For G=GL(2,R), for f, show that f is not an inner automorphism

  • Thread starter mathnerd1
  • Start date
In summary, the conversation discusses the task of proving that f(A)=(A^tr)^-1 is not an inner automorphism in G=GL(2,R) and how to approach this problem. The conversation also mentions the importance of considering the restriction of f to the center of G and the failure of using matrices outside of GL(2,R) in the proof. The conversation concludes with clarifying that g(M)=M for inner automorphisms, but it is not necessarily true for f(M).
  • #1
mathnerd1
2
0
1. Homework Statement :

Let G=GL(2,R) and define f:G->G by f(A)=(A^tr)^-1, where A^tr represents the transpose of A for all A in GL(2,R). Prove that f is not an inner automorphism, hence prove that there does not exist a fixed matrix B in G such that f(A)=BAB^-1 for all A in G

2. Homework Equations :

Before doing this question, we were asked to find the Z(G) [centre of G=GL(2,R)].
I know that an inner automorphism on G is given by as stated in the question f(A)=BAB^-1

3. The Attempt at a Solution :

So my attempt at the solution was first to find the centre of GL(2,R)
Hence Z(G) is given by the set of matrices of the form aI, where a is a scalar and I is the 2x2 identity.
My teacher had told us a hint and said that for us to solve this question we would have to look at the restriction of f to the centre of G=GL(2,R).
After obtaining Z(G), I can't see the restriction that f places on Z(G).
I thought of the zero matrix for B, then obviously that would not be an inner automorphism because all forms of BAB^-1 for A in GL(2,R) would equal the zero matrix. But then it hit me that the zero matrix is not in GL(2,R) so that solution attempt failed.
Then I thought what about a matrix of the form where the first row was zeros and then the bottom row was scalars, but then those matrices do not belong in GL(2,R) since their determinant is 0.
I also tried multiplying arbitrary matrices, but that also got me no where.

Please help me : )
Thank you so much!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Answer this question: what are you trying to gain by trying out several values of B? Indeed the ones you tried are not in GL(2,R), so won't work. But the point is to show that f(A) is not equal to BAB-1 for all B in GL(2,R). Proving it isn't so for some B won't work.

Your teacher's advice is good. Let's say that g(A) = BAB-1 is an inner automorphism. If M is in the center of GL(2,R), what is g(M)?
 
  • #3
mmm

if g(M) for M in the centre of Z(G), that implies that M=BMB^-1 or that MB=BM?
 
  • #4
Ok, so g(M)=M for M in the center where g is an inner automorphism. Does f(M)=M for all M in the center?
 

FAQ: For G=GL(2,R), for f, show that f is not an inner automorphism

What is an inner automorphism?

An inner automorphism is an automorphism of a group G that is induced by conjugation by an element of G. In other words, it is a mapping of the group onto itself that preserves the group structure and is given by g -> xgx^-1, where x is an element of G.

How do you show that f is not an inner automorphism?

To show that f is not an inner automorphism, we need to find an element g in G such that f(g) is not equal to xgx^-1 for any x in G. This would prove that f is not induced by conjugation and therefore not an inner automorphism.

Can you give an example of an inner automorphism?

Yes, an example of an inner automorphism is the identity mapping, which maps every element of the group onto itself. This can be written as g -> ggg^-1 = g for any x in G.

How does the group GL(2,R) relate to inner automorphisms?

The group GL(2,R) is the set of all invertible 2x2 matrices with real entries. It is a subgroup of the general linear group over R and it is isomorphic to the group of all invertible linear transformations from R^2 to itself. This group has many inner automorphisms, but not all automorphisms are inner.

Is there a general method for proving that an automorphism is not an inner automorphism?

Yes, there is a general method for proving that an automorphism is not an inner automorphism. This involves finding elements in the group G that do not satisfy the condition xgx^-1 = f(g) for any x in G. If such elements are found, then f cannot be an inner automorphism. However, this method may not work for all groups and in some cases, a more specific approach may be needed.

Similar threads

Back
Top