Finding minimum force to pull the napkin out from under the tea cup

7 replies · 2K views · last reply
Jpyhsics
Messages
84
Reaction score
2

Homework Statement


There is a table, and a napkin on it. The napkin has a mass mn=71.6 g. On the napkin, there is a tea cup with mass mc=104.6 g. What is the minimum force required for someone to pull the napkin out from under the tea cup? Assume that between the table and the napkin the friction is µk= 0.484, while the coefficient of static friction between the tea cup and the napkin is µs=0.705. Express your answer in Newtons.

Homework Equations


F=ma

The Attempt at a Solution


ΣFxNapkin=F-frC-frT (where C is cup and T is table)
ΣFxCup=frN (where N is napkin)

I have also included a photo of my FBD
How can I proceed with this question? Do I have a correct FBD?
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten free-body diagrams: a napkin with forces F, FfrC, FfrT, FNC, Fg and FN, and a cup with FfrN, FN and Fg, followed by handwritten force equations for the napkin.
    IMG_109F6D002955-1.jpeg
    22.1 KB · Views: 519
Jpyhsics said:
How can I proceed with this question? Do I have a correct FBD?
Your FBD looks fine.
What about the cup's acceleration?
 
haruspex said:
Your FBD looks fine.
What about the cup's acceleration?
Would the acceleration of the cup be equal to the acceleration of the napkin?
 
Jpyhsics said:
Would the acceleration of the cup be equal to the acceleration of the napkin?
Yes, or only very slightly less. So what equation can you write?
 
so would the cup acceleration be:
ac=μkg ?
Which subsequently would be the acceleration of the napkin?

So would my solution in the picture make sense?
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten physics working on a napkin and tea cup problem: free-body diagrams for the napkin and cup, force sums, masses 0.0716 kg and 0.1046 kg, cup acceleration a = 4.74804, and a boxed result of 1.90 N.
    IMG_E3E262A0D1DA-1.jpeg
    28 KB · Views: 502
Jpyhsics said:
so would the cup acceleration be:
ac=μkg ?
μk is the kinetic friction between the napkin and the table.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Jpyhsics
Jpyhsics said:
Okay thanks!
Not sure how to interpret that response. I am telling you that your equation in post #5 makes no sense... and wondering if it was a typo.

Edit: I have marked the thread unsolved.
 
Last edited: