Find Pressure at Point A in the Manometer

1 reply · 7K views · last reply
Northbysouth
Messages
241
Reaction score
2

Homework Statement


Determine the pressure of the water in pipe A shown in the figure (p2.56) if the gage pressure of the air in the tank is 2 psi.

I have attached the image

Homework Equations


The Attempt at a Solution



Figure P2.56

I drew a jumpline at 2ft above point A because everything below point A has the same density. From here I assigned P1 to account for the pressure above the jumpline in the tank and p2 to account for the pressure in the pipe adjacent to it.

P1 = P + ρH2O*3ft

P2 = P1 + ρH2O* 4 ft

PA = P2 + ρSG*4ft

PA = ρSG*4ft + ρH2O*4ft + P + ρH2O*3ft

γH2O = 62.4 lb/ft3 taken from textbook

SG = ρfluid/ρH2O@4°

ρSG = 0.9*1.940 slug/ft3

PA = 4ft(.9*1.940 slugs/ft3) + 62.4 lb/ft3 + 2lb/in[SUP2[/SUP]*144in2/1ft2 + 62.4lb/ft3*3ft

PA = 731.784 lb/ft2

My answer should be 525 lb/ft2

I'm not sure where I've gone wrong. I realize that I have slugs in my calculation witht he pressure of the fluid with the given SG but I'm not sure how to deal with them. Any suggestions would be appreciated.
 
Attachments
  • Textbook figure P2.56: a tank of air at gage pressure p = 2 psi connected by a pipe to a water-filled U-shaped manometer, with dimensions 3 ft, 4 ft and SG = 0.9 fluid marked on the legs.
    ME 2.56.jpg
    24.9 KB · Views: 1,060
There's unequal lengths of the mystery fluid in the "U", so I don't think you can count on the fluid pressure at the bottom of the tank being the same as the pressure at point A, even though they are at the same elevation and the same fluid is below your "jumpline" in each.

Instead, start at a point of known pressure and "walk" the path to point A. The surface of the water in the tank would be a good place to start.

Manometer diagram from Figure P2.56 showing an air-filled tank with a gauge reading 2 psi, a U-tube with fluid of SG = 0.9, water below, and marked heights of 1 ft, 4 ft and 2 ft with pressures p0 = 2 psi, p1 and the differences Δp1, Δp2 and Δp3.


Note that you can count on the pressure being the same across the top of the "U" at the height of the water surface, since the same fluid is continuous along the path from one side of the "U" to the other.
 
Attachments
  • Manometer diagram of Figure P2.56 with an air-filled tank at left, a gauge reading 2 psi, a U-tube containing fluid of SG = 0.9, and a water-filled section below, with labels p0 = 2 psi, p1, and the pressure differences Δp1, Δp2 and Δp3, and heights of 1 ft, 4 ft and 2 ft.
    Fig1.gif
    11.2 KB · Views: 1,893
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: gracy