Calculated G force and don't know what to do now (punch force)

  • Context: High School 
  • Thread starter Thread starter Patrick ryans
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Force
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around calculating the g-forces associated with the punch of a fictional character, Doomsday, from comic books. Participants explore the application of physics equations to estimate the force of a punch, including the use of velocity and radius in their calculations. The conversation includes attempts to clarify the meaning of calculated values and the appropriate methods for determining g-forces.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Mathematical reasoning

Main Points Raised

  • One participant calculated a value of 1.39160521 × 10^23 hertz using the equation V^2/R but is uncertain about its meaning and how to derive g-forces from it.
  • Another participant requests to see the calculations to understand the process better.
  • Concerns are raised about the appropriateness of using arm length as the radius in the calculations.
  • There is a discussion about the implications of exceeding the speed of light in the calculations, with some participants suggesting to ignore physical laws due to the fictional context.
  • Participants discuss the complexity of calculating the force of a punch, emphasizing the need to consider factors such as the mass of the fist and the speed change upon impact.
  • One participant acknowledges the need to redo calculations after realizing the misunderstanding of g-force and acceleration.
  • Another participant suggests estimating the mass of the object being punched and its speed change as a method to calculate the force.
  • There is a request for clarification on the equations and symbols involved in calculating the force of a punch.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the validity of the calculations and the methods used. There is no consensus on the correct approach to calculating g-forces or the force of a punch, and the discussion remains unresolved with multiple competing ideas and methods proposed.

Contextual Notes

Some participants note limitations in the calculations, including the use of incorrect dimensions in equations and the need for clearer definitions of terms like g-force and acceleration. There is also an acknowledgment that the calculations involve fictional scenarios that may not adhere to real-world physics.

Patrick ryans
Messages
6
Reaction score
0
i have calculated the g forces for my favorite comic book character doomsday to see how hard he punches and i know that the equation is V^2/R and i finally finished my equation and my answer is
1.39160521 × 10^23 hertz what does this answer mean and what do i do know to find the amount of G forces and let me know if this is the right thread level for g forces
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Patrick ryans said:
i have calculated the g forces for my favorite comic book character doomsday to see how hard he punches and i know that the equation is V^2/R and i finally finished my equation and my answer is
1.39160521 × 10^23 hertz what does this answer mean and what do i do know to find the amount of G forces and let me know if this is the right thread level for g forces
Show your calculations or we won't have any idea what you've done.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Patrick ryans
Please show your working :-)
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Patrick ryans
“Tests with Air force pilots have shown, that they could identify the plane on a flashed picture that was flashed only for 1/220th of a second.”

That is identifying. So it's pretty safe to say, that recognizing, that SOME light was there is possible with 1/300th of a second.”

First, let's assume your field of vision on a clear horizon at ground level is 2.5 miles in either direction. Also, let's assume that the statistic quoted above that you probably couldn't recognize something if it flashed for just 1/300th of a second is true.

So a plane traveling 5 miles in 1/300th of a second would travel at 1,500 miles a second or 5.4 million miles an hour. That's about .8% the speed of light.

5.4 million miles an hour divided by the normal speed a human runs is

192,857 times faster to be useable

And At it's closest, Pluto is 2.66 billion miles (4.28 billion km) from Earth, and at its furthest 4.67 billion miles (7.5 billion km). This means that Superman is traveling somewhere between 238 and 418 times the speed of light let's take 418 then

418 times 192,857

80,614,226 times the speed of light

speed of light in meters per second 299,792,458

so 299,792,458 times 80,614,226 is

24,167,537,000,000,000 m/s

So the equation for g forces is Velocity in m/s with that number squared divided by the radius in meters

So if you make 24,167,537,000,000,000 m/s squared it is

194,824,730,000,000,000,000,000/?

