Good pre-honours 'revise all physics' type book(s)

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion centers around recommendations for physics textbooks suitable for revising modern physics concepts at a post-graduate level, particularly for someone returning to study after a significant gap. The focus includes various areas of physics such as quantum mechanics, electromagnetism, nuclear physics, solid state physics, and advanced mathematics, with an emphasis on finding resources that include practice problems and solutions for self-assessment.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Homework-related
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant seeks a few comprehensive books for revising modern physics, emphasizing the need for practice problems and model answers.
  • Another participant recommends Griffiths' books for quantum mechanics and electromagnetism, suggesting a sequence for study.
  • A participant mentions the challenge of transitioning from a calculus-based physics background to one that relies more on linear algebra, expressing a need for resources that better align with this approach.
  • For nuclear physics, a recommendation is made for Krane's "Introductory Nuclear Physics," while Kittel's "Introduction to Solid State Physics" is suggested for solid state studies.
  • Concerns are raised about the prerequisites of Arfken's mathematical methods book, with a participant expressing difficulty in following some material due to gaps in their knowledge.
  • Another participant notes the availability of solutions manuals for Arfken and suggests Boas as a potentially lower-level alternative.
  • There is a request for a linear algebra-based equivalent of Resnik & Halliday, indicating a desire for resources that better fit the participant's current mathematical understanding.
  • A participant expresses appreciation for the forum's supportive community and indicates a willingness to contribute in the future.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree on the need for textbooks that include practice problems and solutions, but there are multiple competing views regarding specific book recommendations and the best approach to bridging gaps in knowledge.

Contextual Notes

Participants express varying levels of familiarity with the material, indicating that some may require more foundational support than others. There are also mentions of specific challenges related to the transition from calculus to linear algebra in the context of physics education.

ognik
Messages
626
Reaction score
2
Hi - I'm doing an honors degree in physics by distance learning, having received my B.Sc around 20 years ago. I find there is a lot that is presented quite differently, and also stuff that I don't remember well enough - or not at all. So I'm looking for the fewest books that I can use to revise modern physics fairly quickly up to post-grad level. These would need to have practice problems etc. - if possible with model answers so I can check what I do. All advice appreciated.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
ognik said:
Hi - I'm doing an honors degree in physics by distance learning, having received my B.Sc around 20 years ago. I find there is a lot that is presented quite differently, and also stuff that I don't remember well enough - or not at all. So I'm looking for the fewest books that I can use to revise modern physics fairly quickly up to post-grad level. These would need to have practice problems etc. - if possible with model answers so I can check what I do. All advice appreciated.

I'm assuming you'll be doing Quantum and E&M at least? What else are you doing?
I'm also assuming that from your terminology, you're either in NZ or Australia - "post-grad level" changes from country to country. For quantum mechanics, I'd recommend a sequence of two books - Griffiths Introduction to Quantum Mechanics for the bare-bones basics (first/second year BSc), and once you're happy with that content, I'd go for Auletta, Fortunato and Parisi's Quantum Mechanics (Third/Honours year through to post-grad).

For electromagnetism, Griffith's Introduction to Electrodynamics for the basics, followed by Jacskon Classical Electrodynamics (Honours through to post-grad).
 
Hi and thanks for those, I will be doing QM x 2, E&M, Nuclear, solid state, statistical, advanced maths, research methods x 2. I have registered with UNISA (.co.za).

One of my hurdles is that the physics I studied was very calculus based, these courses lean heavily to linear algebra - I have Arfken et al. for maths (which at times assumes more background than I have). I would appreciate a book with more problems - that I can get solutions to for self-learning checking.

I see the the 2 griffiths books are well regarded, thanks for that. I have come across numerous positives for Resnik & Hallkiday for 'general' physics (Lagrangians and Hamiltonians are also new to me) - but that seems to be very calculus flavored, any linear algebra/operators equivalents ? Again with problems & solutions...
 
For Nuclear, I'd go for Introductory Nuclear Physics by Krane. It's very old-school, but it's the go-to undergrad nuclear text. For solid state, Introduction to Solid State Physics by Kittel is the standard.

I'll let someone else recommend a linear-algebra text. None come to mind for me.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: ognik
What are the prerequisites of Arfken (that you are missing)?
 
Last edited:
Up front, I recognise its a good text, I think my issue is the gap since I last studied. I can find my way thought most of the material well enough, but sometimes much too slowly when I need to figure out what I'm missing - in quite a few places the book 'jumps' over some steps that I don't follow. If the book said something like 'we use xyz to get from a to z' I could follow that and fill in - sadly it doesn't. I would like a book with a similar syllabus - with more worked examples; also more problems with the ability to see the solutions to excercises. This last is really important for self study, I am doing problems without knowing if I do them correctly, or if there are other methods of solution. Hope I'm not asking too much... thanks for the interest.
 
There should be solutions manuals available for Arfken, although I never looked it up myself. The same should go for the book by Boas, which I find to be at a slightly lower level.
 
ognik said:
Up front, I recognise its a good text, I think my issue is the gap since I last studied. I can find my way thought most of the material well enough, but sometimes much too slowly when I need to figure out what I'm missing - in quite a few places the book 'jumps' over some steps that I don't follow. If the book said something like 'we use xyz to get from a to z' I could follow that and fill in - sadly it doesn't. I would like a book with a similar syllabus - with more worked examples; also more problems with the ability to see the solutions to excercises. This last is really important for self study, I am doing problems without knowing if I do them correctly, or if there are other methods of solution. Hope I'm not asking too much... thanks for the interest.

This isn't as good as a whole book, I know, but you're always welcome to ask for help here!
 
Have searched long & hard for solutions manual, found a few 'private' solutions but no manual - if anyone knows of a solutions manual link I'd appreciate that.
Probably more interested in a more linear algebra based equivalent of Resnik & Hallkiday ...Thanks
 
  • #10
..and thanks e.bar.goum, I do use this forum and find it valuable, uplifting to find how many people give their time freely to help others - when I'm a bit more confident I'm sure I will give back as well ...
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: e.bar.goum

Similar threads

  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • Sticky
  • · Replies 16 ·
Replies
16
Views
13K
Replies
13
Views
10K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
2K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
3K
Replies
4
Views
516
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
15
Views
42K