Formation of an internally statically determinate truss

5 replies · 2K views · last reply
GreatBlitz
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
TL;DR
I am unable to understand how a given truss is internally statically determinate.
My professor taught me that a internally statically determinate truss is formed by having one basic truss - the triangular truss consisting of three joints and three members:
Triangle truss made of three blue members connecting three open circle joints, one at each vertex.


and then repeatedly adding two members and a joint:
Planar truss diagram: a blue triangle of three members joined at three joints, with two red members added to a new joint on the right, forming a quadrilateral-like frame.


So, it makes sense why this is a statically determinate truss:
Planar pin-jointed truss with a top chord and bottom chord connected by diagonal and vertical members, supported by a pin on the left and a roller on the right.

However, I don't understand how this can be a statically determinate truss under the same reasoning:
Planar truss with a pin support on the left and a roller support on the right, built from triangles with a horizontal bottom chord and a peaked top chord.

Can someone can help?
 
Dr.D said:
Do you not see triangles in the last figure?

The truss in the third figure can be easily formed by starting with one triangle and then successively adding two members and a joint between them (first and second figures). However, I don't see how this can be done with the last figure, even if it is made of triangles.
 
Why not build the cluster of triangles on the left side, then build the cluster of triangles on the right, and finally add one pin and one member to joint the two clusters?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: anorlunda
So if what you
Dr.D said:
Do you not see triangles in the last figure?

So if I understand you correctly, what you're saying is that all trusses made of solely triangles are internally statically determinate. Then can you explain why this is (internally) statically determinate?

Planar truss of blue members and joints built from triangles, with a pin support at the lower left and a roller support at the lower right.
 
I never said anything about being statically determinate or not, and certainly not about your last figure. You are moving the goal posts here.

Being statically determinant or not is, to some degree, dependent upon how the frame is loaded. You last figure may not be statically determinant if the extreme left and right nodes are not externally loaded.