- 22,340
- 7,138
I changed the title, which is now more on-topic.
I'm going to join a friend making some homebrew this weekend - probably a Porter.
I'm going to join a friend making some homebrew this weekend - probably a Porter.
Astronuc said:I changed the title, which is now more on-topic.
I'm going to join a friend making some homebrew this weekend - probably a Porter.
Astronuc said:I changed the title, which is now more on-topic.
I'm going to join a friend making some homebrew this weekend - probably a Porter.
dlgoff said:8% or greater? Are you close to Kansas? If so, I'll be right over. :!)
This is outstanding info. You might have actually convinced me to look into this. Heck, I live near two grain elevators where you can get almost every kind of grain you want (Kansas grown). Since I like the Golden Wheat State microbrewery stuff, I wouldn't need barley. Or would I? Seems like I remember hearing you need both (wheat and barley)?Insanity said:Relatively close I suppose yes, if Michigan is close. Waiting to thaw out to brew again.
my barley wine is 11.5% I've made mead at 12.5%
want to attempt an all-grain to get over 20%.
Room shouldn't be a problem. I always cold-brewed my beers using Blue Ribbon barley malt and sometimes an admixture of Blue Ribbon corn malt. You need to boil some of the water, in order to dissolve the sugar and malt, then combine that mix with more water, yeast (after the water cools), hops, etc in your crock. It's easy, consistent, and rewarding.dlgoff said:This is outstanding info. You might have actually convinced me to look into this. Heck, I live near two grain elevators where you can get almost every kind of grain you want (Kansas grown). Since I like the Golden Wheat State microbrewery stuff, I wouldn't need barley. Or would I? Seems like I remember hearing you need both (wheat and barley)?
I'll do a little internet research in the meantime. I do have some pumps, solenoid valves, etc that might come in handy. My problem will be the space to do the process.
I don't know yet. My friend, who is also an officemate, has already picked out the recipe and ingredients. His last porter was really good.nismaratwork said:A porter! Ooooohh... what kind of profile are you looking for? Agressive hopping, or more malt and nut/coffee flavor? Porter is SOOOOO good (Otter Creek StovePipe Porter being an example)
dlgoff said:This is outstanding info. You might have actually convinced me to look into this. Heck, I live near two grain elevators where you can get almost every kind of grain you want (Kansas grown). Since I like the Golden Wheat State microbrewery stuff, I wouldn't need barley. Or would I? Seems like I remember hearing you need both (wheat and barley)?
I'll do a little internet research in the meantime. I do have some pumps, solenoid valves, etc that might come in handy. My problem will be the space to do the process.
turbo-1 said:Room shouldn't be a problem. I always cold-brewed my beers using Blue Ribbon barley malt and sometimes an admixture of Blue Ribbon corn malt. You need to boil some of the water, in order to dissolve the sugar and malt, then combine that mix with more water, yeast (after the water cools), hops, etc in your crock. It's easy, consistent, and rewarding.
If you want to get 'way back to the basics and start milling and cooking your own grains, etc, then you might need more resources, but if you start with sugar, canned malts, yeast, and hops, you can keep it simple.
Insanity said:beer can be made from almost any grain, so long the starches are converted into sugars somehow.
Barley and wheat I know have enough enzymes in the grain itself for it to convert when mashed in hot water. Other grains may need extra enzyme for the conversion, which you can get from a liquid extract or from mashing it with a grain that has enough enzymes, such as barley.
Of all the grains, barley, I believe, is the most desirable, due to starch content, enzyme content, and the husk.
A brew can be 100% barley or 100% wheat or any ratio in between and you can add other grains as well. There is what is called the grain bill, which the % that each type of grain makes the brew. Most brewing supply stores carry specialty grains, which can be a grain other then barley or wheat, or a variation of those two.
Pumps and valves maybe to much initially, everything that comes in contact with the beer before fermentation should be sanitized. The more little things you have, the more you'll need to sanitize, and the more complicated a thing it is, the more likely it may break.
I get along fine with ball valves on my kettles, just open it and it flows. Gravity does the work.
