How Does x in Equation 6.24 Become a(1-cosӨ)?

4 replies · 4K views · last reply
Hamza Abbasi
Messages
47
Reaction score
4

Homework Statement


This is the solution of Brachistochrone .

Textbook figure 6-3 showing a curve from point (x1, y1) down to (x2, y2) with force F acting downward, followed by equations 6.21 to 6.24 for the brachistochrone solution.

Diagram of a cycloid curve in a vertical coordinate frame: a dashed circle of radius a rolls along a horizontal line, tracing an arch from (x1, y1) to (x2, y2) through point P(x, y), with the angle theta marked and labels a, 2a, and pi a on the axes.


Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution


I am very confused that how the x in equation(6.24) get its value a(1-cosӨ) ? What is the technique behind this solution of x?
 
Attachments
  • Printed textbook page with a small sketch of a cycloid arch from theta = 0 to theta = pi, followed by numbered equations (1) to (5) giving the parametric form x = a(1 + cos theta), y = a(theta + sin theta) and the brachistochrone travel time integral.
    upload_2015-9-26_19-40-17.png
    64.3 KB · Views: 855
  • Printed derivation of the brachistochrone time integral: parametric cycloid equations x = a(1 + cos θ), y = a(θ + sin θ), velocity v = sqrt(2g(x - x1)), and the time integral t written in terms of θ, ending with a standard-form integral in z = sin(θ/2).
    upload_2015-9-26_19-44-33.png
    55.1 KB · Views: 778
  • Typeset equations numbered (7) and (8): the integral of dx over the square root of a squared minus x squared equals arcsine of x over a, and t equals pi times the square root of a over g. Text reads 'Evaluating, we find' and 'Thus, the time of transit from (x1, y1) to the minimum point does not depend on the position of the starting point.'
    upload_2015-9-26_19-45-3.png
    11.2 KB · Views: 681
It is just a clever substitution that replaces x. How to find that:
- in theory: "oh, it is completely obvious that this substitution will lead to a nice solution!"
- in practice: "let's try several approaches until one of them works"
 
Why only a(1-cosӨ ? What is the theory behind this substitution?
 
There is no deeper theory. It is a clever definition of Ө. You can see that it works nicely later.

You could also choose x=Ө2 + 3 cos(Ө) but that wouldn't help.
 
Hamza Abbasi said:
Why only a(1-cosӨ ? What is the theory behind this substitution?
To motivate the substitution (6.24), first make the substitution x = au in (6.23). Then complete the square in the denominator. From your experience with integration, you should then see what might be another good substitution to further simplify the integral.