Best Calculus book before college

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around recommendations for calculus books suitable for a high school student preparing for college-level calculus, specifically aiming to master Calculus 1 and advance into Calculus 2. Participants explore various textbooks, their content, and suitability for different levels of mathematical maturity.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested
  • Technical explanation
  • Homework-related

Main Points Raised

  • One participant seeks recommendations for calculus books to prepare for college, expressing uncertainty about the content of Calculus 2.
  • Another participant outlines typical topics covered in Calculus 2, including applications of integration, differential equations, techniques of integration, L'Hopital's rule, infinite series, and parametric/polar functions.
  • Several participants recommend specific textbooks, including Larson, Stewart, Spivak, Apostol, and Thomas, each highlighting different strengths such as rigor, ease of understanding, and depth of theory.
  • Some participants suggest that Stewart's book may be sufficient for those primarily looking to prepare for Calculus 2 without a focus on theoretical depth.
  • There is a discussion about the level of mathematical maturity required for Spivak and Apostol, with some participants indicating that these books may be challenging for those without a strong background in proofs.
  • One participant mentions a comic book-style calculus primer as a helpful resource for understanding calculus language and notation.
  • Concerns are raised about the difficulty of Spivak and Apostol for the original poster, who feels uncertain about their readiness for these texts.
  • Another participant shares their positive experience with Spivak, suggesting it teaches deeper mathematical understanding beyond just formulas.
  • There is a suggestion to physically examine books in a bookstore to assess their suitability before purchasing.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a range of opinions on which calculus books are most appropriate, with no clear consensus on a single recommendation. Some favor more rigorous texts while others advocate for more standard, application-focused books. The discussion reflects differing views on the necessary background knowledge for various texts.

Contextual Notes

Participants note varying levels of familiarity with calculus and mathematical concepts, which may influence their recommendations. There is also mention of different educational systems and how they structure calculus courses, which could affect the appropriateness of certain texts.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be useful for high school students preparing for college calculus, educators seeking textbook recommendations, and anyone interested in understanding the differences between various calculus texts.

Nathew
I am looking for a calculus book to help prepare me for college next year.

Currently i am in AP calc AB but that class will end in about 2 weeks. Next year i will hopefully start in calc 2 if my credits transfer. I want to have mastered calc 1 and be at least most of the way into calc 2.

What book would you guys recommend for me to buy and work on the rest of the school year/this summer?
I looked through most of the calc books on here but i couldn't really find a good one? Plus i don't really know what calc 2 entails so if you could recommend me a book, what would it be, and what is covered in calc 2?

Thanks a lot!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Nathew said:
Plus i don't really know what calc 2 entails so if you could recommend me a book, what would it be, and what is covered in calc 2?
I'll assume you are in the US. The length of the calculus sequence of courses vary by school. The two most common are the three-semester sequence and the four-quarter sequence. I think most schools in my area (Maryland) offer calculus as a three-semester sequence, so for those schools, what constitutes "Calculus 2", in general, would be:
- applications of integration
- a little differential equations
- techniques of integration
- L'Hopital's rule
- infinite series
- parametric/polar functions

Nathew said:
I am looking for a calculus book to help prepare me for college next year.

Currently i am in AP calc AB but that class will end in about 2 weeks. Next year i will hopefully start in calc 2 if my credits transfer. I want to have mastered calc 1 and be at least most of the way into calc 2.

What book would you guys recommend for me to buy and work on the rest of the school year/this summer?
I looked through most of the calc books on here but i couldn't really find a good one?
You say that you are currently in AP Calc AB. What book are you using?

I'm partial towards Larson - not only did I study from it when I took Calculus in high school (3rd edition), but I currently teach out of it (9th edition). I like the amount of exercises given. I like his exposition. I don't like how he skips multiple steps in his examples.
 
Right now, we are using single variable calculus early transcendentals (fourth edition) by james stewart.
 
Seriously, anybody? My course is about to end and I kind of want to get a book soon. Any books that have both calc 1 and 2?
 
I would suggest Spivak's Calculus. It's easy to read and also serves as an intro to proofs.
 
If you want rigorous/theoretical treatment, my recommendation is Apostol. You can get the international edition for less than $20 on abebooks. The first volume covers calc 1 and 2, plus some linear algebra. The second volume covers the rest of linear algebra, calc 3, and some numerical analysis/propability. Spivak is also an amazing book (I just prefer the former). Apostol will provide a nice blend of technique and theory.

