Finding the Voltage across a Resistor using the Node Voltage Method

2 replies · 3K views · last reply
rugerts
Messages
153
Reaction score
11

Homework Statement


For the given circuit (see below), find the voltage across resistor 3.

Homework Equations


n-1 Kirchhoff's Current Laws for n nodes.

The Attempt at a Solution


Handwritten notes annotating a circuit: part a says node voltage method needs 2 KCL equations versus 3 for mesh, so choose node voltage; part b gives V1 = V23. Below, KCL at node 1 and node 2 are written out.
Handwritten node voltage equations with V1 and V2 over resistances in mA units, followed by Cramer's rule for V1 as a ratio of two 2x2 determinants with entries 550, -3, -219.7, 11.991 and 4.4286, -3, -3, 11.991.


Can anyone verify whether my KCL equations are correct? The mixture of source voltages with node voltages may have stumped me as far as finding a relevant expression for current across for example resistor 4.
My answer for V1, which is the same as the voltage across resistor 3, comes out to 134.59 V and the answer appears to be 84.54 V.
I have tried using Cramer's rule.

Here are imgur links incase the above images are too blurry:
https://imgur.com/KKL49X7
https://imgur.com/N79tdYo
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten notes annotating a circuit: part a says node voltage method needs 2 KCL equations versus 3 for mesh, so choose node voltage; part b gives V1 = V23. Below, KCL at node 1 and node 2 are written out.
    IMG-1912.JPG
    38.1 KB · Views: 975
  • Handwritten node voltage equations with V1 and V2 over resistances in mA units, followed by Cramer's rule for V1 as a ratio of two 2x2 determinants with entries 550, -3, -219.7, 11.991 and 4.4286, -3, -3, 11.991.
    IMG-1913.JPG
    32.5 KB · Views: 719
rugerts said:

Homework Statement


For the given circuit (see below), find the voltage across resistor 3.

Homework Equations


n-1 Kirchhoff's Current Laws for n nodes.

The Attempt at a Solution


View attachment 239069 View attachment 239070

Can anyone verify whether my KCL equations are correct? The mixture of source voltages with node voltages may have stumped me as far as finding a relevant expression for current across for example resistor 4.
My answer for V1, which is the same as the voltage across resistor 3, comes out to 134.59 V and the answer appears to be 84.54 V.
I have tried using Cramer's rule.

Here are imgur links incase the above images are too blurry:
https://imgur.com/KKL49X7
https://imgur.com/N79tdYo

Check the signs in your equations. Remember, the current flows from higher potential to lower one.
Also, it would be easier to write KCL equation for the nod at the ground instead of node 2.
 
The most efficient way would be to use the method of replacing the voltage sources with current sources and vice verse.