Unless the grains you get are already malted, you'll have to do that too, and that's challenging. I'd suggest buying malted grains from a brewing place, then from a grain elevator. Unmalted grain won't ferment, or very poorly if it does.
The Golden Wheat is about 25% wheat, and is fashioned after a Koelsch, very light colored beer, prominent hoppiness.
http://www.homebrewersassociation.org/pages/government-affairs/statutes
Astronuc said:I don't know yet. My friend, who is also an officemate, has already picked out the recipe and ingredients. His last porter was really good.
I'd like it to be like Anchor Porter or Samuel Adams Honey Porter.
The other night, we had an after hours business development and beer tasting meeting.
We compared Smuttynose Robust Porter, Otter Creek Stovepipe Porter, Anchor Porter and Guinness Stout. The Smuttynose was hoppy, the Stovepipe was smooth, the Anchor was sweeter than the other two, and the Guinness rounded out the meeting, and was the last one.
At the moment, I'm testing Saranac Imperial Stout which has a nice taste and creamy texture.
We will be doing more testing this weekend.
Insanity said:Kansas, correct? Looks like no limit on volume, but cannot distill.
Barley wine is made from malted grains, so it is a beer, but its ABV is as high or higher then wines, so its called a barley wine.
dlgoff said:Thank you Insanity. I'm glad you found Physicsforums.
I'll probably have some questions once I get started.
Oh, and thank you Astronuc for starting this thread.
I'll certainly keep that in mind.nismaratwork said:I'm not trying to dissuade you, far from it, just avoid the mistake I (and others) have made: do not over-sugar for the final stage of carbonation. Nothing sucks more than exploding bottles, and while I never brewed again (impracticle given my low consumption), my friend did not.
Any time and effort is worth crafting your own favorite beers, much as bread is best when made with skill and at home.
dlgoff said:I'll certainly keep that in mind.
As to exploding. Been there, done that. Believe it or not, I started fermenting fruit juices as a preteen. Boy did I get into trouble when a couple of quart jars exploded. Dad made me pour is all out (and there were several gallons) but I snuck a few quarts outside and put in a snow drift. It was a nice winter. Dad would kill me if he knew that.
If I'm ever incarcerated I'll have it made.nismaratwork said:Excellent! You made Pruno as a kid! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pruno
Me, either. I used way more sugar and malt than most in the initial fermentations, worked them down until the ferrmenting beer was flat (no more bubbles) and then decanted the beer into old swirl Pepsi bottles (very tough bottles) loaded with more sugar syrup before capping.Insanity said:I've never had any bottles explode.
Astronuc said:So we brewed a batch of porter this evening.
http://www.capecodbeer.com/brewery/wp-content/uploads/2010/05/Recipe_porter.pdf
For more ideas
http://www.capecodbeer.com/brewery/index.php/cape-cod-homebrew-supply/beer-making/
http://www.capecodbeer.com/brewery/index.php/category/recipes/
And we talked about beer making, the economy and investing, and seriously buying some land for growing grain and hops.
My friend and officemate has a great reference book:
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B003CNQ4OS/?tag=pfamazon01-20
http://www.radicalbrewing.com/
And we tasted several porters and stouts, and Ayinger Celebrator, which is a Bavarian Doppelbock, and which must be a Schwarzbier.
Insanity said:I got some data from the USDA, for lb yield per acre for several grains.
Barley = 2,510 lb/acre
Wheat = 2,143 lb/acre
Corn = 6,825 lb/acre
Rye = 1,310 lb/acre
Oats = 1,700 lb/acre
Rice = 6,647 lb/acre
To get 5 gallons of a beer at ~4.5% ABV needs ~8.5 lbs of barley/wheat.
An acre, growing several types should do anyone fine.
dlgoff said:Growing is going to be out of the question. Thank god I live where grain is grown, even though I'll probably have to do some looking when it come to Barley, Rye and Hops. Everything else I can get from the grain elevators in 50 lb sacks.
I've got lots of learning to do.
