Heat Car Engine on Cold Morning: Tips & Advice

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around methods for heating a car engine on cold mornings, particularly in extreme winter conditions. Participants share various tips, experiences, and equipment related to engine heating, battery maintenance, and insulation techniques.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Mathematical reasoning

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants suggest using block heaters as an effective method for warming engines, while others propose alternative methods like using electric blankets or light bulbs.
  • One participant mentions the effectiveness of a cabin heater that circulates warm water through the system, highlighting its ease of installation.
  • There are discussions about the limitations of using a 100W light bulb for heating, with some arguing it is better than nothing, while others express skepticism about its effectiveness in extreme cold.
  • Several participants emphasize the importance of battery maintenance in cold weather, suggesting insulation and battery blankets as potential solutions.
  • Some participants share personal anecdotes about their experiences with different heating methods, including the use of electric space heaters and dipstick heaters.
  • There are differing opinions on whether engine heaters are necessary at milder temperatures, with some asserting that a new battery might be more critical than heating methods at -3°C (26°F).

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants do not reach a consensus on the best method for heating car engines in cold weather. Multiple competing views and personal experiences are presented, leading to an unresolved discussion regarding the effectiveness of various techniques.

Contextual Notes

Participants mention specific temperature ranges and conditions, indicating that the effectiveness of heating methods may depend on individual circumstances, such as the age of the battery and the specific vehicle model.

Who May Find This Useful

Individuals living in cold climates, car enthusiasts, and those seeking practical advice on maintaining vehicle performance during winter months may find this discussion relevant.

questionboy
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Does anyone know the proper way to do this?
 
Engineering news on Phys.org


You mean other than having a block heater installed in your car that you just plug in?
 
If the car's sitting outside, the heat from the heater is going to dissipate. It will help a little bit, but not a lot. You would need well insulated blankets hanging from the hood to the ground, with the heater carefully located under the engine block, far enough away that the wind won't blow a flammable blanket into the heating elements. It's not a good way to heat your engine.

As Georgina mentioned, an engine block heater will work much better. An oil heater or a coolant heater will work just about as well and are much easier to install. (http://autorepair.about.com/library/a/1e/bl119e.htm)
 


While I have a regular frost-plug block heater, the one that I prefer splices into the cabin heater hose and circulates warm water throughout the system. It's cheap and really easy to install. Just make sure that you pick the right hose, aim the unit in the right direction, and leave the heater valves open. (Good link, Bob.)
Given the climate around here, I also use an electric battery blanket and have a 1500 W cabin heater that I turn on a half-hour or so before driving. The latter not only makes for a comfy environment, but also deices the windows.

Edit: Actually, the cab of the El Camino is so small that 10-15 minutes of the heater is sufficient. A regular car takes about 1/2 hour.
 
Last edited:


Hm. So I guess my method of hanging a 100W lightbulb in my engine when it's in the driveway is just foolin' myself.
 


DaveC426913 said:
Hm. So I guess my method of hanging a 100W lightbulb in my engine when it's in the driveway is just foolin' myself.

It's better than nothing.
I thought that you were a fellow Canuck. :confused: Where I live, it can hit -45C. Even a heat-light such as for a sauna won't do much good here.

Questionboy, also remember to bang on your hood a couple of times before starting the car. Otherwise, you might end up with a cat entangled in your fan belt. Strays like to sleep on engines in winter to keep warm.
 


DaveC426913 said:
Hm. So I guess my method of hanging a 100W lightbulb in my engine when it's in the driveway is just foolin' myself.
This is the method I used - and it worked - especially when the temperature was -20 to -30 F. I put a hang-light/lamp under the car. I put a blanket over the hood in order to insulate the engine. The blanket (or tarp) draped over the car such that it also prevented a breeze from blowing under the car.

It also helps to use 5W30 motor oil or thinner in winter time.
 


Danger said:
It's better than nothing.
I thought that you were a fellow Canuck. :confused:
I am the other type of Canuck.

I'm in Toronto. I wear a black leather jacket and I get snow tires the day after the snowfall. If power ever goes out, I will die.
 