If you want a more standard text (more applications and computation), then I suggest Thomas' Calculus. It will cover Calc 1-3. It touches on some of the theory, but focuses mostly on application. I hear Courant is excellent, treating theory thoroughly with a heavy emphasis on applications.
 
Well, Spivak and Apostol were named, but I only advise those two if you want to review calculus with an eye for detail. If, all you want to do is learn and be prepared for calc II, then stewart is a fine book to stick it or Larson. Gilbert Strang Calculus is free online and will cover the same material as those two books. Calc II tends to just be a lot of integration techniques (parts, trig sub, partial fractions, ...) and infinite series and perhaps some conics or polar/spherical coordinates to prepare for Calc III. The integration techniques and application, if I recall correctly, take most of the course up.
 
Nathew said:
Right now, we are using single variable calculus early transcendentals (fourth edition) by james stewart.

Judging from the table of contents on amazon.com, that book includes the usual Calculus 2 topics. If you're comfortable with it, you can simply keep on using it.
 
kostas230 said:
I would suggest Spivak's Calculus. It's easy to read and also serves as an intro to proofs.

dustbin said:
If you want rigorous/theoretical treatment, my recommendation is Apostol. You can get the international edition for less than $20 on abebooks. The first volume covers calc 1 and 2, plus some linear algebra. The second volume covers the rest of linear algebra, calc 3, and some numerical analysis/propability. Spivak is also an amazing book (I just prefer the former). Apostol will provide a nice blend of technique and theory.

If you want a more standard text (more applications and computation), then I suggest Thomas' Calculus. It will cover Calc 1-3. It touches on some of the theory, but focuses mostly on application. I hear Courant is excellent, treating theory thoroughly with a heavy emphasis on applications.

It sounds like the OP is a high school senior. If so, then I don't know if any of the suggestions above (besides Thomas) would be appropriate.
 
  • #10
Say i want to do Spivak, should i have enough knowledge to go through it and learn from it? or do i need to know more about proofs/have more mathematical "maturity"?
 
  • #11
I wish I would have had this book before I took Calculus I in college, it would have made the process so much easier. Prof. E McSquared's Calculus Primer: Expanded Intergalactic Version is like a comic book explaining the language of Calculus. You must learn the symbolic notations.
 
  • #12
Yeah I know I've taken calc 1 in high school. Is that enough for this book?
 
  • #13
Best thing you can do is get your hands on one of those in a bookstore and look inside of it. Amazon has a feature which let's you do a little of that, you can view the table of contents to get an idea about what the book covers.
 
  • #14
Yeah but not for that book. If I know the basics of calc do you think I should understand it?
 
  • #15
Check it out at Barnes & Noble or Books A Million in your area. It's a comic book, so it should be easy to understand.
 
  • #16
I am so torn. As i look into each book more and more, I am not sure its for me. Spivak seems like it might be too difficult for me as of right now, apostol also seems like it is for a more mathematically familiar crowd, and stewart seems like it isn't quite deep enough. I CANT DECIDE! I am dying someone help
 
  • #17
Nathew said:
I am so torn. As i look into each book more and more, I am not sure its for me. Spivak seems like it might be too difficult for me as of right now, apostol also seems like it is for a more mathematically familiar crowd, and stewart seems like it isn't quite deep enough. I CANT DECIDE! I am dying someone help
Spivak might have a tough learning curve but it's very rewarding.
 
  • #18
Nathew said:
I am so torn. As i look into each book more and more, I am not sure its for me. Spivak seems like it might be too difficult for me as of right now, apostol also seems like it is for a more mathematically familiar crowd, and stewart seems like it isn't quite deep enough. I CANT DECIDE! I am dying someone help

I learned calculus when I was in high school from Spivak. Stick with it and it will teach you how to actually do mathematics, rather than just using formulas...
 
  • #19
kostas230 said:
I learned calculus when I was in high school from Spivak. Stick with it and it will teach you how to actually do mathematics, rather than just using formulas...

What prior knowledge did you have before starting spivak?
 
  • #20
Algebra and trigonometry. Seriously, you don't need anything else to know to study calculus.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
4K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
11K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
2K
  • · Replies 20 ·
Replies
20
Views
9K
  • · Replies 17 ·
Replies
17
Views
12K
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
3K
Replies
41
Views
7K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
4K