Cold Weather Makes Snow Squeak: The Science Behind It

  • Context: High School 
  • Thread starter Thread starter AEM
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Cold Science Weather
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the phenomenon of snow making different sounds depending on temperature, particularly focusing on the squeaking sound observed in very cold conditions. Participants explore the scientific reasoning behind this auditory effect, including the physical properties of snow and ice at varying temperatures.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants note that snow produces a qualitatively different sound at lower temperatures, with noticeable squeaking starting around -10 degrees Fahrenheit.
  • One participant suggests that the sound is related to the friction between ice grains, which increases as temperatures drop, leading to louder noises when snow is compressed.
  • Another participant references a source indicating that at colder temperatures, snow becomes drier, which may contribute to the increased noise from crushing ice crystals.
  • There is mention of a temperature range where snow produces different sounds: a "crunch" sound between 0 to 20 degrees Fahrenheit and a "squeak" sound below zero degrees Fahrenheit.
  • One participant shares personal observations about the sound of snow at various temperatures, indicating a subjective experience of the phenomenon.
  • A participant introduces the idea that different ski wax formulations are used for varying temperatures, although details are not provided.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree that temperature affects the sound produced by snow, but there are multiple explanations offered for why this occurs. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the precise mechanisms and conditions that lead to these auditory differences.

Contextual Notes

Some assumptions about the physical properties of snow and ice, as well as the specific temperature thresholds for sound changes, are not fully explored or quantified. The discussion also reflects personal experiences that may vary widely.

Who May Find This Useful

Individuals interested in the physics of sound, snow properties, winter sports, or those curious about environmental phenomena may find this discussion relevant.

AEM
Messages
360
Reaction score
1
Right now it's a bit chilly in the upper midwest (-21 degrees this morning at 6:00 am; -23 degrees predicted for tonight). When walking our dog this afternoon, my wife and I noticed that the snow underfoot squeaked louder that usual. We observe that snow makes a qualitatively different sound depending on temperature with the most noticeable squeaking starting at about -10 degrees. (All degrees in this post are Farenheit.) Why should the sound made when walking on snow depend on temperature, and why should it appear louder the lower temperature?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Everything you ever wanted to know about snow
http://nsidc.colorado.edu/snow/faq.html

Why does snow crunch when you step on it?
At what temperature does it crunch?

A layer of snow is made up of ice grains with air in between the ice grains. Because the snow layer is mostly empty air space, when you step on a layer of snow you compress that layer a little or a lot, depending on how old the snow is. As the snow compresses, the ice grains rub against each other. This creates friction or resistance; the colder the temperature, the greater the friction between the grains of ice. The sudden squashing of the snow at lower temperatures produces the familiar creaking or crunching sound. At warmer temperatures, closer to melting, this friction is reduced to the point where the sliding of the grains against each other produces little or no noise. It's difficult to say at what temperature the snow starts to crunch, but the colder the snow, the louder the crunch.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
AEM said:
Right now it's a bit chilly in the upper midwest (-21 degrees this morning at 6:00 am; -23 degrees predicted for tonight). When walking our dog this afternoon, my wife and I noticed that the snow underfoot squeaked louder that usual. We observe that snow makes a qualitatively different sound depending on temperature with the most noticeable squeaking starting at about -10 degrees. (All degrees in this post are Farenheit.) Why should the sound made when walking on snow depend on temperature, and why should it appear louder the lower temperature?
I suppose this site offers as good an explanation I can find:
http://cimss.ssec.wisc.edu/wxwise/squeak.html

Apparently, at the colder temps, the water in the snow freezes, and thus becomes a dry (i.e, water in its frozen state) snow, causing crushing of the ice crystals , and hence, more noise as you walk on it; also, the sound is not absorbed as well as a fresh fallen snow, so the sound is louder. I've noticed, however, that when the temperature is around 20 to 30 degrees or more, degrees F, the snow is relatively quiet when you walk on it; in the 0 to 20 degree range, degrees F, you get a "crunch,crunch" sound; and when the temperature drops below zero, you get that "squeak, squeak" sound. I'll check it out tomorrow morning when the temperature is expected to drop to 5 below in these parts. Interesting!
 
Thanks for the feedback and links. My wife (who is an applied mathematician) and I had surmised the answer, but it's nice to have confirmation. Stay warm!
 
Interesting links. I also know that different ski wax formulations are used for different temperatures- don't know any real details, other than they are different colors.