Forces on a rotating rod: why is my force balance wrong?

  • Thread starter cupid.callin
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Rod Rotation
9 replies · 3K views · last reply
cupid.callin
Messages
1,130
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement


Hi all :biggrin:

Printed textbook problem 69: a uniform rod pivoted at its upper end is displaced through 60 degrees and released; find the force on a particle dm at the tip when the rod makes 37 degrees with the vertical.

The Attempt at a Solution


This was a solution to my problem i found on internet ...
Handwritten derivation of a rod's angular velocity and angular acceleration from energy and torque, ending with the total force on a particle at the rod's tip, F = 0.9√2 (dm) g.


I found w2 correctly like in solution ... but then when i thought that that net force will be force due to rod (F) - mg cos37 ... along rod ...

and mg sin37 perpendicular to rod ...

F - mg cos37 = (dm)w2L = .9 (dm) g

mgsin37 = (dm) g (3/5)

But I'm wrong ! :cry:

WHY? :confused:

And please someone explain me what is written in solution after finding w2 ... i can't understand it :-pEDIT:I got what they have written in answer ... they used τ = αI to find α

they used to find (dm) (dv/dt) = (lα)(dm) ie tangential force ... now i need to know .. why i am wrong in my way ? ... :confused:
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten derivation on a rotating rod: energy principle gives omega squared = 9g/(10l), angular acceleration alpha = 0.9(g/l), then centrifugal and tangential forces on a particle at the tip sum to total force 0.9 sqrt(2) dm g.
    01259.jpg
    49.8 KB · Views: 745
  • Printed textbook problem 69: a uniform rod pivoted at its upper end is displaced through 60 degrees and released; find the force on a particle dm at the tip when the rod makes 37 degrees with the vertical.
    01260.jpg
    23.7 KB · Views: 707
Last edited:
hi cupid.callin! :smile:
cupid.callin said:
I found w2 correctly like in solution ... but then when i thought that that net force will be force due to rod (F) - mg cos37 ... along rod ...

and mg sin37 perpendicular to rod ...
…
EDIT:


I got what they have written in answer ... they used τ = αI to find α

they used to find (dm) (dv/dt) = (lα)(dm) ie tangential force ... now i need to know .. why i am wrong in my way ? ... :confused:


your mg sin37° and mgcos37° are only the weight …

you've ignored the tension in the rod …

this method finds the total ("net") force, which is the LHS of F = ma, by just getting the RHS :wink:​
 
The equation after finding w2 is:
ml2/3 (alpha) = mgl/2 sin37.
It is just an equation connecting torque, moment of inertia and angular acceleration
 
how have i ignored tension?

I found F(tension) - mgcos37 ... i.e. along rod
and mg sin37 ... i.e. perpendicular to rod!

That includes tension, Rioght ?
 
ashishsinghal said:
The equation after finding w2 is:
ml2/3 (alpha) = mgl/2 sin37.
It is just an equation connecting torque, moment of inertia and angular acceleration

Yes i wrote that in edited part!

:)
 
cupid.callin said:
how have i ignored tension?

I found F(tension) - mgcos37 ... i.e. along rod

ah, no …

the tension force is only mgcos37° on a flat slope …

that's because the acceleration perpendicular to a flat slope is zero, and so you can take components perpendicular to the slope: T = mgcos37° …

in this case, the acceleration perpendicular to the slope is not zero, so that doesn't work! :smile:
and mg sin37 ... i.e. perpendicular to rod!

that's certainly not tension :confused:
 
tiny-tim said:
ah, no …

the tension force is only mgcos37° on a flat slope …

that's because the acceleration perpendicular to a flat slope is zero, and so you can take components perpendicular to the slope: T = mgcos37° …

in this case, the acceleration perpendicular to the slope is not zero, so that doesn't work! :smile:

I guess you are not understanding what i have done

i haven't taken mgcos37 = T
i have used T - mgcos37 = mv2/r = mw2r

And as i have taken X,Y axis as perpendicular to rod, along rod respectively so the only force in X axis is mg sin37 (and no tension of rod)

so shouldn't that be right?
 
cupid.callin said:
I guess you are not understanding what i have done

i haven't taken mgcos37 = T
i have used T - mgcos37 = mv2/r = mw2r

but the question asks for the total force …

where does that appear in your solution? :confused:
… the only force in X axis is mg sin37 (and no tension of rod)

this is a rigid rod, not a rope or chain …

it does have "tension" perpendicular to its length
 
EDIT:

Not even a string has any tension perpendicular to its length

And i know it has no tension perpendicular to length
...

and i have calculated the net of tension and mg in the first eqn, isn't that right?
 
cupid.callin said:
a rod also has tension along its length ... just its not same in all parts like in string

true :smile:

but a cable (ie a string with mass) also has has tension only along (and not perpendicular to) its length, and yet the tension is not the same all the way along

and a rigid rod also has tension perpendicular to its length