Can you correctly measure wave properties but get wrong wavelength?

In summary: And that's the key to understanding why the answer could be (a) yes, (b) yes, (c) yes. With different linear densities, the waves will propagate at different speeds, resulting in different wavelengths at different points along the rope. Therefore, it is possible for your friend to measure a wavelength of 0.8m, 1.0m, or 1.2m at her part of the rope.
  • #1
bkraabel
26
0

Homework Statement



You and a friend each have one rope. You tie the two ropes together and stand as far apart as possible, each holding one end of the new longer rope and pulling to put it under tension. You then begin moving your arm in such a way as to produce a harmonic wave with a wavelength of 1.0 m. Your friend looks at the waves as they reach her arm. Is it possible that she measures a wavelength of (a) 0.8 m, (b) 1.0 m, or (c) 1.2 m?

Homework Equations


For standing wave with BOTH ends fixed: [itex]\lambda=\frac{2 \ell}{n-1}[/itex] where [itex]n[/itex] is the number of nodes (including the node at each end) and [itex]\ell[/itex] is the length of the rope.

If one end of the rope is driven, this end is an antinode, so the wavelength would be so you get [itex]\lambda/4+(n-1)\lambda/2=\ell[/itex] , which simplifies to [itex]\lambda=\frac{4\ell}{2n-1}[/itex]

We also have the following relation between wave speed [itex]c[/itex], frequency and wavelength: [itex]c=\lambda f[/itex].


The Attempt at a Solution


I assume the friend does not more her arm, so her end of the rope is a node. Your end of the rope is an antinode. The friend "looks at the waves as they reach her arm." What does that mean? She measures the wave speed? Frequency? Amplitude? All of those? Does she count the nodes between the two ends of the rope? That would seem to not be consistent with "looking at the waves as they reach her arm." So I assume she measures wavespeed and frequency and calculates wavelength. If she does that correctly, she should get the correct wavelength, so the answer would be
(a) no, (b) yes, (c) no
However, others argue (I don't know why) that the answer is
(a) yes, (b) yes, (c) yes

My question is: What argument(s) can you give to support the second answer (all yes)??

Thanks for any ideas.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Your "relevant equations" all assume that there is a single wavelength everywhere. You cannot use them here.

What does that mean? She measures the wave speed? Frequency? Amplitude? All of those?
She can probably observe all, but only the wavelength is interesting here.
Does she count the nodes between the two ends of the rope?
She measures the distance between nodes at her part of the rope. For the answer, it does not matter if there is a standing wave or not.
So I assume she measures wavespeed and frequency and calculates wavelength.
Okay, that is possible.
If she does that correctly, she should get the correct wavelength
Sure, she will get the wavelength at her part of the rope.
so the answer would be
(a) no, (b) yes, (c) no
Why? You started with the (wrong) conclusion here.

What do you know about the speed of waves in a rope?
What do you know about the frequency you and your friend will measure?
 
  • #3
The problem statement says "moving your arm in such a way as to produce a harmonic wave with a wavelength of 1.0 m." Does that not means there is a single wavelength-frequency combination on the rope? Where would the other frequencies come from?
thanks, Brett
 
  • #4
Are the two ropes identical? Does the knot have an effect?
 
  • #5
bkraabel said:
The problem statement says "moving your arm in such a way as to produce a harmonic wave with a wavelength of 1.0 m." Does that not means there is a single wavelength-frequency combination on the rope? Where would the other frequencies come from?
thanks, Brett
You have a well-defined wavelength at your arm. That does not mean that the wavelength has to be the same everywhere.

The frequency will stay constant, but the propagation speed of the wave does not have to be (why? -> see the question in my previous post). What happens if you have the same frequency, but different propagation speeds?
 
  • #6
Ah - I guess the two ropes are not identical. I took "one rope" as meaning a single rope. So the wavelength can change if the ropes have different linear densities.
 
  • #7
bkraabel said:
Ah - I guess the two ropes are not identical. I took "one rope" as meaning a single rope. So the wavelength can change if the ropes have different linear densities.
Exactly.
 

1. Can you explain the difference between wave properties and wavelength?

Wave properties refer to the characteristics of a wave, such as amplitude, frequency, and speed. Wavelength, on the other hand, is the distance between two consecutive points on a wave that are in phase. In simple terms, it is the length of one complete wave cycle.

2. How is wavelength measured?

Wavelength is typically measured in meters, and it can be measured in various ways depending on the type of wave. For electromagnetic waves, it can be measured using a ruler or a specialized device called a spectrophotometer. For sound waves, it can be measured using a microphone and analyzing software.

3. Can you accurately measure wave properties but still get the wavelength wrong?

Yes, it is possible to accurately measure other wave properties, such as amplitude and frequency, but still get the wavelength wrong. This can happen if there is interference or diffraction of the wave, making it difficult to determine the exact wavelength.

4. Why is knowing the correct wavelength important in scientific research?

Wavelength is a crucial factor in understanding and studying waves. It helps in determining the nature of the wave, its behavior, and its interaction with its surroundings. In fields such as physics and astronomy, knowing the correct wavelength is essential in analyzing data and making accurate predictions and calculations.

5. Are there any potential sources of error when measuring wavelength?

Yes, there are several potential sources of error when measuring wavelength. These can include equipment limitations, human error, and environmental factors that can affect the wave's behavior. It is essential to carefully consider and control these factors to obtain accurate measurements of wavelength.

Similar threads

  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
3K
Replies
15
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
10
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
907
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
5K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
4K
Back
Top