Finding Length of Parabolic Segment - Get Help Here!

  • Context: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter Thread starter jrm2002
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Parabola
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around finding the length of a segment of a parabola defined by specific points and a non-parallel directrix. Participants explore the mathematical formulation and transformations necessary to calculate the arc length of the parabola.

Discussion Character

  • Technical explanation
  • Mathematical reasoning
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant seeks help in calculating the length of a parabolic segment defined by three specific points and a non-parallel directrix.
  • Another participant questions the validity of the equation provided, suggesting it may not yield a parabola.
  • A different participant provides a transformation approach to rotate the coordinate system to simplify the problem, proposing a new equation for the parabola.
  • There is a discussion about the integration method for finding the arc length, with one participant stating their calculated length differs from the expected result.
  • Multiple participants express uncertainty about the correctness of the transformation and integration steps, with one participant repeatedly asking for clarification on where they might be going wrong.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants do not reach a consensus on the validity of the original equation or the correctness of the calculated arc length. There are competing views on the transformation method and its implications for the arc length calculation.

Contextual Notes

Participants reference specific mathematical transformations and integration techniques without resolving the assumptions or dependencies involved in these methods. The discussion includes unresolved questions about the accuracy of the derived equations and calculations.

jrm2002
Messages
54
Reaction score
0
I have a parabola.

Now, i need to get the length of aprt of a parabolic segment--that is a quarter of a parabola or 1/10 of a parabola, 3/4 of a parabola or anything

How is this possible?

Please help
 
Physics news on Phys.org
?? What do you mean by "a quarter of a parabola or 1/10 of a parabola, 3/4 of a parabola"? A parabola has infinite length. If you have a parabola opening downward and are looking at the part above y= 0, please say so.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Sorry---I will put it more clearly,

I have a parabola whose directrix is not parallel to x axis.

The equation of this parabola is:

x^2 + 2xy + y^2 - 16y + 32 = 0


I know three points which lie on the parabola [start point, end point, vertex].

Now, I want the length of the parabola
 
What exactly makes you think that equation yields a parabola?
 
Whatever makes him thinks so, he is right. The quadratic part is x^2+ 2xy+ y^2= (x+ y)^2 Let u= x+ y. Then y= u- x and the equation becomes, in terms of u, u^2- 16(u- x)- 32= 0 or u^2- 16u- 16x- 32= 0 and, finally, x= (1/16)u^2- u- 2. That is a parabola at 45 degrees to the coordinate axes. There is no simple formula for arclength of a parabola. You would have to integrate \sqrt{1+ ((1/8)u- 1)^2}du[/itex] between the u values of the endpoints.
 
To explain in detail what I want:

Now,

I have a parabola whose 3 points (x , y) are defined as:

Point 1 : (-9, -1)

Point 2 : (-6,6) [VERTEX POINT]

Point 3: (4,-9)

I need to get the length of the parabola.

Now, the directrix of this parabola is not parallel to x axis.OK?

So, I introduce a transformed coordinate system in which the directrix
is parallel to an axis:

Now, always if I draw a tangent to the parabola at the vertex, it will be parallel to the directrix, right?

So, in the transformed coordinate system , the inclination of directrix would be:

tan(inverse) of 6/-6 [SEE THE VERTEX POINT].Right?

that is : -45 degrees

Now,

A transformed coordinate axis which
is rotated about the origin through an angle T is given by:

[ x' ] [ Cos T Sin T ][ x ] [ x Cos T + y Sin T ]
| | = | || | = | |
[ y' ] [ -Sin T Cos T ][ y ] [ -x Sin T + y Cos T ]

So, I get,

x ' = (x+y) (-cos 45)

y' = (y - x) (-cos45)

Right?

