Have you ever taught HS Physics with the Inquiry Based Approach?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the Inquiry Based Approach (IBA) in education, with participants expressing a desire to shift their teaching practices towards this method, which emphasizes active learning and student involvement. While some participants acknowledge the challenges of implementing IBA in a test-driven educational system, they highlight its potential to address the shortcomings of traditional education. References are made to influential works, including Paulo Freire's "Pedagogy of the Oppressed" and Andrew Hacker's "The Math Myth," which advocate for critical thinking and innovative teaching strategies. Concerns are raised about the political implications of educational philosophies, with some expressing skepticism about the potential for indoctrination. Overall, the conversation reflects a growing interest in reforming educational practices to foster deeper engagement and critical thinking among students.
robertphy
Messages
15
Reaction score
5
Nothing exceptionally new here, but I want to shift gears in my teaching practice and increase the Inquiry Based Approach more and more.

Have you ever taught with this approach, what resources did you use, and what results you had ?
Thank you for your cooperation
 
  • Like
Likes DeBangis21 and gleem
Science news on Phys.org
robertphy said:
Nothing exceptionally new here, but I want to shift gears in my teaching practice and increase the Inquiry Based Approach more and more.
I think inquiry based learning is also known as active learning, flipped classroom or the Discovery Approach which are designed to directly involve the student. I do not have any experience in this method but I have an interest in the continuing decline of our educational systems. Despite decades of tinkering with it and trying to improve it has resulted in little if any progress. Our standard system of education is like a business model a standard product produced on a fixed schedule. If you don't meet the specifications then you are tossed in the bin.

A book that perhaps reintroduced the discovery approach is that of Paulo Freire The Pedagogy of the Oppressed which builds on the foundational works of Jane Addams and John Dewey a hundred years ago. In his book "The Math Myth" Andrew Hacker sees this approach as solving some of the problems of current math education.

This method is more work for the teacher and may of course be difficult to implement in our test based educational systems. It may take some time for you to come up to speed. Good Luck
 
gleem said:
I think inquiry based learning is also known as active learning, flipped classroom or the Discovery Approach which are designed to directly involve the student. I do not have any experience in this method but I have an interest in the continuing decline of our educational systems. Despite decades of tinkering with it and trying to improve it has resulted in little if any progress. Our standard system of education is like a business model a standard product produced on a fixed schedule. If you don't meet the specifications then you are tossed in the bin.

A book that perhaps reintroduced the discovery approach is that of Paulo Freire The Pedagogy of the Oppressed which builds on the foundational works of Jane Addams and John Dewey a hundred years ago. In his book "The Math Myth" Andrew Hacker sees this approach as solving some of the problems of current math education.

This method is more work for the teacher and may of course be difficult to implement in our test based educational systems. It may take some time for you to come up to speed. Good Luck
Well, it seems to bring in political assumptions, I'd even say an agenda. Politics edit , nor religion, should be brought up when teaching children. Both smack of pushing personal agendas. Edit: Freire, together with Gramsci are known to be promoters of " The Long March though the Institions", a movement to surreptitiously promote Comunism in the West.
 
Last edited:
gleem said:
A book that perhaps reintroduced the discovery approach is that of Paulo Freire The Pedagogy of the Oppressed which builds on the foundational works of Jane Addams and John Dewey a hundred years ago. In his book "The Math Myth" Andrew Hacker sees this approach as solving some of the problems of current math education.
Freire was a noted educator and has had a significant impact on teaching, his political philosophy aside. He was noted for promoting the teaching of critical thinking.
 
I used to send my class notes to students, encouraged them to experiment before class rather than just solve problems. It made up for a lively, intense environment. It was harder on me, but it was the only methodology I could live with, rather than what I would call an educational ambush.

I may be wrong here, but when I hear terms, phrases like " oppressed" or "( respect for) tradition", I start suspecting some indoctrination ( not necessarily conscious or intentional) , however minor, from the left/right respectively. I'm surprised since, as a T.A, I never brought up in class anything outside the material I was teaching.
 
Last edited:
https://www.aapt.org/Conferences/ lists the next set of conferences 2026 Winter Meeting - January 17 - 19, Las Vegas, Nevada 2026 Summer Meeting - July 18 - 22, Pasadena, California 2027 Winter Meeting - January 9 - 12, New Orleans, Louisiana 2027 Summer Meeting - July 31 - August 4, Washington, DC I won't be attending the 2026 Winter Meeting in Las Vegas... For me, it's too close to the start of the semester. https://www.aapt.org/Conferences/wm2026/index.cfm...

Similar threads

Back
Top