Difference between Rutherford and Bohr's theory of atom

terryds

1. Homework Statement

The difference between Rutherford's and Bohr's theory of atom is ...

A. Bohr's spectrum of hydrogen atom is discrete while Rutherford's continuous
B. Bohr's stated electron goes around the nucleon while radiating energy, while Rutherford's not radiating energy.
C. Bohr's electron travels in stationary path while Rutherford's parabolic path
D. Bohr's stated stationary path has no energy, while Rutherford's path has energy
E. Bohr's electron can't switch its path, while Rutherford's electron can switch its path

2. Homework Equations

No equation

3. The Attempt at a Solution

It seems that A and C is correct, right ?
I'm confused

Related Introductory Physics Homework Help News on Phys.org

slider142

What is a "stationary path" ? Can you find any reference that cites Rutherford's belief that electrons travel in "parabolic paths" ? :-)

terryds

What is a "stationary path" ? Can you find any reference that cites Rutherford's belief that electrons travel in "parabolic paths" ? :-)
Stationary path means that the electron will not "absorbed" into the nucleon. I mean the electron will not lose its energy.
So, Rutherford didn't say that the electron travels in parabolic paths?
Hmm...
Yes, you're right. Electron travels in spiral not parabolic path

Okay, I think the answer is A. Thank you

Let'sthink

A. Bohr's spectrum of hydrogen atom is discrete while Rutherford's continuous, can be called as correct and other statements contain such terms and statements which neither Rutherford nor Bohr can think of. only a test-maker who had to some how produce a multiple choice test item.

Let'sthink

In Bohr's semi quantum approach, electron is supposed to travel in a circular path and in Rutherford's theory which is completely classical the electron will spiral into the nucleus. Spiral is a circle of continually decreasing radius.

"Difference between Rutherford and Bohr's theory of atom"

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving