Finding Thevenin equivalent with supernode and supermesh

2 replies · 2K views · last reply
Frank-95
Messages
51
Reaction score
1
Hi all :)

I'm trying to figure out the Thevenin equivalent of this circuit:

Circuit schematic with nodes 1, 2, a and b: current source I2 (1 A) and resistor R2 (6) to ground from node 1, voltage source V1 (14 V) and resistor R3 (14) in series from node 1 to node 2, current source I1 (3 A) and resistor R1 (5) from node 2 to ground, with terminals a and b.


I start by switching off every source and calculating the equivalent resistance:

RTh = RN = (6 + 14) || 5 = 4 Ω


Then I proceed with finding the voltage at 2.

I note that the nodes between 1 and 2 form a supernode:

Circuit schematic with terminals a and b: a current source I2 with value 1 and resistor R2 of 6 ohms on the left between nodes 1 and b, a dashed wire between nodes 1 and 2, current source I1 of 3 and resistor R1 of 5 ohms on the right, with ground at the bottom.


So I set up the (super)nodal equation:

1 = v1/6 + 3 + v2/5

Then I proceed with mesh analysis. I note than the voltage source and the current source I1 form a supermesh.

Circuit schematic with terminals a and b, nodes 1 and 2, a 1 A current source I2, resistors R2 = 6, R3 = 14 and R1 = 5, a 14 V source V1, and mesh currents i1 and i2 with a dashed supermesh boundary.


And now I have some problems at setting up the equation :/

I know that:

-14 + 14*i1 + 5*i2 - 6(1 - i1) = 0

To bring this equation as a function of v1 and v2

I tried to think up about these equivalences, but I probably mistakened since the equation would become v1 = 0

14i1 = 14 - v2
5i2 = v2
6(1 - i1) = v1


Thanks in advance :)
 
If you have a problem with a mesh analysis why you do not proceed with the node analysis ? Also you can use a source transformation and convert a current source into a voltage source.
And your supernode equation is also wrong because V2 - V1 is not equal to 14V.

EDIT

The correct super mash look like this:
Circuit schematic with nodes 1, 2, a and b, showing sources V1 (14), I2 (1), I1 (3), resistors R2 (6), R3 (14), R1 (5), and red mesh currents I1, I2 and I3 drawn as loops.


So we have
I1 = 3A
I2 = 1A

and for loop I3 we have:

-14V + 14Ω*I3 + 5Ω*(I3 - I1) + 6Ω*(I3 - I2) = 0

And please notice that I3 is always in first place in parentheses.

And the solution is
http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=-14+++14*x+++5*(x+-+3)+++6*(x+-+1)+=+0

I3 = 7/5A = 1.4A and the current flowing through 5 ohm resistor is equal to:
IR1 = I3 - I1 = 1.4A - 3A = -1.6A and this means that V2 voltage is equal to :
V2 = -1.6A*5Ω = -8V
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the answer, I had mistakened with R1 resistance :)