Ballentine on Diffraction Scattering

4 replies · 2K views · last reply
EE18
Messages
112
Reaction score
13
In Chapter 5.4b of Ballentine, a discussion ensues about the analysis of a particle scattering off of a (Bravais lattice) periodic array. I attach pictures here of the full discussion in case anyone wants/needs to refer to it, but I am particularly baffled by the discussion on page 135. In particular, my understanding is as follows:

(1) As a general goal, we are looking for an eigenstate (i.e. solution to (5.24) -- what Ballentine often refers to as a "physical solution") which respects the boundary condition that it is incident from some source which we capture vaguely based on the ultimate ##e^{i\textbf{k} \cdot \textbf{x}}## in (5.27) which is to be discussed.

(2) We employ Bloch's Theorem which tells us that it is possible to pick an eigenbasis of the Hamiltonian (i.e. of (5.24)) in which every solution is of the form (5.26). That it is possible is important -- it does not, in particular, follow that every eigenstate obeying (5.24) is of the form (5.26).

(3) My issue is with why Ballentine says, at the bottom of 135, that (5.27) must be of the form (5.26). Why!? I'm satisfied with the paragraph above (5.27) where we argue that we need only one eigenstate of the form (5.26) to account for the first term in (5.27), but why should we in general say that that one eigenstate (for the given ##\textbf{q}=\textbf{k}_{xy}## is then sufficient to account for all the other terms in (5.27)? That doesn't seem to have been established at all, and I could imagine that there would be other ##\textbf{q}## in the eigenspace of ##H## corresponding to the given value of ##E## so that, from my comments in (2), we in general have to bring in other eigenstates of the form (5.26) to write (5.27)? Ballentine must be using some other information to exclude this possibility.

Textbook page titled 5.4 Diffraction Scattering: Theory, with paragraphs on diffraction by a periodic array and equation (5.24), a Schrödinger equation with the Laplacian, potential W(x) and eigenvalue E.
Diagram of diffraction by a periodic array of atoms: a row of evenly spaced circles on a line, labeled with spacing a, with an incident beam at angle θ1 and a scattered beam at angle θ2, and a z-y axis key at lower left.
Printed textbook page 135 on diffraction scattering from a periodic lattice, containing equations 5.26 and 5.27 and a discussion of the incident and scattered wave terms.
Printed textbook page 136 with equations 5.28 and 5.29 on momentum transfer quantized by the reciprocal lattice vector, and the 1D diffraction condition ħk(sin θ2 − sin θ1) = 2πħn/a.
 
EE18 said:
My issue is with why Ballentine says, at the bottom of 135, that (5.27) must be of the form (5.26). Why!? I'm satisfied with the paragraph above (5.27) where we argue that we need only one eigenstate of the form (5.26) to account for the first term in (5.27), but why should we in general say that that one eigenstate (for the given is then sufficient to account for all the other terms in (5.27)?
He's matching a general form of the full three dimensional wave-function to the form established for its restriction to the xy plane containing the lattice.
 
LittleSchwinger said:
He's matching a general form of the full three dimensional wave-function to the form established for its restriction to the xy plane containing the lattice.
But how has he established that the particular solution for this problem is an element of the Bloch basis and not just a member of that eigenspace (and so a sum of elements of the Bloch basis in that eigenspace)?
 
Because this solution must meet the boundary condition imposed by the incident wave.
 
and to be an eigenstate the energy of the system is constrained asymptotically. This restricts the eigenstates to a subset that looks like Bloch waves with a particular in-plane momentum