Calculating Resistance of Aluminum & Copper Pipe

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The problem involves calculating the electrical resistance of a cylindrical aluminum pipe filled with copper. The dimensions of the pipe and the resistivity values for both materials are provided, prompting a discussion on the configuration of the materials in relation to their resistance.

Discussion Character

  • Mixed

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants explore the resistance calculation using the formula R = ρL/A, with specific attention to the areas of the inner and outer cylinders. There is a discussion about whether the aluminum and copper parts are in series or parallel.

Discussion Status

Some participants have provided guidance on correcting the cross-sectional area calculation for the aluminum cylinder, suggesting the use of the area of the outer cylinder minus the inner cylinder area. This has led to a clarification of the approach needed for the resistance calculation.

Contextual Notes

There is a noted misunderstanding regarding the calculation of the cross-sectional area for the aluminum section, which has been addressed in the discussion. The original poster's calculations were based on an incorrect assumption about the area used for the aluminum pipe.

gamesandmore
Messages
32
Reaction score
0
A cylindrical aluminum pipe of length 1.36 m has an inner radius of 1.80 10-3 m and an outer radius of 3.00 10-3 m. The interior of the pipe is completely filled with copper. What is the resistance of this unit? (Hint: Imagine that the pipe is connected between the terminals of a battery and decide whether the aluminum and copper parts of the pipe are in series or in parallel.)

Here is what I did:
L = 1.36 m
ri = 1.80e-3m
ro = 3.00e-3 m
R = ? ohms
R = pL/A
pcopper = 1.72e-8 ohm*m
palum = 2.82e-8 ohm*m

In = copper
Out = aluminum

Ai = pi*ri^2 = 1.01788e-5 m^2
Ao= pi*ro^2 = 2.827e-5 m^2

Ri = pcopper * L/Ai = .002298 ohms
Ro = palum * L/Ao = .0013566 ohms

Then I did
1 / ( (1/.002298ohms) + (1/.0013566 ohms) )
and got 8.53e-4 Ohms, but it was wrong...
 
Physics news on Phys.org
gamesandmore said:
A cylindrical aluminum pipe of length 1.36 m has an inner radius of 1.80 10-3 m and an outer radius of 3.00 10-3 m. The interior of the pipe is completely filled with copper. What is the resistance of this unit? (Hint: Imagine that the pipe is connected between the terminals of a battery and decide whether the aluminum and copper parts of the pipe are in series or in parallel.)

Here is what I did:
L = 1.36 m
ri = 1.80e-3m
ro = 3.00e-3 m
R = ? ohms
R = pL/A
pcopper = 1.72e-8 ohm*m
palum = 2.82e-8 ohm*m

In = copper
Out = aluminum

Ai = pi*ri^2 = 1.01788e-5 m^2
Ao= pi*ro^2 = 2.827e-5 m^2

Ri = pcopper * L/Ai = .002298 ohms
Ro = palum * L/Ao = .0013566 ohms

Then I did
1 / ( (1/.002298ohms) + (1/.0013566 ohms) )
and got 8.53e-4 Ohms, but it was wrong...

The cross sectional area for the aluminum cylinder is not ][itex]\pi r_0 ^2[/itex], you must use only the area of the outside cyliner which wil be [itex]\pi(r_0^2 - r_i^2)[/itex]
 
So Ao = pi*(ro^2 - ri^2) ?
 
gamesandmore said:
So Ao = pi*(ro^2 - ri^2) ?

Yes, that's what I wrote.
 
Thanks, worked perfect :)
 
gamesandmore said:
Thanks, worked perfect :)

Great. Am glad I could help. I hope you see why this is the correct equation to use for the cross sectional area of the aluminum pipe.

good luck
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
3K
Replies
2
Views
23K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
12K
Replies
6
Views
15K
Replies
14
Views
3K