1. Limited time only! Sign up for a free 30min personal tutor trial with Chegg Tutors
    Dismiss Notice
Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

Homework Help: Finding net force on charges on xy plane

  1. Sep 21, 2008 #1
    1. The problem statement, all variables and given/known data

    A proton is on the x axis at x = 1.2 nm. An electron is on the y axis at y = 1.2 nm.
    Find the net force the two exert on a helium nucleus (charge +2e) at the origin.
    Express your answer using two significant figures. Enter your answers numerically separated by a comma, such that " Fx, Fy = ...,..."

    2. Relevant equations

    electron charge, e = -1.6*10^-19 coulombs
    proton charge, + e = + 1.6*10^-19 coulombs
    distance, r = 1.2 nm = 1.2*10^-9 m
    constant, k = 9*10^9

    force in newtons, F = kq_1q_2/r^2 where q_1 and q_2 represent point charge

    3. The attempt at a solution

    charge at origin = +2e = 3.2*10^-19 coulombs

    Fy = force y axis = electron and origin charge = [(9*10^9)(-1.6*10^-19)(3.2*10^-19)]/(1.2*10^-9)2 = - 3.2*10^-10 newtons

    Fx = force y axis = proton and origin charge = [(9*10^9)(+1.6*10^-19)(3.2*10^-19)]/(1.2*10^-9)2 = - 3.2*10^-10 newtons

    Fnet = sqrt(Fy^2 + Fx^2) = sqrt(2.048*10^-19) = 4.5255*10^-10 newtons

    i entered these and they were wrong:

    Fx, Fy = 4.53*10^-10, -4.53*10^-10
    Fx, Fy = 3.2*10^-10, -3.2*10^-10

    are my calculations correct? what should i enter?
  2. jcsd
  3. Sep 22, 2008 #2
    yea, i solved that problem the same way. the problem is in the book, and using that same equation for Fx, Fy i got the same answer as the solution in the book. but when i did the problem on mp (my numbers were different) the answer was wrong - and i solved it the SAME way. aghhh im sooo lost. i dont know why its wrong =/
  4. Sep 22, 2008 #3
    i originally had the signs wrong, Fx is actually -3.2*10^-10, my Fy is wrong, it is a positive value though. why is it wrong, i thought the two forces would be equal in magnitude.

    it says my Fy value is "you may have made a rounding error or used the wrong number of significant figures." it is currently Fy = 3.2*10^-10

    could someone please help me for Fy
  5. Sep 22, 2008 #4
    i would have thought it would have been the same in your problem, just opposite signs, since your distances are the same. mine are different for the x-axis and y-axis, so i dont know - my answer's not even right =( im finishing up mp tomorrow afternoon though - kinda late - but im sure i'll get the rest of it by then, if ur still working on it
  6. Sep 22, 2008 #5
    i tried to run the calculations again and i am still getting 3.2*10^-10, is there any reason why the forces should have different magnitudes? it doesn't seem to make sense
  7. Sep 22, 2008 #6
    ok, i tried my answer and it keeps coming out wrong - i dont think i messed up on any of my calculations...
    i had 1.7 nm distance on the x-axis for the proton, and 1.3 nm distance on the y-axis for the electron. everything else is the same.
    my equations were:

    Fx= -k (e)(2e)/(1.7*10-9)2 = -(9*109)(1.6*10-19)(3.2*10-19)/(2.89*10-18) = -(4.608*10-28)/(2.89*10-18) = -1.594*10-10 N

    Fx= k (e)(2e)/(1.3*10-9)2 = (9*109)(1.6*10-19)(3.2*10-19)/(1.69*10-18) = (4.608*10-28)/(1.69*10-18) = 2.726*10-10 N

    i solved the problem in the book the same way, with their numbers and it was right.... but i dont know what i did wrong here...? mp marked my answers wrong with no suggestions or anything - so its like they're completely off. any idea why?
    Last edited: Sep 22, 2008
  8. Sep 23, 2008 #7
    i think your answer is right - MP had the wong answers. she's making it a practice problem now so we don't lose points.
Share this great discussion with others via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook