Average Speed on I-10 from San Antonio to Houston

[hytuoc]

You drive on Interstate 10 from San Antonio to Houston, half the distance at 55km/h and the other half at 90km/h. what is your average speed from San Antonio to Houson?
How do I do this?

 

[DrWarezz]

To find the average of something, you simply add up all the numbers you have, then divide by how many you have, as an answer to your question:

(55+90)/2 = 72.5

:)
[r.D]

 

[Tide]

The average speed is the total distance traveled divided by the total time to make the trip.

 

[DrWarezz]

Tide, that's the overall speed. Which would equal the average speed. So, you're not necessarily wrong, however, niether the time nor the distance are specified in the question. So, my answer is the one to go for :)

[r.D]

 

[robphy]

To find the average of something, you simply add up all the numbers you have, then divide by how many you have, as an answer to your question:

(55+90)/2 = 72.5

:)
[r.D]

That's the problem with the lack of a good explanation of "average velocity" in physics textbooks.

"average velocity" is a time-weighted-average of velocities.
v_{av}=\frac{v_1 \Delta t_1 + v_2 \Delta t_2}{\Delta t_1+\Delta t_2}
Only then does it logically follow that
v_{av}=\frac{\Delta x}{\Delta t}

Generally speaking (i.e., for non-constant acceleration), the straight-average velocity has no physically interesting application.

edit:
"average speed" is a time-weighted-average of speeds.
s_{av}=\frac{|v_1 \Delta t_1| + |v_2 \Delta t_2|}{\Delta t_1+\Delta t_2}
Only then does it logically follow that
s_{av}=\frac{d_{total}}{\Delta t}=\frac{d_{total}}{t_{total}}
where d_{total} is the total-distance travelled.

 

[DrWarezz]

Thanks robphy.
However, my solution answers the authors question, correct?

:)

[r.D]

 

[robphy]

Thanks robphy.
However, my solution answers the authors question, correct?

:)

[r.D]

Since v₁t₁=v₂t₂, I get 68.276 km/hr.

 

[DrWarezz]

\ Hmm..
Well, I'm guessing by the simplicity of the question, that such a method is not necessary. Instead, the teacher that set this homework :P is just wanting to see the use of averages. :) hehe.

So, to the author: If this is just some homework, and you haven't done averages at school yet (I'm assuming you're at school), then go for my answer. But, if you're, eg, at college or something, definitely go for robphys' solution :D

best of luck - and thanks for the insight robphy, I am only a young school student (15 yrs old), so, your solution is quite new to me. But, I've bookmarked it, and will surely use it in the future :D Thanks.

[r.D]

 

[ZapperZ]

Tide, that's the overall speed. Which would equal the average speed. So, you're not necessarily wrong, however, niether the time nor the distance are specified in the question. So, my answer is the one to go for :)

[r.D]

You cannot apply the statistical definition of "average" to average speed. It is DEFINED, as stated, as the total distance traveled divided by the total time taken. Even though the total distance and time taken here are not given, this problem is still solvable if one stick to solving it symbolically in the beginning and not plug in numbers right away.

Zz.

P.S. This thing is posted in the wrong section of PF. We do have a Homework Help section.

 

[Tide]

Tide, that's the overall speed. Which would equal the average speed. So, you're not necessarily wrong, however, niether the time nor the distance are specified in the question. So, my answer is the one to go for :)

[r.D]

Well, you could certainly do that but consider this. Suppose you traveled at 50 km/h for the entire trip except that over the last meter you gunned it and traveled at the speed of light. Would your average speed have been half the speed of light?

 

[krab]

The reciprocal of the average speed is the average of the reciprocals:
\overline{v}={d\over t}={d\over t_1+t_2}={d\over{d\over 2v_1}+{d\over 2v_2}}={2v_1v_2\over v_1+v_2}

 

[Tide]

More generally, if the fraction of the total distance traveled at speed v_1 is f with the remainder at speed v_2 then the average time is
\frac {v_1 v_2}{f v_2 + (1-f)v_1}

 

[ArmoSkater87]

The solution offered in the very biginning,
\overline {v} = {v_0 + v_f \over 2} only works if assuming constant acceleration.

 

[ArmoSkater87]

This problem in general is very dumb because it implies an instantaneous change in speed from 55km/h to 90km/h.