Do all visible radiations have heat?

  • Thread starter Karimspencer
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Heat
In summary, the conversation discussed the relationship between light and heat, and whether all light carries thermal energy. It was established that heat is the flow of energy and is more specifically defined as randomly distributed, high entropy energy. Light does not carry heat directly, but can be converted to thermal energy through interactions with charged particles. It was also mentioned that the context of the situation, such as the boundaries of the system, can affect whether light is considered heat. Ultimately, the consensus was that light can contribute to heat through black body radiation, but does not directly carry thermal energy.
  • #1
Karimspencer
117
0
For example when you make a laser , does heat come with it?
 
Science news on Phys.org
  • #2
That is oddly worded, but all EM radiation carries energy, so yes.
 
  • #3
Well i don't mean radiant energy , i mean do all light have thermal energy?
 
  • #4
Are you asking all light, rather than just infra red light that we commonly call as thermal radiation?

I think the answer is yes, because I asked a similar question about a month ago and people helped clarify.

https://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=608036
 
  • #5
Your questions indicate that you are confused about what heat is. Heat is basically energy, but the exact definition depends on the physical context. If you get into the nitty gritty, heat is a pretty difficult subject.

Heat is energy that is more or less randomly distributed across all the degrees of freedom within a system. In typical terrestrial situations, that means most of the energy is in random kinetic motion of the molecules, as well as various vibrational and rotational modes of the molecules. For typical terrestrial situations, very little heat energy is in the form of light.

On the other hand, in a vacuum, most of the heat energy could be in the form of light, because without any other particles, photons are the main degrees of freedom of the system.

If you shine a light on something on Earth, then the light is not considered heat because it doesn't randomly occupy all the degrees of freedom of the air that it is traveling through. But, after the light is absorbed by various materials, it is converted to heat.
 
  • #6
Khashishi said:
Your questions indicate that you are confused about what heat is. Heat is basically energy, but the exact definition depends on the physical context. If you get into the nitty gritty, heat is a pretty difficult subject.

Heat is energy that is more or less randomly distributed across all the degrees of freedom within a system. In typical terrestrial situations, that means most of the energy is in random kinetic motion of the molecules, as well as various vibrational and rotational modes of the molecules. For typical terrestrial situations, very little heat energy is in the form of light.

On the other hand, in a vacuum, most of the heat energy could be in the form of light, because without any other particles, photons are the main degrees of freedom of the system.

If you shine a light on something on Earth, then the light is not considered heat because it doesn't randomly occupy all the degrees of freedom of the air that it is traveling through. But, after the light is absorbed by various materials, it is converted to heat.
Heat is the flow of energy I thought. As in energy transfer. Temperature, as opposed to heat, is the way to quantitatively describe energy level increase in particles after heat has been transferred, so I don't think you would say light is converted to heat, but rather converted to temperature increase. Heat would be the process of light energy converted to thermal energy, or in other words heat is the amount of energy that has been transferred to thermal energy.
 
Last edited:
  • #7
So let's say you get this laser and concentrate on a small object , will the object be heated up?
 
  • #8
Well, yes, heat is used to describe the flow of energy. But not just any energy. It describes a sort of randomly distributed, high entropy energy. Structured energy could be considered as "work" when talking about the flow of energy.
 
  • #9
So your point is that light does not carry heat at all? I think I would agree with that; its electromagnetic energy can only be converted to thermal energy by electrical interaction with charged particles, and the amount of energy converted would be considered heat transfer.
 
  • #10
Karimspencer: yes.

DragonPetter: It depends on the context. Like a lot of physics problems, it depends on where you put the boundaries of your system. I don't know if everyone agrees on this. The way I see it, blackbody radiation can be considered heat depending on how it is used. Sunlight within the Sun is heat energy, and it travels to the Earth and heats the Earth. Now, sunlight within the Earth is not in thermal equilibrium with the Earth, so, if you just consider a system including the sunlight and the Earth, then the sunlight isn't heat. But if you consider a system including the Sun, sunlight, and the Earth, then sunlight can be considered heat. Yeah, it's complicated...

The Earth emits a certain amount of infrared emission because it is warm. It also reflects a certain amount of sunlight. Viewed from afar, the infrared emission is "heat" emission from the Earth, and the reflected sunlight is not.
 
Last edited:
  • #11
I think i would disagree , a lot of visible light rays carry heat for example microwaves, the sun ..but what i want to know :"Do all light carry heat(thermal) energy?"
 
  • #12
I agree with you Khashishi
 
  • #13
I would say that if it is emitted and absorbed via black body radiation, then it transferred heat. If the intermediate form was electromagnetic rather than thermal, I'm not sure that matters - I'd want to know more about the context of the question.

Heat is the transfer of thermal energy and thermal energy is molecular vibration. Light is not molecular vibration.
 
  • #14
Okay let's say you concentrate any kind of light on an object would lt heat up russ
 
  • #15
Karim, have you ever been in a spotlight?
 
  • #16
Karimspencer said:
Okay let's say you concentrate any kind of light on an object would lt heat up russ
Not necessarily and even if it does, it wouldn't necessarily heat up in an amount equal to the light's energy. A solar panel, for example, converts some light directly into electrical energy.
 
  • #17
When you put a dark object in sunlight, its temperature and thermal energy increase. Thermodynamically the energy transfer into the object is called "work" not "heat". The alternating electric field of the light waves causes electrical forces on electrons near the surface of the material. The electrons move in response, so work is done by the electrical forces.
 
  • #18
Well what are the difference between the properties of light that carries heat and one that doesn't.
 

1. Do all visible radiations have heat?

Yes, all visible radiations have heat. Visible radiation is a form of electromagnetic radiation, and all forms of electromagnetic radiation carry energy, which can be perceived as heat.

2. Is heat the only form of energy carried by visible radiations?

No, visible radiations also carry other forms of energy such as light and infrared radiation. Heat is just one type of energy carried by visible radiations.

3. Are there different amounts of heat carried by different types of visible radiations?

Yes, different types of visible radiations carry different amounts of heat. This is because the amount of heat carried is directly related to the wavelength of the radiation. Longer wavelengths (such as those in the infrared spectrum) carry more heat compared to shorter wavelengths (such as those in the visible spectrum).

4. Can visible radiations with shorter wavelengths carry more heat than those with longer wavelengths?

No, shorter wavelengths do not necessarily carry more heat than longer wavelengths. As mentioned, the amount of heat carried is directly related to the wavelength, but there are other factors that can affect the amount of heat, such as intensity and duration of exposure.

5. Is visible radiation the only source of heat on Earth?

No, visible radiation is not the only source of heat on Earth. Other sources of heat include conduction, convection, and radiation from other wavelengths such as infrared and ultraviolet.

Similar threads

Replies
3
Views
443
  • Thermodynamics
Replies
20
Views
9K
Replies
2
Views
390
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
604
  • Thermodynamics
Replies
28
Views
1K
  • Thermodynamics
Replies
5
Views
985
Replies
14
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Thermodynamics
Replies
2
Views
649
Back
Top