need all the sophomore, junior, and senior level physics and math courses. That's likely 2-3 years worth of work.

6 months is an unrealistic fantasy.

Your propensity for ignoring good advice is not a good sign.
I am not ignoring any of your sweet advice. I do thank you for giving me ur time trying to help. but I am starting my ambition in late age that's my whole problem . I want to invest short time doing what others did in 4 years because maybe they started their ambition with 16 17 years old.
Whatever 2 years are good. you mean 2 years is an undergraduate level or some like pre_master's program ?
do you advise me of studying by myself for GRE physics test ? or wait till i finish those 2 years you've mentioned ?
 
  • #15
Dr. Courtney said:
There are no accredited online offerings of quantum mechanics, E&M, classical mechanics, or thermodynamics (stat mech) that I can recommend with any enthusiasm or that I think the admissions folks for any reputable graduate program in astrophysics will not scoff at.

Most admissions folks for reputable graduate programs will likely want to see the full slate of undergrad physics courses (and a lot of math) on the transcript of an accredited institution in addition to a good PGRE score to be convinced an applicant has a good chance to succeed in their program. They want a documented track record of learning. The PGRE is a single data point, but an important one. It is necessary but not sufficient.
Can i take an undergraduate degree in physics in 2 years ? or is it possible to ask them to give me a pre_master courses ? it is impossible to do that in my country . Which countries would accept my condition ?
 
  • #16
Menna2296 said:
Can i take an undergraduate degree in physics in 2 years ? or is it possible to ask them to give me a pre_master courses ? it is impossible to do that in my country . Which countries would accept my condition ?

If you got the cash and can get into the US, lots of accredited institutions will likely admit you as a transient student (not degree seeking) and let you take any and all courses for which you have the pre-requisites on an accredited college transcript. Once you pass a few upper level physics courses, you would likely be admitted to a degree program to earn a BS in Physics.

You are very unlikely to qualify for financial aid. You likely need to budget $20k or so per year, depending on lifestyle, tuition, health care, etc.

But you may also face a challenge getting the university to accept what you have already done as equivalent to college credit in 2 semesters of Calculus and 2 semesters of Calculus-based general physics. All of the upper level physics courses require those as pre-requisites, and many courses also require Calc 3, Diff Eq, Linear Algebra, etc.

It can be hard to get schools to talk about the details of accepting transfer credit and pre-requisites before you are admitted as a student. In any event, no one can even give you good guidance about these questions without seeing your actual college transcript. But in most cases, work done in high school is not going to count for much unless it has already been recognized on an accredited college transcript. Nor should it.

Thinking you are two years away is likely overly optimistic. IF you get a uni to accept your pre-requisites for 1 year of freshman Physics AND Calculus, you are more likely 3 years away. IF they do not accept your pre-reqs, you are closer to 4 years away in most BS Physics programs.
 
  • #17
Dr. Courtney said:
If you got the cash and can get into the US, lots of accredited institutions will likely admit you as a transient student (not degree seeking) and let you take any and all courses for which you have the pre-requisites on an accredited college transcript. Once you pass a few upper level physics courses, you would likely be admitted to a degree program to earn a BS in Physics.

You are very unlikely to qualify for financial aid. You likely need to budget $20k or so per year, depending on lifestyle, tuition, health care, etc.

But you may also face a challenge getting the university to accept what you have already done as equivalent to college credit in 2 semesters of Calculus and 2 semesters of Calculus-based general physics. All of the upper level physics courses require those as pre-requisites, and many courses also require Calc 3, Diff Eq, Linear Algebra, etc.

It can be hard to get schools to talk about the details of accepting transfer credit and pre-requisites before you are admitted as a student. In any event, no one can even give you good guidance about these questions without seeing your actual college transcript. But in most cases, work done in high school is not going to count for much unless it has already been recognized on an accredited college transcript. Nor should it.

Thinking you are two years away is likely overly optimistic. IF you get a uni to accept your pre-requisites for 1 year of freshman Physics AND Calculus, you are more likely 3 years away. IF they do not accept your pre-reqs, you are closer to 4 years away in most BS Physics programs.
Do you have any idea which universities with reasonable fees would accept me ? Not only in the US but also in any other european universty
 
  • #18
Menna2296 said:
Do you have any idea which universities with reasonable fees would accept me ? Not only in the US but also in any other european universty

"Reasonable fees"? Depends on what you mean. In the US, cost of living near most college campuses is $10-$12k a year before you pay a penny in tuition. I'm not familiar with European universities, but in the US, you will not qualify for in-state tuition at most universities, so you are looking at $5-$10k per year in tuition. That is considered "reasonable" for out of state tuition at public universities and the tuition everyone pays for full time at private universities. They will likely accept you as a transient student, because they want to cash your tuition checks. Travel and the required health insurance will likely be expensive also.
 
  • #19
Dr. Courtney said:
"Reasonable fees"? Depends on what you mean. In the US, cost of living near most college campuses is $10-$12k a year before you pay a penny in tuition. I'm not familiar with European universities, but in the US, you will not qualify for in-state tuition at most universities, so you are looking at $5-$10k per year in tuition. That is considered "reasonable" for out of state tuition at public universities and the tuition everyone pays for full time at private universities. They will likely accept you as a transient student, because they want to cash your tuition checks. Travel and the required health insurance will likely be expensive also.
Do you mean that private universities are the ones to accept me as a transient student ? Give me names of those universities
 
  • #20
Menna2296 said:
Do you mean that private universities are the ones to accept me as a transient student ? Give me names of those universities

I think most minimally selective private and the public universities will likely accept most foreign students as transients if several conditions are satisfied:

1. They have an undergraduate transcript with a decent GPA from an accredited university.
2. They can get permission to come here in a student status.
3. They can pay.

You can google US universities yourself and contact their admissions offices.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
2K
  • · Replies 50 ·
2
Replies
50
Views
11K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
4K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
5K