Finding the open ckt voltage (Thevenin equivalent problem)

12 replies · 3K views · last reply
rugerts
Messages
153
Reaction score
11
Homework Statement
Find v_oc.
Relevant Equations
Mesh or Node analysis. => KVL and KCL.
Circuit schematic with source VS1 at node a, resistors R1 to R6 and R5 along the top, nodes a through g, open-circuit voltage Voc between e and ground, mesh currents i1 and i2 drawn in red, and handwritten loop equations below.
Handwritten-style worked derivation of Thevenin voltage: equations 20k*i2 + 115k*i2 + 115k*(i2 - i1) = 0, 250k*i2 = 115k*i1, and i1 = 250/115 i2 (Equation 2); substituting gives 352.391k*i2 = 12, i2 ≈ 0.0341 mA, i1 ≈ 0.0740 mA; Vth = i1*100k + i2*115k, Vth = 11.9186 V.
LTspice schematic of a resistive circuit with a 12 V source V14, resistors R45 100k, R46 15k, R47 100k, R48 15k, R49 20k and R50 100k, with node voltages labelled 12V, 11.318939V, 7.4028378V and 0V.


I'm trying to find Vth (and then Rth). My work and results don't seem to agree with what my circuit simulation (done on LTSpice) shows. Can anyone point out what may be wrong here?
 
I didn't even try to follow what you did, since you did it the hard way. I suggest that you simplify the circuit (with the voltage source treated properly for getting Rth) and THEN do calculations.
 
phinds said:
I didn't even try to follow what you did, since you did it the hard way. I suggest that you simplify the circuit (with the voltage source treated properly for getting Rth) and THEN do calculations.
Figure 5: a linear resistive network with source V_S1 feeding nodes a, b, c, d and e through resistors R1 to R4, a shunt R6 to ground node g, a series R5 across the top, and load resistor R_load between e and g.
Circuit schematic of a Thevenin equivalent: a voltage source V_TH = v_oc in series with resistor R_TH = v_oc/i_sc, driving a load resistor R_load with voltage v_load and current i_load, inside a cloud outline. Caption: Figure 7: Thevenin equivalent for the resistive network in Figure 5.

This is what I'm going based off of.
What exactly are you talking about?

Also, is it really that hard? Granted, what you propose might be much easier, but what I'm doing isn't very involved.
Thanks for the reply.
 
rugerts said:
What exactly are you talking about?
You've got a circuit that easily resolves down to one resistor if you just simply properly. Don't even need to DO any loop or node stuff.

If you're new to all this, you'll soon realize that simplifying the circuit FIRST is almost always going to save time. On this problem, it totally SOLVES the problem (of getting Rth)
 
phinds said:
You've got a circuit that easily resolves down to one resistor if you just simply properly. Don't even need to DO any loop or node stuff.

If you're new to all this, you'll soon realize that simplifying the circuit FIRST is almost always going to save time. On this problem, it totally SOLVES the problem (of getting Rth)
Could you be a bit more specific? You're saying it solves the problem, but how exactly? I've found Req to be 31.8473 k. It took a delta-wye transform.
 
rugerts said:
Could you be a bit more specific? You're saying it solves the problem, but how exactly? I've found Req to be 31.8473 k. It took a delta-wye transform.
No, just simple series & parallel 'til you get to a single R
Handwritten circuit diagram with red pen markings: a top resistor network labelled SERIES and another SERIES section, and a lower network labelled SERIES and PARALLEL with red loops tracing the groupings.
 
phinds said:
No, just simple series & parallel 'til you get to a single R
View attachment 251885
Okay. Well that's one way of doing it. The delta wye works as well.

But, again, could you please follow up with what this would help with? If I'm interpreting you correctly, you're saying to find the single equivalent resistance of the entire ckt? Is this then equal to Rth? What about the voltage across the open ckt, Vth?
 
rugerts said:
Okay. Well that's one way of doing it. The delta wye works as well
But messier by far
you're saying to find the single equivalent resistance of the entire ckt?
yes
Is this then equal to Rth?
What do you think?
What about the voltage across the open ckt, Vth?
Separate issue in either case.
 
In any case, whatever method you personally find easiest and fastest, that's what you should use. I think my way is that for Rth but maybe that's just me.

Also, you can use the same type of simplification technique to get Vth
 
phinds said:
In any case, whatever method you personally find easiest and fastest, that's what you should use. I think my way is that for Rth but maybe that's just me.

Also, you can use the same type of simplification technique to get Vth
Appreciate the feedback. I definitely think it's still important to solve the problem in different ways.

In the meantime, however, do you mind checking my work to see what may have gone wrong? It's bothering me quite a bit and I keep going over it, and can't seem to find what my mistake is.
 
I think you may have slipped up in your calculations here (finger error on your calculator?):

Handwritten-style calculation of Thevenin voltage: i2 ≈ 0.0341 mA, i1 ≈ 0.0740 mA, Vth = i1 * 100k + i2 * 115k, Vth = 11.9186 V.


When I use your current values and resistance values in that calculation I get a ##V_{th}## of 11.32 V, agreeing with your spice simulation.
 
gneill said:
I think you may have slipped up in your calculations here (finger error on your calculator?):

View attachment 251902

When I use your current values and resistance values in that calculation I get a ##V_{th}## of 11.32 V, agreeing with your spice simulation.
Yep. I get the same. Thanks for double checking.