So, the three points with respect to the rotated coordinate axis would be:

Point 1 = ( -7.071 , -5.6568)

Point 2 = (0, 8.4852)

Point 3 = (3.5355 , 9.1923)

Solving the equation,

y = Ax^2 + Bx +C

I get,

A = 0.5091
B = 3.1999
C = -8.4852

y = 0.5091x^2 + 3.1999x +(-8.4852)

Right?

If i want to find the length of the parabolic arc I use:

1+ dy/dx^2)^1/2

and integrate between -7.071 and 3.5355.

I egt answer 33.3338488

But correct answer is : 26.603

Where am I going wrong?

Please help
 
Now,

I have a parabola whose 3 points (x , y) are defined as:

Point 1 : (-9, -1)

Point 2 : (-6,6) [VERTEX POINT]

Point 3: (4,-9)

I need to get the length of the parabola.

Now, the directrix of this parabola is not parallel to x axis.OK?

So, I introduce a transformed coordinate system in which the directrix
is parallel to an axis:

Now, always if I draw a tangent to the parabola at the vertex, it will be parallel to the directrix, right?

So, in the transformed coordinate system , the inclination of directrix would be:

tan(inverse) of 6/-6 [SEE THE VERTEX POINT].Right?

that is : -45 degrees

Now,

A transformed coordinate axis which
is rotated about the origin through an angle T is given by:

[ x' ] [ Cos T Sin T ][ x ] [ x Cos T + y Sin T ]
| | = | || | = | |
[ y' ] [ -Sin T Cos T ][ y ] [ -x Sin T + y Cos T ]

So, I get,

x ' = (x+y) (-cos 45)

y' = (y - x) (-cos45)

Right?

So, the three points with respect to the rotated coordinate axis would be:

Point 1 = ( -7.071 , -5.6568)

Point 2 = (0, 8.4852)

Point 3 = (3.5355 , 9.1923)

Solving the equation,

y = Ax^2 + Bx +C

I get,

A = 0.5091
B = 3.1999
C = -8.4852

y = 0.5091x^2 + 3.1999x +(-8.4852)

Right?

If i want to find the length of the parabolic arc I use:

1+ dy/dx^2)^1/2

and integrate between -7.071 and 3.5355.

I egt answer 33.3338488

But correct answer is : 26.603

Where am I going wrong?

Please help
 
To explain in detail what i want:

Now,

I have a parabola whose 3 points (x , y) are defined as:

Point 1 : (-9, -1)

Point 2 : (-6,6) [VERTEX POINT]

Point 3: (4,-9)

I need to get the length of the parabola.

Now, the directrix of this parabola is not parallel to x axis.OK?

So, I introduce a transformed coordinate system in which the directrix
is parallel to an axis:

Now, always if I draw a tangent to the parabola at the vertex, it will be parallel to the directrix, right?

So, in the transformed coordinate system , the inclination of directrix would be:

tan(inverse) of 6/-6 [SEE THE VERTEX POINT].Right?

that is : -45 degrees

Now,

A transformed coordinate axis which
is rotated about the origin through an angle T is given by:

[ x' ] [ Cos T Sin T ][ x ] [ x Cos T + y Sin T ]
| | = | || | = | |
[ y' ] [ -Sin T Cos T ][ y ] [ -x Sin T + y Cos T ]

So, I get,

x ' = (x+y) (-cos 45)

y' = (y - x) (-cos45)

Right?

So, the three points with respect to the rotated coordinate axis would be:

Point 1 = ( -7.071 , -5.6568)

Point 2 = (0, 8.4852)

Point 3 = (3.5355 , 9.1923)

Solving the equation,

y = Ax^2 + Bx +C

I get,

A = 0.5091
B = 3.1999
C = -8.4852

y = 0.5091x^2 + 3.1999x +(-8.4852)

Right?

If i want to find the length of the parabolic arc I use:

1+ dy/dx^2)^1/2

and integrate between -7.071 and 3.5355.

I egt answer 33.3338488

But correct answer is : 26.603

Where am I going wrong?

Please help
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
19K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
4K
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
11K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
6K
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K