How Long Does it Take for a Motorcycle to Overtake a Car?

5 replies · 2K views · last reply
rtareen
Messages
162
Reaction score
32
Homework Statement
The motorcycle first takes the lead because its (constant) acceleration am = 8.40 m/s2 is greater than the car’s (constant) acceleration ac = 5.60 m/s2, but it soon loses to the car because it reaches its greatest speed vm = 58.8 m/s before the car reaches its greatest speed vc = 106 m/s. How long does the car take to reach the motorcycle?
Relevant Equations
ac = 5.6m/s2
am = 8.40m/s2
vcmax = 106m/s
vmmax = 58.8 m/s
Handwritten physics solution on lined paper: car acceleration 5.60 m/s^2 with max speed 106 m/s, motorcycle acceleration 8.40 m/s^2 with max speed 58.8 m/s, times t1 = 18.9 s and t2 = 7.0 s, followed by position equations and a quadratic solved for t.


Here is my attempt at the solution but I got the wrong answer. The right answer is t=16.6s. I know from the book (this is an example problem) that the motorcycle reaches its max speed at t=7.0s. But I don’t know where I made the mistake that is causing me to get the wrong answer afterwords.
 
Your error lies in how you calculate the motorcycle position.
Handwritten derivation setting x_c = x_m, with the motorcycle equation v_m0 t + a_m t^2 and the car term x_m0 circled in red, then the expanded quadratic 2.8t^2 + 3t^2 + 137.2 = 98.6t + 205.8 simplified to 2.8t^2 - 19.6t - 68.6 = 0.

You're covering the time between 0 s and 7.0 seconds twice, since your xmo already covered that once.
 
gneill said:
Your error lies in how you calculate the motorcycle position.
View attachment 254545
You're covering the time between 0 s and 7.0 seconds twice, since your xmo already covered that once.

I don’t see why that’s a mistake. At t=7.0s the equation for the motorcycles position changes. It no longer has an acceleration, just a constant velocity. xmo is the starting point for this new position function.
 
rtareen said:
xmo is the starting point for this new position function.
The way it is written means that the ##v \times t## term assumes a starting time of ##t = 0##. That is not the case if it's contribution should only "kick in" at ##t = 7 sec##.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: PeroK
rtareen said:
I don’t see why that’s a mistake. At t=7.0s the equation for the motorcycles position changes. It no longer has an acceleration, just a constant velocity. xmo is the starting point for this new position function.

It seems that your answer of ##9.6s## is the time starting from when the motorcycle reaches its maximum speed (after ##7s##). The answer of ##16.6s## is the time from when both vehicles start. I.e. your answer plus the ##7s##.

PS after ##9.6s## the speed of the car is ##53.76 m/s##, so it's not yet reached the speed of the motorcycle.
 
Last edited:
PeroK said:
It seems that your answer of ##9.6s## is the time starting from when the motorcycle reaches its maximum speed (after ##7s##). The answer of ##16.6s## is the time from when both vehicles start. I.e. your answer plus the ##7s##.

PS after ##9.6s## the speed of the car is ##53.76 m/s##, so it's not yet reached the speed of the motorcycle.

So I just need to add 7s to the answer I got and I’ll have the correct answer. I can see why now. Thanks!