How Do You Calculate Vector Operations for Angled Displacements?

Click For Summary
The discussion focuses on calculating vector operations for two displacement vectors, A and B, both with a magnitude of 3.00 m, where vector B is vertical on the y-axis and vector A forms a 30-degree angle with the positive x-axis. Participants clarify the correct approach to find the resultant vectors A+B, A-B, B-A, and A-2B, emphasizing the importance of accurately determining the x and y components. Key corrections include using 0 for the x component of vector B and ensuring proper calculations for angles based on the signs of the components. The conversation highlights the need for careful attention to detail in vector addition and subtraction to arrive at the correct magnitudes and directions.
chocolatelover
Messages
238
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Each of the displacement vectors A and B have a magnitude of 3.00 m. Vector B is vertical and is on the y axis, vector A forms a 30 degree angle to the positive x axis. Report all angles counterclockwise from the positve x axis. Find A+B, A-B, B-A, A-2B
This is similar to what the diagram looks like:
http://id.mind.net/~zona/mstm/physics/mechanics/vectors/components/vectorComponents.html


Homework Equations


magnitude=square root(Ax+Bx)^2+(Ay+By)^2
theta=tan-1(Ay+By/Ax+Bx)


The Attempt at a Solution



1. A+B
magnitude=square root (3cos30+3cos90)^2+(3sin30+3sin90)^2
=2.7

theta=tan-1(3sin30+3sin90)/(3cos30+3cos90)=69.4

2. A-B
magnitude=square root (3cos30+3cos90)^2+-(3sin30+3sin90)^2=square root (-13.5) This then goes to 3.67, right?
theta=tan-1(3sin30+-3sin90)/(3cos30+-3cos90)=19.05

3. B-A
theta=tan-1(sin90-3sin30)/(3cos30-3cos90)=74.4

4. A-2B
magnitude=square root(3cos30+3cos90)^2+-(2(3sin30+3sin90)^2=5.8
theta=tan-1(3sin30-2(3sin30+3sin90)/(3cos30+-2(3cos30+3cos90)

I would really appreciate if someone could help me with these 4 parts. I've been working on this for two days and I don't understand it. I don't see what I'm doing wrong.

Thank you very much
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
There are a couple of things going on here, one is I'm not quite sure how you're getting the answers you're getting.

First let's simplify things a bit. Vector B is vertical and on the y axis, therefore there is no x component, so you should just use 0 when referring to the x component of B. Also, you can just use 1 as the sin90, so the y component of B is just 3.

And you have A split correctly, the x = 3cos30, the y = 3sin30.

So, for A+B you have:
x component (3cos30 + 0) = 2.6
y component (3sin30 + 3) = 1.5 +3 = 4.5

So the magnitude of A+B =\sqrt{2.6^2 + 4.5^2} = \sqrt{27.01} = 5.2

Redo the problem and see if you get the same answers, then recalculate the angle.

For A-B, you need to be careful what you subtract from what. It should be:

x component (3cos30 - 0) = 2.6
y component (3sin30 - 3) = 1.5 - 3 = -1.5

From here you can recalculate the magnitude and angle. Once again, be careful where you put the angle as the x is positive, but the y is negative.
 
Thank you very much

Does this look correct? Aren't the sin angles 90°?

direction of a+b=tan-1(2.6/4.5)=30.02
180-30.02=150 Do I need to subtract it from 180 or 360?

magnitude of a-b=square root of (2.6)^2+(-1.5)^2=3

direction of a-b=tan-1(2.6/-1.5)=-60.02
180-60.02=240.02

b-a
x component=0-3cos30=-2.6
y component=3-3sin30=1.5

magnitude=square root ((-2.6)^2+(1.5)^2)=9.01

direction=tan-1(-2.6/1.5)=-60.1
180-60.1=120.0

a-2b

x component=3cos30-2(0)=2.6
y component=3sin30-2(3)=-4.5

magnitude=square root of (2.6^2+-4.5^2)=5.2
direction=tan-1(2.6/-4.5)=-30.02
180-30.02=149.98

Thank you
 
chocolatelover said:
Thank you very much
Does this look correct? Aren't the sin angles 90°?
Not sure what you mean by this. The sin 90° = 1, so 3sin90 = 3*1 = 3

direction of a+b=tan-1(2.6/4.5)=30.02
180-30.02=150 Do I need to subtract it from 180 or 360?

Be careful, the x value is 2.6, the y value is 4.5, and tan is y/x (not x/y as you have it).
So, your angle isn't right. As to what to subtract it from, look at where it would be based on the signs of the x and y. Both are positive, so the angle is in the first quadrant, no need to subtract it from anything.

magnitude of a-b=square root of (2.6)^2+(-1.5)^2=3

direction of a-b=tan-1(2.6/-1.5)=-60.02
180-60.02=240.02

The magnitude of a-b is correct, re-do the angle as above. As to where it's located, the x is positive, the y is negative, so where would the angle be?

b-a
x component=0-3cos30=-2.6
y component=3-3sin30=1.5

magnitude=square root ((-2.6)^2+(1.5)^2)=9.01

direction=tan-1(-2.6/1.5)=-60.1
180-60.1=120.0

Check your math for the magnitude. Then recalculate your angle

a-2b

x component=3cos30-2(0)=2.6
y component=3sin30-2(3)=-4.5

magnitude=square root of (2.6^2+-4.5^2)=5.2
direction=tan-1(2.6/-4.5)=-30.02
180-30.02=149.98
The magnitude looks good. Redo the angle.
You seem to be understanding it pretty well, If I were making these mistakes, and believe me I have, it would be because I was going to fast, and not being deliberate with the calculations. Since you're just using two vectors to do all the calculations, you can do the original calculations at the top, and label them such as:
Ax = 3cos30 = 2.6
Ay = 3sin30 = 1.5

etc., then just plug in the values you need to each equation.
 
Thank you very much

"As to where it's located, the x is positive, the y is negative, so where would the angle be?"

It would be in the third quadrant, right? So, I just need to subtract it from 180, right? If it were in the third or fourth quadrant, I would need to subtract it from 360, right?

thank you
 
Last edited:
The book claims the answer is that all the magnitudes are the same because "the gravitational force on the penguin is the same". I'm having trouble understanding this. I thought the buoyant force was equal to the weight of the fluid displaced. Weight depends on mass which depends on density. Therefore, due to the differing densities the buoyant force will be different in each case? Is this incorrect?

Similar threads

  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
4K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
10
Views
3K
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
4K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
4K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
4K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
8K