Captain America Scene Question

  • Level: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter Sang Ho Lee
  • Start date
1 reply · 3K views · last reply
Sang Ho Lee
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
I was watching Captain America: Winter Solider and was a bit confused with the scene.
I am a high school student who just learned mechanics, and I hope you guys will be able to give me an answer.

Four-panel film still: two armed men on an elevated road beside a black SUV; a man in a round shield crouching on the road, with cars nearby; a close view of the round red, white and blue shield; a large fiery explosion beside a silver car.


Looking at the photo, Bucky shoots a granade catrage, not moving a little bit, while Captain protects himself from the blast and flies off by like 20m until he crashes into a bus.

Wouldn't the conservation of momentum (m1v1 = m2v2) cause Captain to move as much as Bucky did (guessing less because probably m(captain)>m(Bucky))

If not, how does the explosion cause him to fly off?

Thank you,
 
Attachments
  • Still from a film showing a man in black tactical gear aiming a rifle along a highway overpass, with a second man in a dark jacket standing behind him beside a black SUV.
    Captain America The Winter Soldier 2014 720p Bluray DTS x264-PSYPHER.mkv_20160511_232722.553.jpg
    28.3 KB · Views: 762
  • Still from a film showing a man in black tactical gear aiming a rifle on an elevated road, with a second man in a dark jacket standing beside a black Hummer SUV and a concrete barrier in the foreground.
    Captain America The Winter Soldier 2014 720p Bluray DTS x264-PSYPHER.mkv_20160511_232722.553.jpg
    28.3 KB · Views: 589
  • Film still of a man in black tactical gear with a metal prosthetic arm aiming a rifle on an elevated road, with a second man in a dark jacket standing beside him, a black Hummer SUV behind them, and a grey car on the left.
    Captain America The Winter Soldier 2014 720p Bluray DTS x264-PSYPHER.mkv_20160511_232722.553.jpg
    28.3 KB · Views: 557
  • Four-panel film still: a man in dark tactical gear and a masked figure stand by a black Hummer, a man crouches behind a round blue-and-red shield on a highway, a close view of the shield's star, and a fiery explosion beside a silver car.
    Untitled-1.jpg
    29.8 KB · Views: 706
If the grenade were a simple projectile that was stopped dead by Captain America's shield then the simple ##m_1v_1 = m_2v_2## would apply. The recoil from the weapon would be equal to the momentum imparted to the target. However, the grenade does not stop dead. It explodes. Half of the blast goes back in the general direction of the firing position. Half impacts the shield and is stopped. It is the recoil from the high speed gasses expanding back toward the target that drives Captain America away.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Anuran Pal and Karan Punjabi