Dr/Dt world coordinates problem

In summary, the conversation discusses the term Dr/Dt, which is the rate of change of the position of a rigid body in world coordinates relative to the body coordinate system. This is equal to dr/dt-wxr. The question is asked about the terminology for Dr/Dt and if it has the same rules as the operator d/dt. The individual attempted to prove this but found some contradictions, citing an example with d(AxB)/dt and Dr/Dt. The notation dr^s/dt=dr^b/dt-wxr is preferred, with r^s representing the space fixed position and r^b representing the body fixed position. It is noted that the d/dt operator is the same in both cases. A
  • #1
yetar
54
0

Homework Statement


In rigid body, r is the position of a rigid body relative to world coordinates,
dr/dt is the rate of change of r in world coordinates.
I encountered the term Dr/Dt as the rate of change of r in world coordinates relative to the body coordinates system.
And that Dr/Dt = dr/dt-wxr
My question is, how does Dr/Dt is called? (terminology)
Also the operator D/Dt has the same rules as the operator d/dt, how do you proove it? There is some relationship to proove this, but what is this relation ship?


Homework Equations


Dr/Dt = dr/dt-wxr



The Attempt at a Solution


I tried to use Dr/Dt = dr/dt-wxr to proove that both operators has the same rules, but didnt succed.
In matter of fact, I found some contradiction.
For instance: d(AxB)/dt = Ax(dB/dt)+(dA/dt)xB
So D(AxB)/Dt = Ax(DB/Dt)+(DA/Dt)xB should also be true.
However using Dr/Dt = dr/dt-wxr showed that there is inequality.

Thank you.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
I prefer the notation

dr^s/dt=dr^b/dt-wxr

where r^s = space fixed r (with subscript s) and r^b = body fixed r

The d/dt operator is the same in both cases.

There's a good, but lengthy article here

http://python.rice.edu/~chem630/Polyatomics.pdf
 
  • #3


The term Dr/Dt is called the rate of change of position in world coordinates relative to the body coordinates system. This is also known as the absolute velocity of the rigid body. The operator D/Dt is called the total time derivative and it is used to describe the rate of change of a quantity with respect to time, taking into account not only the change in value but also the change in the coordinate system.

To prove that D/Dt and d/dt have the same rules, we can use the chain rule. Let's say we have a function f(x,y,z,t), where x, y, and z are coordinates in the body frame and t is time. We can express this function in terms of world coordinates as f(r,t), where r is the position vector of the body in world coordinates. Now, using the chain rule, we have:

Df/Dt = (df/dr)(dr/dt) + (df/dt)(dt/dt)

But since dt/dt = 1, we can simplify to:

Df/Dt = (df/dr)(dr/dt) + (df/dt)

This is equivalent to the rule for d/dt, where we have:

df/dt = (df/dx)(dx/dt) + (df/dy)(dy/dt) + (df/dz)(dz/dt) + (df/dt)

So, we can see that D/Dt and d/dt have the same rules, with the addition of the term (df/dt) which takes into account the change in the coordinate system. This is why Dr/Dt = dr/dt-wxr, where wxr is the cross product of the angular velocity of the body and the position vector in world coordinates.
 

1. What is the "Dr/Dt world coordinates problem"?

The "Dr/Dt world coordinates problem" refers to the challenge of accurately determining and representing the location and movements of objects in the world, particularly in relation to other objects and reference points. This problem is commonly encountered in fields such as geography, geology, and astronomy.

2. What causes the "Dr/Dt world coordinates problem"?

The "Dr/Dt world coordinates problem" arises from the fact that the Earth is constantly moving and changing, making it difficult to establish a fixed and precise reference frame. Additionally, different methods and systems for measuring and representing coordinates can also contribute to this problem.

3. How is the "Dr/Dt world coordinates problem" addressed in scientific research?

Scientists use a variety of techniques and tools to address the "Dr/Dt world coordinates problem", including advanced mapping technologies, GPS systems, and mathematical models. They also work to continuously improve and refine these methods as technology and knowledge advances.

4. What are some potential applications of solving the "Dr/Dt world coordinates problem"?

Solving the "Dr/Dt world coordinates problem" has numerous practical applications, such as accurately mapping and tracking movements of tectonic plates for earthquake prediction, monitoring changes in sea levels and ice sheets for climate research, and calculating precise satellite orbits for communication and navigation purposes.

5. What are some current challenges in addressing the "Dr/Dt world coordinates problem"?

One of the main challenges in addressing the "Dr/Dt world coordinates problem" is the constant evolution and changes of the Earth's surface, which requires ongoing updates and adjustments to coordinate systems. Additionally, the increasing amount of data and complexity of the Earth's movements also pose challenges for accurately representing and interpreting coordinates.

Similar threads

  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
6
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
3K
Replies
6
Views
6K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
572
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
10
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
732
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
10
Views
5K
Replies
1
Views
907
Back
Top