I remember talk between Turbo-1 and Astronuc, a couple of years ago, about trying to grow hops up there in Maine.nismaratwork said:...but Hops... hops you're best served by going to a brewing store; they're going to have the best selection for all kinds of hopping, up to and including aggressive dry hopping.
dlgoff said:I remember talk between Turbo-1 and Astronuc, a couple of years ago, about trying to grow hops up there in Maine.
If Astronuc or Turbo ever gets into the business of hops, they can put me on their buyers list.
Thanks for the info nismaratwork.
Norman said:So next weekend, I will be heading out to Big Sky, MT for a conference. Why post in this thread about? Well, I plan on partaking in a bunch of Western Craft beers. Specifically, I want to check out Big Sky Brewing company. Here is there beer lineup: http://www.bigskybrew.com/Our_Beers
I really want to check out their brown ale, Moose Drool.
Anyone have any experience with Montana craft beers? Or just beers only found west of the Mississippi? I tend to stay away from IPAs, but everything else is on the table for me. So, any recommendations would be appreciated.
nismaratwork said:Oh you can definitely grow hops... it's related to cannabis, but generally is grown in a trellice. Quite fragrant though, so if you don't like the smell that can be an issue,... but then, who doesn't love that musky, bitter, citrus smell?
Insanity said:Hops grow quite well, during the growing season they can add 18 inches a day.
I know a few people here in Michigan that grow their own, some strains are very hardy, specifically the Cascade and Centennial hops. My college friend had started those two plus Saaz and another European strain, and the two European ones got ravaged by japanese beetles, but the American strains were untouched. Each year he cuts them back to the ground, covers them with leaves and they survive the winter fine. He says they are quite hardy, almost kudzu-ish.
Yes, Hops and Cannabis belong to the same plant family, Cannabaceae, which also includes hackberries.
Hops are also relatively new in brewing within the last few centuries I think, various spices and herbs were used to add flavor to beer before the usage of hops. There still is a style called gruit, which does not use any hops. This summer friend of mine brewed one, he used lemongrass, nutmeg, allspice and a few other herbs. Smelled awesome, and many people he should use it to cook a chicken with.
Insanity said:I don't think they really require anything more then slightly raised bed to allow some drainage. The local brew supply place sells the rhizomes in the springtime, I thought I might get some of cascade and centennial, the most common used, and see if I can start some of my own. I am sure fertilizing each season wouldn't hurt, composed manure. I'll ask my friend.
Dealing with the vines is the bigger challenge. My friend usually goes out each day during the growing season and ties down the vines so they don't go everywhere, and I believe he has some growing up a gazebo, and then a trellis on the side of his house. As the vines can reach a length of 20ft, even during their first growing season, you need space for them. He usually gets several pounds of hop flowers from each vine, so a fair amount, enough for homebrewing. A good pale ale doesn't need more then an ounce per 5 gallons usually. IPAs might take 3-5 oz depending on how bitter you want it. Each strain of hops has a range of percentage of the alpha acid, which provides the bitterness, and that can vary from season to season. Cascade and Centennial are usually high in alpha acids, 5.75% - 10%. There is math to figure out how much to use to hit a target bitterness, or IBU (International Bitterness Unit).
I've spent many hours reading books on beer making, and belong to a local brewing club. Kinda unique among my brewing club as I have a bio/chem degree and am perfectly willing to study and learn it, and know there is a science behind the art of brewing. Some of the best homebrewers out there are engineers or scientists.
Charlie Papazian is notable for his book The Complete Joy of Homebrewing. and is current president of the Brewers Association, he is a nuclear engineer.
Ray Daniels wrote Designing Great Beers, he holds a degree in Biochemistry and has won numerous awards at beer competitions.
For those looking to seriously get into homebrewing and making good brew, I highly recommending getting these two books. Charlie's I think is the best intro into homebrewing and Ray's is great for looking at the many different styles and how to make them.
John Palmer wrote How to Brew, he is a metallurgist, he also made a sliderule to do gravity/volume conversion and IBU calculations with. Got this for Xmas this past.
