Discussion Overview
The discussion centers around the competitiveness of obtaining staff positions at national laboratories compared to tenure-track positions at R1 universities. Participants explore various aspects of job roles, responsibilities, and career trajectories within national labs.
Discussion Character
- Debate/contested
- Exploratory
- Technical explanation
Main Points Raised
- Some participants suggest that jobs directing one's own research at national labs are at least as competitive as tenure-track positions at R1 institutions.
- Others argue that positions at national labs where one does not direct their own research are less competitive and more akin to industry jobs.
- A participant shares personal experience of being turned down for a national lab position right out of graduate school, emphasizing the competitiveness of these roles.
- It is noted that Project Scientist positions, which are funded by external grants, may be easier to obtain but typically have limited duration and are comparable to postdoctoral roles.
- One participant recommends pursuing postdoctoral positions at national labs as a strategic way to gain experience for future permanent roles in either national labs or universities.
- Another participant highlights that the structure of positions at national labs often mirrors that of universities, with titles corresponding to academic ranks.
- Concerns are raised about the misinterpretation of employment numbers at national labs, as many individuals present may be users from other institutions rather than lab employees.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express differing views on the competitiveness of national lab positions compared to university roles, with some asserting they are equally competitive while others suggest varying levels of competitiveness based on job responsibilities.
Contextual Notes
There are limitations in the discussion regarding the specific criteria that define competitiveness, as well as the varying expectations and structures of different positions within national labs.