Distributing negative signs in logarithms

  • Thread starter Thread starter RChristenk
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Logarithm
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on simplifying the expression ##\log(A \times B \div C \times D)## and whether it should be interpreted as ##\log(A)+\log(B)-(\log(C)+\log(D))## or ##\log(A)+\log(B)-\log(C)+\log(D)##. Participants lean towards the latter interpretation, indicating that conventional notation typically dictates the use of parentheses to clarify the division. There is a consensus that algebra textbooks rarely utilize the division sign (##\div##) and often present such problems differently. Concerns are raised about the clarity and quality of the source material if it presents this type of problem. Clear notation is essential for accurate simplification in logarithmic expressions.
RChristenk
Messages
73
Reaction score
9
Homework Statement
Simplify ##\log(A \times B \div C \times D)##
Relevant Equations
Logarithm Rules
Simplify ##\log(A \times B \div C \times D)##

Is it ##\log(A)+\log(B)-(\log(C)+\log(D))## or ##\log(A)+\log(B)-\log(C)+\log(D)##?

I'm leaning toward the former but not sure. Thanks.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
It depends on whether the statement means
##log[\frac {ab} {cd}]## or ##log[\frac {abd} {c}]##
Normal convention says the latter so log(a)+log(b)-log(c)+log(d)
 
  • Like
Likes SammyS and RChristenk
RChristenk said:
Simplify ##\log(A \times B \div C \times D)##
I have not seen any algebra textbooks that would show problems like this. As already noted, the expression in parentheses should be written as either ##\frac{AB}C \cdot D## or as ##\frac{AB}{CD}##. Failing that, there should at least be parentheses around CD to emphasize that this is the divisor.
Is this a problem from some textbook? If so, my guess is that it is substandard or very old.
Also, algebra textbooks generally don't use the ##\div## sign.
 
Back
Top