DaveC426913 said:
I am the other type of Canuck.

I'm in Toronto. I wear a black leather jacket and I get snow tires the day after the snowfall. If power ever goes out, I will die.

And your mayor may call in the army to plow the roads.
 
  • #10


GeorginaS said:
And your mayor may call in the army to plow the roads.

But that man didn't last.
 
  • #11


Im only talking about -3 Celsius or 26Fareinheit here on an old car at worst and only at the coldest part of the morning. The temperature will rise up to 20 Celsisus during the day. Like desert temperature in winter.
 
  • #12


Where is the exact spot under the bonnet I should put the bulb?
 
  • #13


At non-canuck temperatures it's mainly the battery that's the problem.
Block heaters stop the oil freeing at -40 but at -3 you are probably just loosing some battery power (especially if it's old).

Easiest way is to wrap the battery in insulation, you can buy insulated battery covers in cold places but reflective foil covered building insulation material will work, it's cheap and fireproof.
You could also add a garden heater, these are 6in square (or so) sticky pads used for keeping frost off planters in a greenhouse. They run off household current and take 20-100W depending on size.
 
  • #14


questionboy said:
Im only talking about -3 Celsius or 26Fareinheit here on an old car at worst and only at the coldest part of the morning. The temperature will rise up to 20 Celsisus during the day. Like desert temperature in winter.

It depends on the car, but a dipstick heater works well if the temperature doesn't plummet too much. Very easy installation, just replace the dipstick with this special one. Trouble is, the available kind doesn't work with some cars out there.
 
  • #15


mgb_phys said:
At non-canuck temperatures it's mainly the battery that's the problem.
Block heaters stop the oil freeing at -40 but at -3 you are probably just loosing some battery power (especially if it's old).

Easiest way is to wrap the battery in insulation, you can buy insulated battery covers in cold places but reflective foil covered building insulation material will work, it's cheap and fireproof.
You could also add a garden heater, these are 6in square (or so) sticky pads used for keeping frost off planters in a greenhouse. They run off household current and take 20-100W depending on size.

You don't need any kind of engine heater at 26 deg F (-3 C). You don't even need a battery blanket. You need a new battery!

mgb_phys is right that the blanket will allow you to spend a little more time with your current car battery, but it's really time to pull plug on the old thing if it can't withstand temps like that. Put it out of its misery and buy a new one.

By the way, you do check the fluid in your batteries once in a while, don't you? Low battery fluid could case your battery to age prematurely. In fact, a leak could cause it to flat out die.
 
  • #16


A battery heater for -3C? Yeah, no, there's something wrong with your battery.
 
  • #17


questionboy said:
Where is the exact spot under the bonnet I should put the bulb?
Under the oil pan with the bulb close but not touching. In my experience, the whole engine compartment under the bonnet was quite warm, even when the car chassis was near freezing and the ambient air was at or below freezing.
 
  • #18


In good old days when I was driving http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fiat_126 I used to put electric space heater (fan type) just under the bonnet :smile: 1.5 kW for 30 minutes and I was starting it even below -20 deg C.
 
  • #19


Borek said:
In good old days when I was driving http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fiat_126 I used to put electric space heater (fan type) just under the bonnet :smile: 1.5 kW for 30 minutes and I was starting it even below -20 deg C.

That's the same thing I did last winter! Worked like a charm the few times I had to resort to it. My battery finally gave up the ghost after 5 years, and it had trouble starting when it hit -25 or -30 C, and gave up the ghost when it was -40. I got a new battery which I installed when it had 'warmed up' outside to around -30. Everything was numb, and I recall that the drop of drool or snot I dripped froze before I had a chance to wipe it away...

In any case, when I was installing my battery blanket this summer, I think I leaked some of the acid out. Anybody know the best way to check the level, and whether I'd need to replace the sulfuric acid as well, or if I can just top off with distilled water?
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 66 ·
3
Replies
66
Views
5K
  • · Replies 37 ·
2
Replies
37
Views
7K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
956
Replies
13
Views
4K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • · Replies 26 ·
Replies
26
Views
19K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
3K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
3K