Deceleration with weight and a dent? Confused

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around a physics problem involving the deceleration of a meteorite that struck a car, leaving a dent. The meteorite's weight and the depth of the dent are provided, along with its initial speed. Participants are exploring how to calculate the magnitude of deceleration under the assumption of constant deceleration.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Assumption checking, Conceptual clarification

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss various equations related to kinetic energy and force, questioning how to apply them to find deceleration. There is confusion about the role of mass and the conversion of units. Some participants suggest using kinematic equations, while others express uncertainty about the initial and final speeds and the distance traveled during deceleration.

Discussion Status

The discussion is active, with participants sharing their thought processes and calculations. Some have made progress in applying kinematic equations, while others are still clarifying concepts and definitions. There is no explicit consensus on the correct approach, but several hints and suggestions have been provided to guide the original poster.

Contextual Notes

Participants note the importance of unit conversions, particularly from pounds to kilograms and the need to establish a consistent sign convention for direction. There is also mention of significant figures in relation to the depth of the dent.

7Kings
Messages
9
Reaction score
0
Ive been trying to fiure out how to get this answer but am just have some serious trouble.

A 27 pound meteorite struck a car, leaving a dent 27 cm deep in the trunk. If the meteorite struck the car with a speed of 520 m/s, what was the magnitude of its deceleration, assuming it to be constant?

I just can't figure out how this is done. To find the magnitude of deceleration i believe i would need to divide the 520 m/s by some other time in seconds yet...there is no other time in seconds. Also, I haven't an idea what I am supposed to do with the pounds and dent. Is there a way to find out seconds from those or something? I am really stuck here. If someone could just guide me along or give me a formula to figure it how to do this it would be greatly appreciated, as I just cannot find one!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
What equations do you know?
 
You can calculate the Kinetic Energy of the meteorite prior to striking the car. Use KE = F * d to get the average force that the dent acted on the
meteorite during the impact. Once you have the average force you should
be able to calculate the deceleration.

A 27 lb object traveling at nearly the speed of a rifle bullet and a dent??
You've got to be kidding!
 
Don't forget to convert pounds to Newtons, and Newtons into kilograms.
 
What does F, and d stand for? I know KE is the kinetic energy. I did the conversion of pounds to Kilograms. It would be 12.246994 kg.

And the only equations i learned where the four kinetics equations, but i don't see how they could possibly help me yet as none of them have anything to do with mass.
 
Last edited:
F is the force in Newtons in the metric system
d is the distance in meters

F * d is the work in Joules done in stopping the meteorite which is
also equal to the Kinetic Energy of the meteorite at impact
Also, there is no use in using more significant figures than 12.2 Kg
for the mass since you are limited to 2 significant figures in the depth
of the dent.
 
7Kings said:
And the only equations i learned where the four kinetics equations, but i don't see how they could possibly help me yet as none of them have anything to do with mass.
You don't need the mass. You are given all the information needed to solve this as a kinematics problem.

Hints:
What distance does the object travel (during its deceleration)?
What are its initial and final speeds?
 
Last edited:
Thats what I am missing. I don't see where it tells me the distance the object travels, or how i can figure that out. Also, I don't see its inital speed. I just know its final speed is 520 m/s
 
Well:
1. Is the object decelerating before it hits the car?
2. How far does the object travel while it's in contact with the car?
 
  • #10
Actually, I've just made some progress. I've found out i need to use the equation

Vf^2=Vi^2+(2ad)

but I am not sure what i do next.
Was i wrong before and is the INITIAL speed 520 m/s, the FINAL speed 0 m/s?

That would have 0^2=520^2+2ad but...i don't know what the displacement is.

Oh wait, Displacement=final v-inital v. so now i have

0^2=520^2+2a(0-520)
0=270400+2a(-520)
0=270400-1040a
1040a=270400
a=260 m/s/s

Am i right or did i place something wrong? Shouldnt the acceleration be negative? Since its deceleration I am getting?

Sorry about all the editing to this but i think i got it now. I just solved for A and got:
A=(Vf^2-Vi^2)/2d
A=(0-520^2)/2*520
A=-260 m/s/s
 
Last edited:
  • #11
Ok. I don't want to keep on posting my random ideas but this time I am almost positive i did it right.
A=(Vf^2-Vi^2)/2d
A=(0-550^2)/(2*-.27) (Is the -.27 negative because its a dent so it went like..inwards kinda?)
Then you have A=500740.7407 m/sec^2 as your final answer?
 
  • #12
Sorry, sorry guys. I've just got one more thing, and i finished that question. Just the next one, its basically the same thing but I am not sure about one part of it:

Coasting due south on your bicycle at 8.0 m/s, you encounter a sandy patch of road 6.0 m across. When you leave the sandy patch your speed has been reduced to 6.6 m/s. Assuming the bicycle slows with constant acceleration, what was its acceleration in the sandy patch? Give both magnitude and direction.

So once again we use the same formula A=(Vf^2-Vi^2)/2d
A=(6.6^2-8^2)/(0-6) A=3.406 m/sec^2 due north OR
A=(6.6^2-8^2)/(6-0) A=-3.406 m/sec^2 due north

im not sure which way the displacement part of it goes but I am pretty sure my direction part of it is right, since its decelerating the direction would be the opposite. And i know, Displacement=final position-initial position...im just not sure what 6 is!
 
  • #13
7Kings said:
Ok. I don't want to keep on posting my random ideas but this time I am almost positive i did it right.
A=(Vf^2-Vi^2)/2d
A=(0-550^2)/(2*-.27) (Is the -.27 negative because its a dent so it went like..inwards kinda?)
Then you have A=500740.7407 m/sec^2 as your final answer?
That's OK, but please round it off to two significant figures.

If you are worried about the sign of your answer, you must use a sign convention consistently. If you call up positive and down negative, then:
Vi = -520 m/s
d = change in position = -0.27 m - 0 m (calling the initial position at impact = 0)

Using this convention the acceleration will end up positive (upwards), which should make sense. After all, the car pushes up on the meteorite, bringing it to rest. Since the acceleration is opposite to the velocity, the term "deceleration" is used (which just means it slows down).
 
  • #14
7Kings said:
So once again we use the same formula A=(Vf^2-Vi^2)/2d
A=(6.6^2-8^2)/(0-6) A=3.406 m/sec^2 due north OR
A=(6.6^2-8^2)/(6-0) A=-3.406 m/sec^2 due north
Realize that a negative acceleration due north means the same as saying that the acceleration is due south.

im not sure which way the displacement part of it goes but I am pretty sure my direction part of it is right, since its decelerating the direction would be the opposite. And i know, Displacement=final position-initial position...im just not sure what 6 is!
Again, pick a sign convention like I explained in my last post. Call the initial position = 0.

But you really should be able to write down the direction of the acceleration immediately, without fussing with sign conventions or equations. Hint: Is the bike slowing down or speeding up? Use the equation to get the magnitude of the acceleration, but use your understanding to assign the direction.

Of course, if you are strict with the sign convention, the equation will automatically provide the correct sign.
 
  • #15
So then are you saying that 3.406 m/s^2 due north = -3.406m/s^2 due south, since its going south?
 
Last edited:
  • #16
7Kings said:
So then are you saying that 3.406 m/s^2 due north = -3.406m/s^2 due south, since its going south?
No. I'm saying that taking negative two steps forward is the same as taking two steps backward. :wink:

The magnitude of a vector is always positive (or zero). So when you specify a vector, such as acceleration, by giving its magnitude and direction, give a positive number and a direction (never a negative number).
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
3K
Replies
6
Views
5K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
16K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
5K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
3K