Expectation values r and x for electron in H2 ground state

5 replies · 3K views · last reply
gfd43tg
Gold Member
Messages
949
Reaction score
48

Homework Statement


Textbook problem 4.13 with parts (a) finding <r> and <r^2> for the hydrogen ground state electron in terms of the Bohr radius, (b) finding <x> and <x^2> using r^2 = x^2 + y^2 + z^2 and symmetry, and (c) finding <x^2> for n = 2, l = 1, m = 1 with the warning that this state is not symmetrical in x, y, z, using x = r sin θ cos φ.


Homework Equations


$$ \psi_{100} = \frac {1}{\sqrt{\pi a^{3}}} e^{-r/a} $$

The Attempt at a Solution


a)
$$\langle r \rangle = \frac {1}{\pi a^{3}} \int_0^{2 \pi} d \phi \int_{0}^\pi d \theta \int_0^{\infty} r^{3} e^{-2r/a} dr$$
This comes out to be ##\frac {3}{2}a##

$$\langle r^{2} \rangle = \frac {1}{\pi a^{3}} \int_0^{2 \pi} d \phi \int_{0}^\pi d \theta \int_0^{\infty} r^{4} e^{-2r/a} dr$$
Which comes out as ##3a^{2}##

b)
I know ##r^{2} = 3x^{2}##, so the answer for the expectation value of ##x^{2}## is one third the expectation value of ##r^{2}##, therefore ##\langle x^{2} \rangle = a^{2}##

However, I am confused how to find ##\langle x \rangle##. Do I just say ##x = r sin \theta##, therefore ##dx = sin \theta dr + r cos \theta d \theta##?
 
Last edited:
Yes, I am confused how to exploit the symmetry
 
Do you expect the electron to be on average more on the left or the right side? Does that question even make sense as you don't know where left and right are?
 
Okay, I suppose that makes sense, but then why would the square x coordinate not be zero then? By the same reasoning
 
Maylis said:
Okay, I suppose that makes sense, but then why would the square x coordinate not be zero then? By the same reasoning

Because a measurement of ##x^2## is positive so the expected value can't be 0.