Determine the Electrical potential at a given point

7 replies · 2K views · last reply
Karl Karlsson
Messages
104
Reaction score
12
Homework Statement
A rod with a circular center in the middle (which causes the rod to change direction by 90 °) has an evenly distributed linear charge density 𝜆 of electrons along the entire rod. Determine the electrical potential of the red dot in the figure below which is at the center of the circular round. The reference potential is 0 V far away from the rod.
Relevant Equations
See below
A rod with a circular center in the middle (which causes the rod to change direction by 90 °) has an evenly distributed linear charge density 𝜆 of electrons along the entire rod. Determine the electrical potential of the red dot in the figure below which is at the center of the circular round. The reference potential is 0 V far away from the rod.

Diagram of a bent charged rod: a vertical segment of length a and a horizontal segment of length a joined by a quarter-circle arc of radius R, with a red dot at the arc's center.

Given values are radius R, length a and charge density 𝜆.

My attempt:

Handwritten notebook sketch of a bent rod with arms of length a at 45 degrees to the x-axis, meeting at a point (r/√2, 0), with the origin (0,0) and point (d,0) marked, followed by handwritten Swedish notes on the electric field integral.
Handwritten derivation of an integral for electric potential along a rod, with substitution u = (2x - d)/d and the integral reduced to an arctan expression.


Sorry for writing my solution not in english but you get the idea. As one can see the integral gets very complicated when i am trying to come up with an expression for the force at point (d,0). And then i haven't even started doing the integral for the potential difference of the given point and point (d,0). There must be an easier way to solve this problem.

Thanks in beforehand!
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of a bent charged rod: a vertical segment of length a joins a horizontal segment of length a through a quarter-circle bend of radius R, with a red dot at the bend's center.
    Skärmavbild 2020-01-22 kl. 23.57.04.png
    2.5 KB · Views: 271
The problem statement is asking for the potential at the dot, not the force.

Electric potential only depends upon the distance from a given charge and is a scalar value. The zero reference is assumed to be at infinity.
 
I am not at all sure why you are concerned with the point you have labeled (d, 0). It is irrelevant. Note that the point of interest is at distance ##R## from the end of each straight segment in the perpendicular direction. Calculate the electric field vector potential contribution from one segment by integrating as suggested in the figure below, then superimpose the contribution from the other segment which has the same magnitude but different direction double it to account for the other segment, then calculate and superimpose the contribution from the quarter circle to its center.

Diagram of a thin straight rod along a horizontal line, with a point a perpendicular distance R above its left end, a segment of length dx labeled lambda dx, the distance labeled [x^2 + R^2]^(1/2), and an arrow labeled x pointing along the rod.

Note: This post has been edited following @gneill's remarks in post #4.
 
Last edited:
kuruman said:
Calculate the electric field vector contribution from one segment by integrating as suggested in the figure below, then superimpose the contribution from the other segment which has the same magnitude but different direction, then calculate and superimpose the contribution from the quarter circle to its center.
Still, the problem statement wants the electric potential at the point, not the field. Perhaps the OP (@Karl Karlsson) could confirm that the problem statement is correct?

Potential is easier to calculate since it's a scalar value, so no dealing with field component directions.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: kuruman
gneill said:
Still, the problem statement wants the electric potential at the point, not the field. Perhaps the OP (@Karl Karlsson) could confirm that the problem statement is correct?

Potential is easier to calculate since it's a scalar value, so no dealing with field component directions.
Oops, yes, it is the potential. Good catch. I looked at OP's equations with the squares in the denominator and got side-tracked to think it is the field that needs to be calculated. Yes, the potential is easier. One has to double the potential from a single segment and the quarter circle potential is trivial because all the source points on it are equidistant from the point of interest. I edited post #3.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: gneill
gneill said:
Still, the problem statement wants the electric potential at the point, not the field. Perhaps the OP (@Karl Karlsson) could confirm that the problem statement is correct?

Potential is easier to calculate since it's a scalar value, so no dealing with field component directions.
kuruman said:
Oops, yes, it is the potential. Good catch. I looked at OP's equations with the squares in the denominator and got side-tracked to think it is the field that needs to be calculated. Yes, the potential is easier. One has to double the potential from a single segment and the quarter circle potential is trivial because all the source points on it are equidistant from the point of interest. I edited post #3.

Of course now i see it, you are correct, it is much easier to calculate the potential by just plugging into the formula 1/(4pi*e0)*Q/r directly. I still get a quite difficult integral, could you review my solution, and thanks for the help!

Handwritten Swedish derivation of the electric potential at point P from a bent rod, with a small sketch of the L-shaped rod and an integral expression for V_p.
Handwritten integration working on lined paper: integral of 1/sqrt(s^2+R^2) ds with substitution s = R tan(theta), leading to ln(1/cos(theta) + tan(theta)) + C1 and then ln(sqrt(R^2+s^2)+s) + C, followed by the potential V_p expression in terms of lambda, epsilon_0 and R.


Sorry for writing the text on a non english language but i think you understand by looking att the picture i drew and the mathematical expressions and thanks again!
 
kuruman said:
Your final answer agrees with mine. Good job!
Alright must be correct then. Thanks!