I Faster than c communication?

  • Thread starter f todd baker
  • Start date
On my web site (unnamed since I have been previously reprimanded for "promoting" the site!) I got a question, pretty straightforward, the essence of which is: Two long wires are not parallel and make an angle θ with each other; they cross at one point and one wire is moving with velocity v perpendicular to the first; the point where they cross moves with a velocity u.
fasterthanlife.JPG


It is easy to show that u=v/tanθ and u may be larger than c. But this point has no mass and carries no information so, no problem with special relativity (just like a sweeping laser spot moving across the moon with v>c). But then I got a followup question suggesting having an array of moving wires the spacing of which is coded information. What am I missing?
 

Attachments

FactChecker

Science Advisor
Gold Member
2018 Award
4,981
1,750
If the distance between the wires changes, that change can not travel along the wire at infinite speed. In fact it is limited to c or less.
 
All wires but one are moving with the same velocity and are parallel. The distance between any two of them does not change.
 

FactChecker

Science Advisor
Gold Member
2018 Award
4,981
1,750
Oh. I missed that. There is nothing that says that information set up earlier can not be read fast. The wires that you describe can not be set up over a distance faster than c. It would take a long time to set up the parallel wires of that length. Your example is just a more complicated case of sending information and storing it in a safe in a distant location. Then the safe can be opened and read instantly. That does not mean that the information was transmitted instantly.
 
28,016
4,415
I second @FactChecker here. The information is transmitted at the time of setting up the spacing between the wires. The diagonal wire is actually completely irrelevant.
 

Ibix

Science Advisor
Insights Author
5,125
3,422
No information is being transmitted in the u direction - it's being transmitted in the v direction. It's just that observers spaced perpendicular to that get the information with different delays. The only way to communicate in the u direction is to poke one of the wires as it passes, and then this is just a complicated variant on "can I communicate faster than light by pushing a rigid rod".
 

Mister T

Science Advisor
Gold Member
2,253
635
But then I got a followup question suggesting having an array of moving wires the spacing of which is coded information. What am I missing?
The coding can't travel faster than ##c##.
 

DaveC426913

Gold Member
18,141
1,719
Though this is an idealized thought experiment: here's some practical cold water tossed on it:

The speed of transmission will be far slower than c; it is limited to the speed of sound in the material that the wires are made of.

Even if they were made of the hardest substance currently known - diamond - their best transmission speed will be only 12km/s - the speed of sound in diamond.
 

Want to reply to this thread?

"Faster than c communication?" You must log in or register to reply here.

Related Threads for: Faster than c communication?

Replies
8
Views
2K
  • Posted
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • Posted
Replies
24
Views
3K

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving

Hot Threads

Top