Maybe I'll get a list of the books I own on homebrewing.
nismaratwork said:Oh you can definitely grow hops... it's related to cannabis, but generally is grown in a trellice. Quite fragrant though, so if you don't like the smell that can be an issue,... but then, who doesn't love that musky, bitter, citrus smell?
nismaratwork said:What kind of soil do you need to grow them, and how does it effect flavor and aroma? You seem to really know your stuff!
dlgoff said:Well then. I certainly have the space. Sounds like more research.
Great question. I guessing that since cannabis grows wild everywhere around here (mainly around rail ways where it was shipped for hemp products during WWII), hops should do well here.
And I agree about Insanity knowing his stuff. Maybe PF should have a new category for the annual awards. A BEER GURU award would definitely go to him.
dlgoff said:I also checked into home brewing suppliers here in Kansas and there are three. One is just about 20 miles down the road in north Topeka. Yea!
http://www.homebrewersassociation.org/pages/directories/find-a-club
http://www.homebrewersassociation.org/pages/directories/find-a-supply-shop
dlgoff said:There must be something wrong with me. I went all weekend without a beer; and I had those two six packs of Wheat State Golden that I wanted to try.
It's noon her now so I'm catching up for lost time.
BTW There's only one liquor store that carries Free State microbrewery beer in Lawrence, so far. It was less than $4/6-pack which is much cheaper than the growler route and taste great.
I also checked into home brewing suppliers here in Kansas and there are three. One is just about 20 miles down the road in north Topeka. Yea!
Insanity said:Pick the one that knows the alpha acid % (AA%) of their hops and that the hops are refrigerated. Any place that doesn't know the AA% shouldn't be open in many brewers opinions. A good place also has a grain mill to crush the grains there. Crushing grains without one is quite difficult.
Find a local club.
Code:http://www.homebrewersassociation.org/pages/directories/find-a-club
Find a local supply shop
Code:http://www.homebrewersassociation.org/pages/directories/find-a-supply-shop
Insanity said:When I've gotten 55# bags of pale malt, is usually comes crushed, but specialty grains are usually sold in 1#, 3#, 10#.
There has been occasions where I forgot to get the grains crushed, and as I don't yet have my own mill, the alternate to use a rolling pin, and even 2# is rough.
Having a variety of hops, grains and yeast is nice. The yeast is what really makes the beer. You can use the same amount of grains and hops, but use two different yeast and each beer will differ.
[PLAIN]http://www.whitelabs.com/beer/homebrew_strains.html[/PLAIN]
http://www.wyeastlab.com/hb_yeaststrain.cfm
Insanity said:I think the yeast is more important in brewing then most people realize, and there are many different strains of yeast used in brewing aside from the broad ale and lager categories.
White Labs and Wyeast Labs are pretty much the top two labs for producing yeast for fermentation of beer, ciders and wine. Both have about 50 different yeast strains, that can differ in alcohol tolerance, attenuation, flavor profile, etc...
Which is great, because if you want to make a dry irish stout, you can use an irish yeast.
Code:[PLAIN]http://www.whitelabs.com/beer/homebrew_strains.html[/PLAIN] http://www.wyeastlab.com/hb_yeaststrain.cfm
I have read that the Belgium trappist breweries are so particular, that when they will select their yeast cell by cell under a microscope to choose which ones are used to establish their "base".
nismaratwork said:AFAIK you're right about hops, and I think some true Lambics are also unhopped. 18 inches though? Fantastic!
What kind of soil do you need to grow them, and how does it effect flavor and aroma? You seem to really know your stuff!
Insanity said:I asked my friend about what he does for his hops each year, and he says he throws a heaping pile of fresh compost from his compost pile and then uses a light 1/5 strength miracle grow when they start to flower.
Norman said:The more I think about it, the more interested I would be in getting into homebrewing.
The only reservation I have about it is trying to regulate the temperature during fermentation. How do people typically do this? I doubt my wife would let me do the fermentation in the house... My house is horribly insulated anyways. Wild temperature variations in winter when I turn the heat way down while we are at work. I don't have a basement and my garage is not connected to the house nor is it heated.
[PLAIN]http://www.northernbrewer.com/brewing/brewing-equipment/fermenting-equipment/fermentation-temperature-control