Difference in clamping force between bolts and screws

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on the differences in calculating clamping force between screws that thread into a plate and bolts that use nuts. It highlights that while the clamping force calculations are fundamentally similar, screws typically experience higher torque during tightening, which can affect their clamping force. The importance of proper threaded hole depth and perpendicularity to the clamping surface is emphasized, as these factors influence the effectiveness of the fastening. Additionally, the conversation touches on the advantages of using a nut with a threaded stud for greater tension and the role of friction in both fastening methods. Ultimately, understanding these nuances is crucial for effective mechanical design and joint integrity.
chessguy103
Messages
13
Reaction score
3
TL;DR Summary
Is there a difference between clamping force calculation for screws (threaded holes) vs bolts (clearance holes + nut)?
Hi everyone,

I’m trying to figure out the clamping force of a set of screws that thread into a plate.

My question is:
  • Would this calculation differ from calculating the clamping force of a bolt with a nut?
  • What would be the difference in how the fasteners/members would react to a tensile load?
I was reading through Shigley’s mechanical engineering design chapter 8, but the chapter really focuses on bolts and not screws. Any guidance will be appreciated.

I’ve attached a picture of the basic design I’m working with.

Thanks
 

Attachments

  • 11E5460E-2910-49E2-815E-64C790EF5A23.jpeg
    11E5460E-2910-49E2-815E-64C790EF5A23.jpeg
    60.6 KB · Views: 175
Last edited:
Engineering news on Phys.org
For similar materials, clamping force should be similar.
It is important that the threaded hole is perpendicular to the clamping surface of the plate and deep enough to accommodate the bolt with plenty clearance at the bottom.
 
  • Like
Likes chessguy103
chessguy103 said:
Would this calculation differ from calculating the clamping force of a bolt with a nut?
When reading the bolt calculation chapter, look carefully at the assumptions. To oversimplify:

Something is turning against something else that is stationary.
There is friction between the turning part and the stationary part.
That friction is in the threads.
That friction is also under the bolt/screw head or nut, depending on which is turning.

If you look at it that way, the calculation for a bolt with nut is identical to the calculation for a screw into a tapped hole.

Lnewqban said:
It is important that the threaded hole is ... and deep enough to accommodate the bolt with plenty clearance at the bottom.
This is important. I once had a startup failure because of exactly this.
 
  • Like
Likes Lnewqban and chessguy103
chessguy103 said:
Summary: Is there a difference between clamping force calculation for screws (threaded holes) vs bolts (clearance holes + nut)?

I’m trying to figure out the clamping force of a set of screws that thread into a plate.
A screw is defined by the "turning of the head to increase the tension". Bolt tension is increased by turning the nut. The bolt clamping force is greater than the screw because the shank of a screw is subjected to a higher torque while being tightened than is a bolt.

There is a compromise. If a threaded hole is needed due to access restriction, then a threaded stud in that hole can be tensioned by a nut, giving the greater tension of a bolt.
 
My understanding of jonting methods is that we can either rely on friction grip bolting, where torque is very high and shank tension is somehow measured, or we assume a pin joint, where less tension is used and we provide sufficient shear strength from the bolts. I the latter case, friction plays a part but we assume pin jointing for design purposes. An advantage of this method is that critical measurements during bolt tightening are avoided, and a course thread can be used, which allows for galvanising if required. I notice for the present case that for the threaded plate, the bolt shank is subject to torque during tightening, whereas with a nut being rotated on a bolt it is not. I also notice that a nut can be provided more easily with a locking device.
 
Thread 'Where is my curb stop?'
My water meter is submerged under water for about 95% of the year. Today I took a photograph of the inside of my water meter box because today is one of the rare days that my water meter is not submerged in water. Here is the photograph that I took of my water meter with the cover on: Here is a photograph I took of my water meter with the cover off: I edited the photograph to draw a red circle around a knob on my water meter. Is that knob that I drew a red circle around my meter...
Thread 'How can I find the cleanout for my building drain?'
I am a long distance truck driver, but I recently completed a plumbing program with Stratford Career Institute. In the chapter of my textbook Repairing DWV Systems, the author says that if there is a clog in the building drain, one can clear out the clog by using a snake augur or maybe some other type of tool into the cleanout for the building drain. The author said that the cleanout for the building drain is usually near the stack. I live in a duplex townhouse. Just out of curiosity, I...
Back
Top