How Does the Definition of Work Affect the First Law of Thermodynamics Equation?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion highlights the importance of accurately defining the direction of energy transfer in the context of work done on a system, specifically a gas. It emphasizes that the interpretation of the first law of thermodynamics can vary based on how work (W) is defined in different textbooks, leading to equations that either add or subtract W. The change in internal energy (ΔU) is consistently represented as being influenced by both heat (Q) and work (W). Clarification is sought on which equation represents work done on the gas, with the consensus that ΔU = Q + W applies when W is defined as work done on the gas. Understanding these definitions is crucial for correctly applying the first law of thermodynamics.
Nick tringali
Messages
71
Reaction score
13
Homework Statement
I picked choice A but the Answer is choice B. The book literally states that when work is done on the system work is negative. I get that when it’s Adiabatic the equation simplifies to U=-W making it U=-(-W). Is this like a trick question? Why would the book tell me that when work is done on the system work is negative then also ask a question and state it’s actually positive. Hope this question makes sense.
Relevant Equations
Delta U= Q-W
91901605-3D5B-4E5B-B6A6-5D80033CA8A7.jpeg
 

Attachments

  • 6A793973-F975-4ADD-A579-B0DDA21F8C55.jpeg
    6A793973-F975-4ADD-A579-B0DDA21F8C55.jpeg
    52.2 KB · Views: 126
Physics news on Phys.org
Hi @Nick tringali.

You have to be very careful when thinking about the direction of energy-transfer when work is done (on something by something else).

Your textbook link says "... W is the work done by the system" [my underlining].
But the question is about "the work done on the gas" [my underlining; and of course 'the gas' is 'the system' here].
 
  • Like
Likes Nick tringali and Chestermiller
Yes, one needs to be careful about the preposition and be careful about who does the work and on whom work is done. It doesn't help that the first law appears as ##\Delta U=Q+W## in some textbooks and as ##\Delta U=Q-W## in others. Both are correct depending on the definition of ##W## in the textbook. As usual, ##\Delta U## is the change in internal energy and ##Q## is the heat that enters the gas.

To Nick tringali: Can you tell in which equation ##W## stands for "work done on the gas" and why? If so, then you understand what is going on here.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes Nick tringali
kuruman said:
Yes, one needs to be careful about the preposition and be careful about who does the work and on whom work is done. It doesn't help that the first law appears as ##\Delta U=Q+W## in some textbooks and as ##\Delta U=Q-W## in others. Both are correct depending on the definition of ##W## in the textbook. As usual, ##\Delta## is the change in internal energy and ##Q## is the heat that enters the gas.

To Nick tringali: Can you tell in which equation ##W## stands for "work done on the gas" and why? If so, then you understand what is going on here.
I would say that U= Q+W equation is where W stands for work done on the gas. When work is done on the gas it increases the internal energy so +W being work done on the gas would make sense . Right?
 
Thread 'Voltmeter readings for this circuit with switches'
TL;DR Summary: I would like to know the voltmeter readings on the two resistors separately in the picture in the following cases , When one of the keys is closed When both of them are opened (Knowing that the battery has negligible internal resistance) My thoughts for the first case , one of them must be 12 volt while the other is 0 The second case we'll I think both voltmeter readings should be 12 volt since they are both parallel to the battery and they involve the key within what the...
Thread 'Correct statement about a reservoir with an outlet pipe'
The answer to this question is statements (ii) and (iv) are correct. (i) This is FALSE because the speed of water in the tap is greater than speed at the water surface (ii) I don't even understand this statement. What does the "seal" part have to do with water flowing out? Won't the water still flow out through the tap until the tank is empty whether the reservoir is sealed or not? (iii) In my opinion, this statement would be correct. Increasing the gravitational potential energy of the...
Back
Top