Dancing bees and the position of the sun

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion centers around the navigation methods of bees, particularly how they use the position of the sun and their hive location to communicate the direction of pollen sources. Participants explore the implications of the sun's position in the Northern Hemisphere and its effects on bee behavior, especially in relation to the concept of the sun being directly overhead.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested
  • Technical explanation

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants note that in the tropics, the sun can be directly overhead at noon on certain days, while others argue that outside the tropics, this is never the case.
  • One participant questions how bees navigate on cloudy days, suggesting it may relate to the polarization of light.
  • A beekeeper proposes that the bee dance is more about the location of the hive rather than the sun's position, as the hive's location is a constant reference point.
  • Another beekeeper challenges the idea that the dance relates to the sun, emphasizing that it would complicate navigation due to the sun's changing position throughout the day.
  • Some participants express skepticism about the sun being a stronger factor in navigation, suggesting that both the sun's position and the hive's location should be considered as conjecture.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants do not reach a consensus on whether the bee dance primarily relates to the sun's position or the hive's location. Multiple competing views remain regarding the navigation methods of bees and the factors influencing their communication.

Contextual Notes

There are unresolved questions about the specific mechanisms bees use for navigation, particularly in varying environmental conditions such as cloud cover. The discussion also highlights the need for empirical evidence to support claims about the influence of the sun versus the hive location.

nobahar
Messages
482
Reaction score
2
Hello!
I moved this at the recommendation of another mamber (namely, Andre).
I have a question regarding the position of the sun in the sky.
Since it depends on where you are, I am thinking of the Northern hemisphere above the Tropic of Cancer. Say, Northern Europe, Canada, etc.
As the sun moves across the sky, at noon the sun is often referred to as being directly overhead (during certain times of the year). Indeed, it looks as though it is, and shadows seem to suggest that this is the case. However, this would require the suns rays to be perpendicular with the surface of the Earth in these regions. From my reading, I believe that this is never the case.
I ask this because I was reading about dancing bees: bees communicate where pollen is to there friends by dancing. They dance inside the hive on a vertical 'column'. The vertical upwards refers to the position of the sun, and if the bee dances at some angle, say x, to the left of this vertical, it indicates that the pollen is in the direction of angle x, left from the sun in the horizontal plane. In other words, a bee may go outside the hive and face in the direction of the sun. The sun may be up in the sky, not on the horizon, but a line could be drawn, vertically, from the sun onto the horizon, and the location of the pollen would be x degrees to the left of this line. I hope that makes sense.
Now, if the sun is 'directly above', the bee will not be able to establish a bearing. So I was wondering, is the sun ever going to be directly above? I don't think so. But can anyone help with this?
Many thanks!
 
Biology news on Phys.org
in the tropics it will be directly overhead at noon on certain days.

I wonder what bees do when its too cloudy to find the sun
 
The Tropic of Capricorn and Tropic of Cancer (both at 23.5 degrees from the equator) define the limits of an overhead sun. Outside this region, the sun is never directly overhead.
 
Thanks for the response Dave.
Yes, the tropics came up in this post when it was under the Earth section. The issue then with what granpa says, about Bees in the tropics (I believe they also navigate in a similar way (they are sthe same in the important aspects: that is, naviagtion via the position of the sun) or on cloudy days, I think it may be something to do with the polarisation of light? I don't know what that means, however. I need to look it up. I was hoping for a response from someone who is familiar with bees, say a beekeeper or a biologist who has studied bees, for a definitive answer to the issue of bee dancing!
 
I am a beekeeper and I have always felt that the dance was no as much in relation to the position of the sun, but rather the location of the hive. If it was in relation to the sun it would depend on what time of day the source was discovered and what time the dance was made. The relationship of the source from the hive makes much more sense since it is a constant, for the most part. This could probably easily be tested.
 
victorg said:
I am a beekeeper and I have always felt that the dance was no as much in relation to the position of the sun, but rather the location of the hive. If it was in relation to the sun it would depend on what time of day the source was discovered and what time the dance was made. The relationship of the source from the hive makes much more sense since it is a constant, for the most part. This could probably easily be tested.

But "the location of the hive" has no angular component.

What is apianese for "go left 60 degrees from here"?
 
If a bee flys out of his hive, he knows left, right and straight, the dance tells him the relation from straight either left or right. This is always constant no matter the time of day. (IE half way between straight out and right ..would be your 45 degrees)...If the sun is used then the bees have to take into account the time of day and the season to get the postition of the sun for reference, that seems like it is an over complication.
 
seems so simple now
 
victorg said:
If a bee flys out of his hive, he knows left, right and straight, the dance tells him the relation from straight either left or right. This is always constant no matter the time of day. (IE half way between straight out and right ..would be your 45 degrees)...If the sun is used then the bees have to take into account the time of day and the season to get the postition of the sun for reference, that seems like it is an over complication.

1] You find it plausible that the "front door" of a bee hive is well-defined in location and direction.

2] You're guessing. Just because a method makes sense to you, does not mean that's how nature got it to work. Why don't we stick with what our experiments show.
 
  • #10
1) The "front door" of bee hives rarely changes it location or direction
2) It is well documented that the first flights that juvenile bees take is an orientation flight. In this first flight the go a few feet out from the hive, fly up and down, left and right, and move a little farther away and repeart. I can find documentation for this well know occurrence if necessary.
3)I haven't seen any convincing experiments for the sun being a stronger factor, so we would have to assume both are just conjecture.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
4K
  • · Replies 37 ·
2
Replies
37
Views
2K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
4K
  • · Replies 142 ·
5
Replies
142
Views
139K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
16K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
5K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
5K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
7K