How Do You Balance Complex Chemical Equations in Ionic and Neutral Forms?

Click For Summary
SUMMARY

This discussion focuses on balancing complex chemical equations in both ionic and neutral forms, specifically for enargite leaching by sodium bisulfide and the oxidation of As2S5. The balanced equations provided include Cu3AsS4 + 3/2HS- = 3/2Cu2S + AsS43- for the first reaction and As2S5 + 8H2O + 10O2 = 2H3AsO4 + 5H2SO4 for the second. Key insights include the necessity of using H+ instead of ferric ions for neutral forms and the importance of balancing hydrogen and oxygen in basic solutions.

PREREQUISITES
  • Understanding of redox reactions and half-reaction methods.
  • Familiarity with balancing chemical equations in both ionic and neutral forms.
  • Knowledge of basic aqueous chemistry, including the role of H+ and OH- ions.
  • Experience with sulfide and arsenic compounds in chemical reactions.
NEXT STEPS
  • Study the principles of redox reactions and how to identify oxidizing and reducing agents.
  • Learn about balancing complex chemical equations using half-reaction methods.
  • Research the properties and reactions of thioarsenate and chalcocite in chemical processes.
  • Explore the role of water and hydroxide ions in balancing reactions in basic solutions.
USEFUL FOR

Chemistry students, chemical engineers, and professionals involved in metallurgical processes or environmental chemistry, particularly those working with arsenic and sulfide compounds.

1question
Messages
66
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



Write the balanced chemical reactions in ionic and neutral forms for:
i) Enargite leaching by sodium bisulfide in basic solution to form chalcocite and thioarsenate.
ii) Oxygen pressure oxidation of As2S5 in acid solution to form scorodite. Assume all sulfide sulfur forms sulfate. (Assume that ferric ion is present in solution).

Homework Equations


N/A

The Attempt at a Solution


i) Cu3AsS4 + HS- = Cu2S + AsS43-
Balancing:
Cu3AsS4 + HS- = 3/2Cu2S + AsS43-
Cu3AsS4 + HS- = 3/2Cu2S + AsS43- +H+
Cu3AsS4 + HS- +e-= 3/2Cu2S + AsS43- +H+

? I cannot seem to balance the last equation properly. I do know that the e- present in the equation means that there should be 2 half reactions, not one as above, but cannot figure those out either.

ii) As2S5+O2 = AsO43-+SO42-

Left side:
As2S5 = AsO43-+SO42-
As2S5 = 2AsO43-+5SO42-
As2S5+28H2O= 2AsO43-+5SO42-
As2S5+28H2O= 2AsO43-+5SO42-+56H+
As2S5+28H2O= 2AsO43-+5SO42-+56H++40e-

Right side:
O2 = ?
O2 = 2H2O
O2 + 4H+= 2H2O
O2 + 4H++4e-= 2H2O

Add together (and cancel out e-):
As2S5+28H2O= 2AsO43-+5SO42-+56H++40e-
10*(O2 + 4H++4e-= 2H2O)

Ionic Form ===> As2S5+8H2O+10O2 = 2AsO43-+5SO42-+16H+

It is balanced (I checked).

But, I get into trouble when I try to get the neutral form. Nothing on the right requires ferric (the cation I use to put all aq terms into neutral form), thus there is an imbalance of iron. Also, how do I deal with the 2H2O that appears as part of scorodite? Do I just assume that it has become part of the solution?

EDIT: Figured out 1)ii) Use H+ (and NOT ferric, Fe3+) as the cation to turn products into neutral compounds (and thus the entire reaction into neutral form).
i.e. As2S5+8H2O+10O2 = 2H3AsO4+5H2SO4
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
1question said:
i) Enargite leaching by sodium bisulfide in basic solution to form chalcocite and thioarsenate.

In basic solution means you should use water and OH- to balance hydrogen and oxygen. I don't see them in your equation.

Have you tried to decide what is getting oxidized and what is getting reduced?
 
I solved it:

Cu3AsS4 + 3/2HS- = 3/2Cu2S + AsS43-

I can't believe I didn't see that earlier. Thanks for the reply!

(Why can't I edit my post after a given amount of time? It would be nice to be able to grab the formatted stuff from there and change it to suit my current needs...)
 
1question said:
Cu3AsS4 + 3/2HS- = 3/2Cu2S + AsS43-

And where is the hydrogen on the right?

(Why can't I edit my post after a given amount of time? It would be nice to be able to grab the formatted stuff from there and change it to suit my current needs...)

I am afraid we had to do so because some people abuse the editing system. Locking the post means you can't edit the post once caught on posting nonsense.
 
@Borek Yes, the 3/2H+ on the right exists, I just didn't put it on here, sorry.

Ah, I see. Thanks.
 
What about balancing charge? -3/2 on the left, -3 on the right.
 

Similar threads

Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
17
Views
14K
Replies
5
Views
7K
  • · Replies 16 ·
Replies
16
Views
6K
Replies
2
Views
13K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
8K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
4K
Replies
5
Views
9K