Force Equalization on an Anchor

  • Thread starter rambo5330
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Force
In summary, the conversation discusses the concept of force multiplication in a climbing anchor system, where the force on each bolt increases as the angle between the ropes increases. This is due to joint equilibrium considerations and the trig relationships of the force triangle. The conversation also includes examples and calculations to illustrate this concept.
  • #1
rambo5330
84
0

Homework Statement


So I am a climber and I also love physics. I only have first year physics under my belt, and I do not know the concept behind the following question I often think about while setting up a climbing anchor.

Attached is a diagram of two 2-point anchor systems. the red lines building the two sides of the anchor can be thought of as two lengths of rope, and 3rd length of rope attached to the vertex of the anchor goes to the climber (load). In situation (a) when the anchor is less than 120 degrees the load is shared between the two bolts, each seeing less than 1 x the load.. i.e if a 150 lb person is attached to the anchor each bolt will see maybe 75 pounds. therefore making it advantagous to use the 2-point system to reduce overall load on individual bolts.
In situation (b), However; when the angle is greater than 120 degrees the force is actually multiplied at each bolt. so if you have a 150 lb climber (load) attached to the anchor, each bolt will actually see around 200+ lb, makeing it extremely dangerious to use this system.

Why does the force multiply like that and decrease so much when the angle is decreased? with my first year physics all I know how to do is use the angles and the weight of the load to determine the tension on each leg of the anchor and hence the force on each bolt...the numbers work but i don't know WHY they are increaseing and decreaseing as the angle changes? is it acting as a sort of lever causing torque on the bolt.. can someone please explain this?
 

Attachments

  • Anchor Equalization2.doc
    29 KB · Views: 475
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Good point, but be careful with your bolt load calculations. It's due to joint equilibrium considerations per Newton's first law (sum of forces in vertical direction = 0, and sum of forces in horizontal direction = 0). The climbers weight is distributed equally (assuming the anchors are symmetrically located ) to each rope. This results in a vertical component of tension in each rope equal to half the climbers weight (T_v = 75 pounds, assuming a 150 pound climber). This is true regardless of the angle betwen the ropes. But when you look at the actual tension in the rope, which has both a vertical (T_v) and horizontal (T_h) component, the tension, T, in the rope is T_v divided by the cos of 1/2 the angle between the ropes (this follows from laws of equilibrium and geometry/trig/vector analysis). When that angle is 120 degrees, T = 75/cos 60 = 75/0.5 = 150 pounds . When that angle is 0 (bolts close to each other), T = 75/cos 0 = 75/1 = 75 pounds. When the angle is say 150 degrees, T= 75/cos75 = near 300 pounds. Please do not construe this as a recommendation for proper bolt locations when climbing. I'm not the rock climbing expert--- I defer to you on this, as I have the greatest respect for your skills.
 
Last edited:
  • #3
Thank you, Thanks for your reply.

I can get the answers to the questions by breaking it into vectors as you did. however I still don't understand WHY this is happening (the force being multiplied as the angle increases) is it because like you say the vertical component will half the climbers weight no matter what the angle, but as you increase the angle, you increase the horiztontal component so in effect at around 180 degrees you would see 75 pounds on vertically downward and near 150 in the horizontal? I am just trying to grasp the concept here? any thoughts?
edit:
upon doing calculations for 170 degree angle I still have 75 lb in the vertical component just as you said, but in the horizontal component I end up with 857.2 lb for a total force of 860.5 lb on the bolt. how is it possible to have 857.2 lb in the horizontal.. almost 6 times greater force than the original 150 lb. this logic is what baffels me
 
Last edited:
  • #4
Yes, it does seem like you are getting something for nothing, but note that when the bolts are close together, there is no horizontal component, since the ropes support the gravity load (weight) only. As you increase the angle to form the 'V' shape, each rope still must support the weight force, but each rope must also support the rope pulling horizontally on it from the other side. This is in order to satisfy the equilibrium equation in the horizontal direction, that forces in this direction must sum to zero, where the magnitude of such opposing forces are determined form the trig relationships of the force triangle. A good example of the high tension forces resulting for small lateral loads is the 'vehicle stuck in the mud' problem. By fastening a strong taut rope between the vehicle and a tree, you can apply a relatively small force at the mid point of the rope, and displace the rope laterally to form a wide angled 'V', and thus produce high tensile forces in the rope to get the vehicle to slightly move.
 
  • #5
Thanks very much for your explanation its starting to clear things up for me.
and very cool truck in mud example. will possibly post another question regarding forces from climbing tomorrow. found a very cool one the today that confuses me quite a bit..
I appreciate your help.
 

What is force equalization on an anchor?

Force equalization on an anchor is the process of distributing the load or force evenly among multiple anchor points, rather than having all the force on a single anchor. This helps to prevent one anchor from bearing too much weight and potentially failing.

Why is force equalization on an anchor important?

Force equalization on an anchor is important because it helps to increase the overall strength and stability of the anchor system. It also reduces the risk of anchor failure, which can have severe consequences for safety and the success of a project.

What factors affect force equalization on an anchor?

The main factors that affect force equalization on an anchor include the number and placement of anchor points, the strength and quality of the anchors and the type of terrain or surface the anchors are attached to. Other factors such as the angle of the anchor lines and the weight of the load also play a role.

How is force equalization on an anchor calculated?

Force equalization on an anchor can be calculated using vector analysis, which takes into account the direction and magnitude of the forces acting on each anchor point. There are also various software programs and online calculators available to assist with these calculations.

What are some techniques for achieving force equalization on an anchor?

There are several techniques that can be used to achieve force equalization on an anchor, including the use of anchor slings or equalization devices, creating a redundant anchor system, and using natural features or structures as additional anchor points. It is important to carefully plan and properly distribute the load among the anchor points to achieve the best results.

Similar threads

  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
6
Views
1K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
18
Views
881
Replies
4
Views
785
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
4K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
9
Views
1K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
18
Views
707
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
353
Back
Top