Calculating the force on an electron from two positive point charges

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on calculating the force on an electron positioned between two positive point charges, each with charge +q, located on the z-axis. While the mathematical approach involves calculating the electric potential and deriving the electric field, the intuitive expectation is that the electron should experience no net force due to the repelling nature of the charges. The confusion arises from the assumption that electric field lines do not interact, leading to the belief that the plane between the charges should have no field lines. However, field lines are merely a representation of the electric field and do not physically interact; thus, the mathematical calculations can yield a net force despite the intuitive notion of zero force. The key takeaway is that the mathematical treatment of electric fields does not align with the intuitive understanding of field lines in this scenario.
Antonis Hadjipittas
Messages
2
Reaction score
1
So this is more of an intuitive question rather than a mathematical one. I present the problem.

Assume I have 2 charges of charge +q at a distance r from each other on the z axis. Position of two charges is (0,0,r/2) and (0,0,-r/2). Assume now that I want to calculate the force these two charges exert on an electron which is at a point (x,0,0) or (0,y,0). Basically any point on the plane which lies on z=0, i.e. exactly between the two charges.

Mathematically the way to go about this, you calculate the electric potential for a system of charges and take both positive charges into account. Then you calculate the gradient of the electric potential which gives you the electric field and then find the force on the electron. If this is done correctly, you will find that there is a net force on the electron, however this is not intuitive to grasp. You see, since both charges are positive, the electric field lines should repel each other leaving the plane (x,y,0) in the middle with no field lines, therefore the force on the electron should be zero (Also assume that the electron's effect is minimal).

So my issue is the following: When we calculate the electric potential of a system of charges, we assume that the electric field lines do not interact with each other. If we assume that they do interact with each other, in this case we get a different answer since there should be no field lines in the plane lying exactly in the middle of the two charges. What am I missing?

Thanks in advance
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Antonis Hadjipittas said:
we assume that the electric field lines do not interact with each other. If we assume that they do interact with each other, in this case we get a different answer since there should be no field lines in the plane lying exactly in the middle of the two charges.
Field lines are just a visual aid that we draw to help us see which direction the electric field points at any given point. They're no more real than the lines of latitude and longitude that we draw on a map of the earth, so they cannot attract or repel or anything else.
 
Antonis Hadjipittas said:
So my issue is the following: When we calculate the electric potential of a system of charges, we assume that the electric field lines do not interact with each other.
Where do we assume that such a thing, whatever its supposed to mean. You compute the potential, and then can derive the field lines from that. Not the other way around.
 
This is from Griffiths' Electrodynamics, 3rd edition, page 352. I am trying to calculate the divergence of the Maxwell stress tensor. The tensor is given as ##T_{ij} =\epsilon_0 (E_iE_j-\frac 1 2 \delta_{ij} E^2)+\frac 1 {\mu_0}(B_iB_j-\frac 1 2 \delta_{ij} B^2)##. To make things easier, I just want to focus on the part with the electrical field, i.e. I want to find the divergence of ##E_{ij}=E_iE_j-\frac 1 2 \delta_{ij}E^2##. In matrix form, this tensor should look like this...
Thread 'Applying the Gauss (1835) formula for force between 2 parallel DC currents'
Please can anyone either:- (1) point me to a derivation of the perpendicular force (Fy) between two very long parallel wires carrying steady currents utilising the formula of Gauss for the force F along the line r between 2 charges? Or alternatively (2) point out where I have gone wrong in my method? I am having problems with calculating the direction and magnitude of the force as expected from modern (Biot-Savart-Maxwell-Lorentz) formula. Here is my method and results so far:- This...
Back
Top