By using a photo of doomsday, doomsday is 4.62500 inches as the picture at least and using a unit I call DH which stands for doomsday heads which the size of his head is around 0.6875 inches

So 4.62500 divided by 0.6875 inches

That means there is 6.72727273 doomsday heads in his whole body so let’s put it down to 6.73 so its easier (this is the closest I can get I’m not a master at decimals so the whole thing might be almost a sliver off)

And the actual height of doomsday is 8ft and 10 inches

So 8 ft 10 inches divided by 6.73 is

So doomsdays actual size of his head is 1 foot 3¾ inches

So we saw how many DH can be on one arm and it is exactly 3 and 1/5

So 1 foot 3¾ inches times 3 and 1/5 is

4 feet 7⅛ inches or 4.59375 feet

So let’s make this easier and sat his arm is 4.59 feet

So that means his arm is 1.399032 meters

Let’s simplify it so it is 1.4 meters

So know let’s use this info and complete the equation

So 194,824,730,000,000,000,000,000/1.4

1.39160521 × 10^23 hertz

links because some of this stuff other people have kind of answered

http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?t=580044

https://www.reddit.com/r/DCcomics/comments/3079d5/how_fast_is_superman/
 
ok here is the equation V^2/R is velocity in meters per second squared divided by the radius in meters I did this calculation used a google as a calculator and ended up with hertz
 
Quite a few issues with your calculations.
Patrick ryans said:
i know that the equation is V^2/R

Patrick ryans said:
So the equation for g forces is Velocity in m/s with that number squared divided by the radius in meters
Why did you use this formula? Why have you used his arm length as the "radius"?
Patrick ryans said:
5.4 million miles an hour divided by the normal speed a human runs is

192,857 times faster to be useable

And At it's closest, Pluto is 2.66 billion miles (4.28 billion km) from Earth, and at its furthest 4.67 billion miles (7.5 billion km). This means that Superman is traveling somewhere between 238 and 418 times the speed of light let's take 418 then

418 times 192,857
I didn't get this also. What do you mean by "useable"?
Patrick ryans said:
80,614,226 times the speed of light

speed of light in meters per second 299,792,458

so 299,792,458 times 80,614,226 is

24,167,537,000,000,000 m/s
Here you've exceeded the speed of light, which isn't possible (even in theory). But, since this is Superman (fiction) we're talking about, let's just ignore the laws of relativity.
It's not that simple to apply these equations to human actions. A punch is a complicated thing. Knowing how fast Superman moves isn't enough to know the force of impact; you'd also have to know how he conducts his arm during the punch (or at least the depth of the dent caused by the punch).
As for the units, g-force is measured in g's (the g stands for acceleration due to gravity; roughly equal to ##9.8m/s^2##). I suppose you know that g-force isn't actually a force, rather it's an acceleration.
 
Patrick ryans said:
So the equation for g forces is Velocity in m/s with that number squared divided by the radius in meters
Patrick ryans said:
ok here is the equation V^2/R is velocity in meters per second squared divided by the radius in meters I did this calculation used a google as a calculator and ended up with hertz
That's not an equation for force of any type because it doesn't have the right dimensions. ##v^2/r## is an acceleration, namely the centripetal acceleration needed to keep an object in a circular orbit of radius ##r##. It has nothing to do with what you're trying to calculate, so it's not surprising that you're getting nonsensical results.

You're looking for the "force of a punch". For that you can start with the definition of what a force is, from Newton: ##F=ma##. There are two ways you can go from there:
1) Estimate the mass of the fist and how much its speed changes when it strikes the punched object.
2) Estimate the mass of the punched object and how much its speed changes when it is struck by the fist.

You will use the speed change to calculate the acceleration, but to do that you need to know long it takes for the speed to change. That can be calculated from the initial and final speed and as aniruddha said, "the depth of the dent caused by the punch".
 
Last edited:
ok I found out how to calculate it here https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/calculating-g-force.611116/ and I am ignoring the laws of physics since it passes the speed of light and I meant at that one part where I said useable I meant unseable I also just realized that I need to find out the exeleration of the object he Is hitting and I new it wasn't a force it was an exelleration but I wasn't thinking of that so dang it I have to do most of the equation over lol I will send you the results when I'm done
 
and I just read what nugatory said and I need to do the whole thing over again lol
 
  • #10
so I'm going to so option number 2 where you said
"2) Estimate the mass of the punched object and how much its speed changes when it is struck by the fist."
know what is the equation to this and I am new to equations so explain what the symbols mean
 
  • #11
Patrick ryans said:
so I'm going to so option number 2 where you said
"2) Estimate the mass of the punched object and how much its speed changes when it is struck by the fist."
know what is the equation to this and I am new to equations so explain what the symbols mean
So what are your estimates of the mass of the punched object and how much its speed changes when struck by the fist?
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
9K
  • · Replies 35 ·
2
Replies
35
Views
5K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
4K
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
2K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
3K
  • · Replies 29 ·
Replies
29
Views
4K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 28 ·
Replies
28
Views
3K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
2K