News Cried about the carpet bombing of civilians

  • Thread starter Thread starter Alias
  • Start date Start date
Click For Summary
The discussion centers on contrasting views regarding the Iraq War and its aftermath. Participants debate the initial fears of civilian casualties and high coalition soldier deaths, which did not materialize as expected, and highlight the joy of some Iraqis at Saddam's downfall. Critics argue that the war was unjustified and that the U.S. has caused civilian harm, while supporters claim the intervention was necessary to liberate Iraq from a brutal regime. The conversation also touches on the political implications of the war, with some asserting that the military success could influence future elections. Ultimately, the thread reflects deep divisions in opinion about the war's justification and consequences.
  • #61
Originally posted by russ_watters
Yeah. Should I follow your lead?

I believe I DID state in another thread that it was a mistake to not send a better occupation force in sooner. Its a catch-22 though - clamp down too tight and the anti-US crowd (you) will claim we are there to occupy them. I believe it was a calculated political move when it shouldn't have been.

So, whole truth, eh: is there anything good that you see coming out of this war? Anything at all? Only ONE of us has been acknowledging that there are two sides to every story.

Go ahead Russ, turn off your brain by calling me 'anti-US' again, because i don't look at the world through rose-colored glasses. You only see the 'good', what little there is of it. There are so many negative aspects to American foreign policy in general, that you simply ignore in your fervor to 'support' America no matter what.

You are like a mother of a death row inmate, screaming about how wonderful her murdering son is.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #62
Originally posted by GlamGein
Alias:
No, the fact remains that GB is the person responsible for Saddam, and why is a little conspiracy so hard for you to believe?
No what? It's you that is hard to believe.
GWB admits he is a member of the society of the skull and bones, which some say controls the entire world...
If he "controls the entire world", why does he need the US Military to get his way? What, are you four??
some say GB forced Regan to accept him as running mate, and OTHERS say the assassination attempt of president regan was NO coincidence...
Some say not tossing salad is hazardous to your health.
A little conspiracy here and there never hurt anyone.
All hail the Evil One, George Bush! Hail George Bush!
 
  • #63
Originally posted by Zero
Go ahead Russ, turn off your brain by calling me 'anti-US' again, because i don't look at the world through rose-colored glasses.
I think it is self evident - if you are against the policies and/or actions of the US, you are anti-us. Thats kinda the definition.

You can differentiate that from "anti-american."
 
  • #64
Originally posted by russ_watters
I think it is self evident - if you are against the policies and/or actions of the US, you are anti-us. Thats kinda the definition.

You can differentiate that from "anti-american."


The current administration is not the country, boss...elsewise, all those who attacked Clinton based on lies(Rush Limbaugh, for instance), should be considered traitors.
 
  • #65
Originally posted by Zero
The current administration is not the country, boss...elsewise, all those who attacked Clinton based on lies(Rush Limbaugh, for instance), should be considered traitors.
Quite wrong. The current administration sets most of the official policies of the USA. virtually all of the foreign policy for example comes directly from the president or from people he personally appointed to represent him. When an ambassador goes to another country, he's a representative of the President himself. The war we just fought was Bush's policy.

Now if you oppose Bush's tax plan for example, then you do not oppose the official policy of the USA since Bush doesn't have the authority to set that policy. See the difference?

And there isn't anything impeachable about what Bush has done - otherwise the democrats would be pushing to impeach him. Also, there is nothing traitorous about opposing a policy.
 
  • #66
Russ, Ihave no idea what you are talking about...how is opposing Bush and his anti-American cabal the same as opposing the country?
 
  • #67
well i know how everyone hates it when someone starts making nazi comparisons, but it is basically the same as how it was considered an outright crime against the homeland if you opposed Hitler. i mean at other points in history it has been perfectly fine to disagree with the administration, but when the country is worked up into a heathenist frenzy it is a whole different story; anything even boarding on dissent becomes essentially the antitheses of apple pie and baseball.
 
  • #68
That's like people saying that calling Bush a slacker gives aid to terrorists...no, in real life, aid would be money or food. Only in some sort of Orwellian nightmare word does criticism of one person equal support of another.
 
  • #69
well i know how everyone hates it when someone starts making nazi comparisons, but it is basically the same as how it was considered an outright crime against the homeland if you opposed Hitler.
Yeah, basically. In Nazi Germany if you openly opposed Hitler, the SS came to your door at 5am to drag you away to a death camp. Now, if you openly oppose Bush, some conservatives call you a dirty hippie and say you're unpatriotic.

Exactly the same thing. <rolls eyes>
 
  • #70
Originally posted by damgo
Yeah, basically. In Nazi Germany if you openly opposed Hitler, the SS came to your door at 5am to drag you away to a death camp. Now, if you openly oppose Bush, some conservatives call you a dirty hippie and say you're unpatriotic.

Exactly the same thing. <rolls eyes>

LOL, the ATTITUDE is similar...and, after all, like the right-wing media has been screaming; do you wait until they do act before responding, or do you nip it in the bud early, before the damage is done?
 
  • #71
well damgo, i was referring to the earlier stages prior to the death camps. but you might want to stop rolling your eyes and break out a dictionary to understand the difference between the terms "basically" and "exactly", it would be more productive. :wink:
 
  • #72
:wink: Yeah, I see the parallel... isn't there even some famous quote by a Nazi about all governments using patriotism in wartime to demonize political opponents? Was that your sig I saw that in kyleb?
 
  • #73
Mind you... seeing that Zero allowed this entire thread which is based on gloating and ridiculing of other people's reviews, it's pretty stupid accusing him of being too strict in his role as moderator here, or abusing his power. Hmm...
 
  • #74
Originally posted by FZ+
Mind you... seeing that Zero allowed this entire thread which is based on gloating and ridiculing of other people's reviews, it's pretty stupid accusing him of being too strict in his role as moderator here, or abusing his power. Hmm...

The complaining about me 'abusing power' isn't about reality. It is about claiming victim status to get special treatment, a classic strategy. For the most part, one side feels like if it has to compromise, it is being suppressed. It is the same way that some Christian groups claim that their rights are being taken away if they cannot force their views on others 24/7 in every public forum.
 
  • #75
i think this thread has gone on long enough as i see it drifting way off topic...zero, sting, are you with me in closing it?
 
  • #76
Originally posted by Kerrie
i think this thread has gone on long enough as i see it drifting way off topic...zero, sting, are you with me in closing it?

I dunno...yeah, why not? And, you could show me how to close one, if you aren't too busy?
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 62 ·
3
Replies
62
Views
10K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 52 ·
2
Replies
52
Views
7K
Replies
8
Views
4K
Replies
8
Views
5K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • · Replies 39 ·
2
Replies
39
Views
5K
  • · Replies 91 ·
4
Replies
91
Views
9K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
4K