Do any singularities have Infinite density

  • Thread starter jamesb-uk
  • Start date
  • #1
69
0

Main Question or Discussion Point

Do any singularities (including the big bang singularity) have:
1. Infinite density
2. Infinite mass
3. Volume
Also, based on the questions above, are naked singularities different to black hole singularities?
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
Nabeshin
Science Advisor
2,205
16


Do any singularities (including the big bang singularity) have:
1. Infinite density
2. Infinite mass
3. Volume
Also, based on the questions above, are naked singularities different to black hole singularities?
A singularity with infinite mass makes no sense, so #2 is a no.

#1 and #3 are saying the same thing, because infinite density is a finite amount of mass in a infinitesimal volume. This is the hallmark of gravitational singularities (such as those of a black hole).
 
  • #3
ZapperZ
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Education Advisor
Insights Author
35,465
4,230


Do any singularities (including the big bang singularity) have:
1. Infinite density
2. Infinite mass
3. Volume
Also, based on the questions above, are naked singularities different to black hole singularities?
The van Hove singularity satisfies none of the above description.

Zz.
 
  • #4
69
0


The van Hove singularity satisfies none of the above description.

Zz.
What is the van hove singularity?

The reason I asked whether singularities have infinite mass was because I heard that black hole singulaities have infinite space-time curvature. This doesn't seem right to me, as if that were true, wouldn't that mean the gravitational attraction of a black hole is infinite.
 
  • #5
ZapperZ
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Education Advisor
Insights Author
35,465
4,230


What is the van hove singularity?

The reason I asked whether singularities have infinite mass was because I heard that black hole singulaities have infinite space-time curvature. This doesn't seem right to me, as if that were true, wouldn't that mean the gravitational attraction of a black hole is infinite.
I'm sure you are able to do a search on this yourself.

Note that in your OP, you asked about ANY "singularity". There are a gazillion different types of "singularity", which simply means a quantity, ANY quantity, that diverges at certain values. I happen to have shown you one type of singularity in the electronic density of states.

Zz.
 
  • #6
490
2


If there was a singularity with infinite mass then all other particles in the universe would have infinite acceleration towards that singularity, which means that all stars and galaxies would be ripped to shreds in an infinitely small amount of time. The fact that I am alive and typing this message is therefore proof that no object in the universe has infinite mass.
 
  • #7
69
0


If there was a singularity with infinite mass then all other particles in the universe would have infinite acceleration towards that singularity, which means that all stars and galaxies would be ripped to shreds in an infinitely small amount of time. The fact that I am alive and typing this message is therefore proof that no object in the universe has infinite mass.
Exactly, that's why I couldn't understand the statement that singulariies have infinite space-time curvature.
 
  • #8
Nabeshin
Science Advisor
2,205
16


Exactly, that's why I couldn't understand the statement that singulariies have infinite space-time curvature.
I find the 2-D rubber sheet analogy to be a good method of resolving this.

http://cse.ssl.berkeley.edu/bmendez/ay10/2002/notes/pics/bt2lfS316_a.jpg

This site has three very good images showing various space-time curvatures of objects with the same mass* but different densities. As you can see in the black hole case, the potential well never ends, and so the curvature is said to be infinite at that point. However, it's just a local effect and far away you can see space-time is curved exactly the same as if the object was the sun.

*As per stellar evolution the masses of these three objects wouldn't be exactly the same, but they're close enough to illustrate the point.
 
  • #9
diazona
Homework Helper
2,175
6


Exactly, that's why I couldn't understand the statement that singulariies have infinite space-time curvature.
Infinite curvature results from infinite density, not infinite mass. And as previously explained, you can get infinite density when you pack any (nonzero) amount of mass into an infinitesimal (you can think of it as basically zero) volume. That's what happens in a black hole, according to general relativity.

And of course, this has also been mentioned before, but a "singularity" is really a mathematical concept that has kind of been extended to physics; it basically just describes a point where something is infinite. Black holes are not the only kind of singularity, although they're probably the most commonly discussed among physicists.
 
  • #10
diazona
Homework Helper
2,175
6


This might be interesting: the actual equation from general relativity is

[tex]R^{\mu\nu} - \frac{1}{2}g^{\mu\nu}R = 8\pi T^{\mu\nu}[/tex]

(well that's one way of writing it, if you ignore the cosmological constant). This represents 16 equations, one for each pair of values of [tex]\mu, \nu = 0, 1, 2, 3[/tex] (although some of the 16 are the same). The important point is that all that junk on the left side is, roughly speaking, a measure of the curvature of spacetime (i.e. gravity), and [tex]T^{\mu\nu}[/tex] is proportional to the density of matter - not the total mass. The actual mass doesn't appear anywhere in this equation, except as part of the density. So as long as you have infinite density, there will be a singularity (because a term in the equation is infinite), regardless of the total mass involved.
 
  • #11
Andy Resnick
Science Advisor
Education Advisor
Insights Author
7,352
1,787


Caustics have infinite energy density. Conversely, wave dislocations have zero energy density.
 

Related Threads for: Do any singularities have Infinite density

  • Last Post
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • Last Post
2
Replies
29
Views
4K
Replies
4
Views
5K
Replies
5
Views
885
  • Last Post
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
6
Views
822
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
6K
  • Last Post
Replies
4
Views
2K
Top