Calculus Help locating a Math Equation to fit this curve

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around finding an equation for a curve based on two points, with concentration on the Y axis and values on the X axis. Participants note that without more information about the curve, it's impossible to determine a specific equation. Suggestions include that the curve may resemble a square root function or a parabola, but emphasize that three points are needed for accurate fitting, while only two are provided. Log-Log graphs are mentioned as a potential method for power functions, although they come with reliability concerns. The conversation highlights the necessity of additional data points and clear definitions of the axes to make any meaningful analysis. The lack of detail in the original post is criticized, leading to the conclusion that speculation is futile without more context. The thread also references procedural guidelines for posting homework-related questions in the appropriate forum.
ikihi
Messages
81
Reaction score
2
Rules Violation - member warned about restarting a closed thread
The concentration is the Y axis, and the values are the x axis. What is the equation for finding a target value on a curve between set of points?
curve.png
 
Physics news on Phys.org
That completely depends on the curve. Since you have not provided any more information than ”curve”, nobody can say.
 
ikihi said:
The concentration is the Y axis, and the values are the x axis. What is the equation for finding a target value on a curve between set of points?
That looks a bit like a square root function.
Swap the x and y axes, and it becomes a parabola.
It takes three known points to fit a parabola, but you only have two.
The best you can do with two points is a straight line.

Log-Log graphs are good for power functions. Maybe if you plot Log(x) against Log(y) to get a straight line, it would make interpolation easier, but still unreliable. That assumes there is no data less than or equal to zero on the x or y axis.
 
ikihi said:
The concentration is the Y axis, and the values are the x axis. What is the equation for finding a target value on a curve between set of points?
View attachment 335714
I have not read other responses yet and have not picked at this one yet, but the curve drawn appears like part of a circle. Can you work that way with your example?

Also, the description for your graph is incomplete. WHAT is the x-axis? What are those "values" supposed to mean?
 
ikihi
We cannot be sure what points we see accented on your graph. What are the ordered pair of those points accented in the big red dots?

edit: If we try to estimate to read your two points they may be (6.9 , 0.0093) and (4.8, 0.0041) .

If we guess that you have attempted to fit your scale numberings to the points, as off as they appear, these might be (4.8, 0.0040) and (7.0, 0.0080).
What ARE the two given points?
 
Last edited:
I changed my mind. I do not like the idea of fitting those only two points to a circle. Better for some square root function or logarithmic function. Still we no know your actual given points.
 
To be honest, neither the square root function norbthe circle seem like good firs to me. This entire discussion just accentuates what I already said in #2. There is way too little information in the OP to make anything but guesswork.
 
Orodruin said:
There is way too little information in the OP to make anything but guesswork.
Concentration suggests chemistry, which suggests adding exponential decay to the list of possible functions.

Like a good mystery, we need a couple of more data points, and units for the axes.
 
  • Like
Likes Vanadium 50
Baluncore said:
Concentration suggests chemistry, which suggests adding exponential decay to the list of possible functions.

Like a good mystery, we need a couple of more data points, and units for the axes.
Did you also note the scales of the x and y axes? My point is not that it is a good mystery, my point is that it the mystery is not well defined, making any speculation meaningless.
 
  • #10
Orodruin said:
Did you also note the scales of the x and y axes? My point is not that it is a good mystery, my point is that it the mystery is not well defined, making any speculation meaningless.
That's right. And we have not been informed better since @ikihi posted.
 
  • #11
Thread closed.
The OP started this thread after an earlier thread was deleted by another mentor. Homework and homework-type questions must be posted in the relevant subforum of the Homework Help section.
 

Similar threads

Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
0
Views
776
Replies
0
Views
298
Replies
0
Views
310
Replies
17
Views
2K
Back
Top