Differential Forms.... Another question.... Browder, Sec 13.1

2 replies · 2K views · last reply
Math Amateur
Gold Member
MHB
Messages
3,920
Reaction score
48
I am reading Andrew Browder's book: "Mathematical Analysis: An Introduction" ... ...

I am reading Chapter 13: Differential Forms ... ... and am currently focused on Section 13.1 Tensor Fields ...

I need some help in order to fully understand some statements by Browder in Section 13.1 ... ...


Section 13.1 reads as follows:
Printed page from Browder's Mathematical Analysis, Section 13.1 Tensor Fields, giving the definitions of tensor fields of rank r, differential forms of degree r, and class C^k tensor fields.

Printed textbook page from Browder's Mathematical Analysis on differential forms: text on coordinate functions, the 1-form expansion with f_j and dx^j, the r-form sum over increasing r-tuples, and the formula df = sum of partial f over partial x^j dx^j.


In the above text we read the following:

" ... ... We observe also that ##\text{dx}_P^j (h^1, \cdot \cdot \cdot , h^n) = h^j## ... ... "My question is what is the nature of the ##h^i## ... given that ##\text{dx}_P^j## is a constant mapping from an open subset ##U## of ##\mathbb{R}^n## it seems that the ##h^i## are real numbers ...

... BUT ... then it seems strange that ##\text{dx}_p^j (h^1, \cdot \cdot \cdot , h^n) = h^j## ... that is ... how can the function evaluate to a real number when it is a constant mapping into ##\mathbb{R}^{ n \ast }## ... it should evaluate to a linear functional, surely ...

... indeed ... should Browder have written ...

##\text{dx}_P^j (h^1, \cdot \cdot \cdot , h^n) = \tilde{e}^j##
Can someone please clarify the above ...

Peter
 
Attachments
  • Printed page from Browder's Mathematical Analysis, Section 13.1 Tensor Fields, giving the definitions of tensor field of rank r, differential form of degree r, and class C^k tensor field.
    Browder - Defn of a differential form .png
    59.4 KB · Views: 440
  • Printed page from Browder's Mathematical Analysis covering differential forms: dx^j as the jth coordinate function, df_p as a linear map, the expression df = sum of (D_j f) dx^j, and notation for smooth r-forms.
    Browder - 2 - Start of Section 13.1 ... ... PART 2 ... .png
    60.3 KB · Views: 407
  • Printed page of Browder's analysis text on differential forms, covering coordinate functions, 1-forms, r-forms written as sums over increasing r-tuples, and the formula for df, with a notation note on smooth forms.
    Browder - 2 - Start of Section 13.1 ... ... PART 2 ... .png
    60.3 KB · Views: 412
  • Printed page from Browder's Mathematical Analysis, Section 13.1 Tensor Fields, giving the definitions of tensor fields of rank r, differential forms of degree r, and class C^k tensor fields.
    ?temp_hash=b63a36a349d9b9bbedf37aea4772fe69.png
    59.4 KB · Views: 527
  • Printed textbook page from Browder's Mathematical Analysis on differential forms: text on coordinate functions, the 1-form expansion with f_j and dx^j, the r-form sum over increasing r-tuples, and the formula df = sum of partial f over partial x^j dx^j.
    ?temp_hash=b63a36a349d9b9bbedf37aea4772fe69.png
    60.3 KB · Views: 502
I think it really helps to distinguish between the manifold, often denoted by M, and the tangent bundle, usually denoted by TM, which is the union of all tangent spaces to points on the manifold. TM consists of vectors, whereas M consists of points that may or may not be vectors. Unfortunately, that distinction is obscured here by the author specifying that U, which is a part of the manifold, is a subset of ##\mathbb R^n##, which is a vector space as well as a manifold. Is it an old text? Newer texts tend to avoid assuming the manifold is embedded in ##\mathbb R^n##, partly to give greater generality, but also to avoid this sort of confusion.
Math Amateur said:
My question is what is the nature of the ##h^i## ... given that ##\text{dx}_P^j## is a constant mapping from an open subset ##U## of ##\mathbb{R}^n## it seems that the ##h^i## are real numbers ...
Not quite. If you look carefully, you will see that it is ##dx^j## that is a map whose domain is ##U##. That domain is part of the manifold. The function ##dx^i_{\mathbf p}## has a domain that is the tangent space ##T_{\mathbf p}M##, which is a vector space. That domain has no intersection with ##U##. That's why the argument to the function ##x^j## is given as a ##n##-tuple of numbers with lower subscripts ##(a_1,...,a_n)##, being coordinates of a manifold point, and the same applies to the argument to the function ##dx^j##. But the argument to the function ##dx^j_{\mathbf p}## has components with superscripts - ##(h^1,...,h^n)## - because they are components of a vector in the tangent space at ##\mathbf p##.
it seems strange that ##\text{dx}_p^j (h^1, \cdot \cdot \cdot , h^n) = h^j## ... that is ... how can the function evaluate to a real number when it is a constant mapping into ##\mathbb{R}^{ n \ast }## ... it should evaluate to a linear functional, surely ...

... indeed ... should Browder have written ...

##\text{dx}_P^j (h^1, \cdot \cdot \cdot , h^n) = \tilde{e}^j##
The correct expression is

##\text{dx}_P^j= \tilde{e}^j##, which is a linear functional, aka a 'one-form'.

Then when we apply it to the vector ##\vec h##, which the author writes in component form as ##(h^1,...,h^n)##, we get a real number.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Math Amateur
Thanks Andrew ...

Really appreciate your help ...

Still reflecting on what you have written ...

Your distinction between M and TM was most illuminating...

Thanks again...

Peter

NOTE: Browder's text was published in 1996