Classical How is the book "Structure and Interpretation of Classical Mechanics"?

Click For Summary
The discussion centers around the book "Structure and Interpretation of Classical Mechanics" by Jack Wisdom and Gerald Jay Sussman, which is noted for its connection between physics and computer programming. Participants express curiosity about the book's value for learning classical mechanics, particularly for those with a background in physics. While the book is published by MIT Press and is considered well-reviewed, opinions vary on its accessibility, especially due to its focus on numerical computations and non-standard notations. Some participants highlight the importance of considering the author's background in computer science when evaluating the book's approach to physics. The text is available online, which adds to its appeal for those interested in exploring it further. Overall, there is a sense of cautious optimism about the book's potential as a resource, despite its specialized focus.
CGandC
Messages
326
Reaction score
34
I learned some computer science basics from the book SICP ( Structure and Interpretation of Computer Programs, Authors: Gerald Jay Sussman, Hal Abelson, Julie Sussman ) and I've witnessed a book about mechanics from the same author called Structure and Interpretation of Classical Mechanics, authors: Jack Wisdom, Gerald Jay Sussman.
How is it as a book that teaches classical mechanics ( I have experience in physics but that was long time ago )? is it worthwhile investing the time?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
I can only assume that you looked it up on Amazon. Just because a book is not famous (talked about here or on StackExchange) doesn't mean it can't be a gem waiting to be found. This is under MIT Press and I'm pretty sure it was well reviewed by the corpus of the prestigious school. The price is high, maybe a used copy somewhere can be made available for at least 1/2 a price.
 
  • Like
Likes PhDeezNutz and vanhees71
The book seems to be adjusted to those who are interested in numerical computations. Not my cup of tea.
 
I like how the book seems to relate physics to computer programs/numerical computations. The only downside is that some of the notations in the book are non-standard but that shouldn't be a problem. I think I'll order a copy once I'll have time to immerse myself into it. Thanks!
 
Gerry Sussman is a professor of computer science, so what you say is not surprising. In general, I would consider physics texts written by non-physicists at best as intended for a narrow and specialized audience.
 
This thread only works as a summary from the original source: List of STEM Masterworks in Physics, Mechanics, Electrodynamics... The original thread got very long and somewhat hard to read so I have compiled the recommendations from that thread in an online (Google Drive) spreadsheet. SUMMARY Permits are granted so you can make comments on the spreadsheet but I'll initially be the only one capable of edition. This is to avoid the possibility of someone deleting everything either by mistake...
Largely what the title says. I'm a retired chemical engineer, but for my own re-education, I'd like to review my college physics courses. Those were more than 50 years ago, and a portion has slipped away from lack of need/use. So...how about recommendations for general (say, 200 or 300 level) physics textbooks? It would really be handy if such a book/books were available as free PDFs (yeah, I know...I'm cheap). Thanks very much.

Similar threads

Replies
6
Views
3K
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
12
Views
6K
Replies
11
Views
6K
Replies
15
Views
3K
Replies
13
Views
11K
Replies
7
Views
15K